Wall round Bethlehem an ugly barrier to Palestinian autonomy

An Israeli military gate in the separation wall that surrounds Bethlehem.

Bethlehem, the birthplace of Christ, is synonymous with Christmas, but it is menaced by the concrete divide that encroaches on Palestine territory, says Eoin O’Driscoll.

FOR two millennia, the town of Bethlehem has held a special place in the hearts of Christians. To celebrate the birth of Christ in this town, just a few kilometres south of the famed city of Jerusalem, families have set up cribs in their homes and children have been performing nativity plays in schools and churches.

Through these re-enactments of the nativity, Bethlehem has become synonymous with the sleepy, celebratory time spent with family and friends and hope for the new year that characterise Christmas.

Sadly, this festive image is far from the reality of Bethlehem’s 25,000 inhabitants. Bethlehem is rich in history and culture. It sits with verdant hills and valleys on one side, and the sprawling city of Jerusalem on the other. In normal circumstances, Bethlehem would be thriving, but circumstances are not normal. It is a city squeezed by political circumstance.

The most visually striking feature of the Israeli occupation, which has constricted life in Bethlehem since 1967, is the separation barrier.

The barrier looms over Bethlehem as an imposing, 3m concrete wall. Aside from dominating the landscape, the barrier separates Bethlehem from much of the land owned by its people, and, crucially, it also severs it from Jerusalem.

Since 2002, the Israeli government has been constructing the barrier — a network of fences, walls, and other structures — ostensibly to safeguard the security of the Israeli people by physically separating them from the Palestinians.

Wall round Bethlehem an ugly barrier to Palestinian autonomy

A 2004 advisory ruling of the International Court of Justice clearly stated that the barrier’s route — more than 90% of it winding through Palestinian territory — breaches international law. Its construction has sparked condemnation from the EU; the US government; the United Nations, and a wide range of international organisations, including the International Committee of the Red Cross.

And yet, construction continues.

On the outskirts of Bethlehem sits the picturesque Cremisan Valley, home to monastic orders since the 7th century. Presently, both a Salesian convent and monastery are sited in the valley.

The monastery also hosts one of the region’s few vineyards, producing Cremisan Cellars wines from the valley’s own grapes.

For the past decade, these religious communities have been fighting to prevent the expansion of the separation barrier through their lands and through the lands of the valley’s Palestinian communities. Despite a 2015 Israeli Supreme Court ruling calling for the barrier’s rerouting, construction continues.

The barrier was developed in response to the second intifada, in 2005. Ostensibly, it protects Israelis from the Palestinians in the West Bank. Israeli statistics suggest that the barrier has reduced the number of attacks on Israelis, but it also serves many other, less laudable purposes. When the International Court of Justice ruled, in 2005, that the planned route of the separation barrier was in breach of international law, the primary issue it cited was its planned construction on Palestinian land. More than 90% of the barrier will run through lands envisioned (under the Oslo process, and negotiated between the Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority in the early 1990s) as a future, autonomous Palestinian homeland.

Wall round Bethlehem an ugly barrier to Palestinian autonomy

At the Cremisan Valley, the barrier runs over 3km on the Palestinian side of the Green Line, the 1948 Arab-Israeli war’s armistice line, regarded by the international community as Israel’s border.

The barrier not only cuts off the Palestinian people living in the area from the land they grew up in, but cements Israeli control over land deep inside Palestinian territory. It establishes, in concrete, Israeli control over the land and physically incorporates Palestinian land into the Israeli state.

As Christians around the world celebrate the nativity, the land in which Christ was born suffers. The town of Jesus’s birth is being continually squeezed by Israeli encroachment and by the imposition of the winding separation barrier through its land.

There is, sadly, no shortage of misery in the world this Christmas. But Bethlehem cannot afford to be ignored any longer. As the separation barrier expands, Bethlehem’s territory shrinks and shrinks. Its continued ability to exist as a viable town reduces every year. Without concerted international action, Palestine will disappear and with it the once sleepy town of Bethlehem.

Eoin O’Driscoll is an Irish peace observer working in the West Bank with advocacy group EAPPI

More on this topic

No end in sight to resolving problems of the Middle EastNo end in sight to resolving problems of the Middle East

We are nothing if we do not act on the promptings of our conscienceWe are nothing if we do not act on the promptings of our conscience

Palestinian gets 18-year jail term for killing British studentPalestinian gets 18-year jail term for killing British student

Ireland will recognise Palestine if impasse with Israel not broken, Coveney saysIreland will recognise Palestine if impasse with Israel not broken, Coveney says


I’d always promised myself a day off school when Gay Bryne died.Secret diary of an Irish teacher: I’ve been thinking about my students, wondering who their ‘Gay Byrne’ will be

In an industry where women battle ageism and sexism, Meryl Streep has managed to decide her own destiny – and roles, writes Suzanne HarringtonJeepers Streepers: Hollywood royalty, all hail queen Meryl

'Ask Audrey' has been the newspaper's hysterical agony aunt “for ages, like”.Ask Audrey: Guten tag. Vot the f**k is the story with your cycle lanes?

Daphne Wright’s major new exhibition at the Crawford addresses such subjects as ageing and consumerism, writes Colette SheridanFinding inspiration in domestic situations

More From The Irish Examiner