VOLKSWAGEN EMISSIONS: The question is, who else did the same?

The exhaust of a Volkswagen car photographed at the Car Show in Frankfurt, Germany

Banking and the car sector have tried to do what they can get away with, not what is right, says Mark Gilbert

There’s never just one cockroach. We learned that from the market-rigging scandals in recent years.

Be it the London Interbank Offered Rates (Libor), currencies, metals, oil or… (you get the picture), it turned out that every bank and broker that touched every market benchmark left grubby fingerprints of fraud, collusion and deceit.

So the revelation that Volkswagen cheated for years on tests measuring how much damage its diesel engines do to the environment raises a mammoth question: Who else did the same?

The parallels between the shameful behaviour in finance and the backdrop to executives at Volkswagen deciding it was OK to programme 11 million cars with deceitful software are compelling.

In both industries, the regulatory structure left large areas of territory open to manipulation. In finance, self-regulation produced flagrant and widespread abuse; in cars, enforcement of diesel emissions rules was lax and testing was easily gamed. And in both industries, that’s created an attitude of “what can we get away with?” rather than “what’s the right way to behave?”

VOLKSWAGEN EMISSIONS: The question is, who else did the same?

While the market was shocked at VW’s flagrant deception, just as it was the Libor scandal, in both cases manipulation was an open secret for industry cognoscenti. There is an echo here of the “broken windows” thesis that argues buildings where a single pane is left broken are more vulnerable to further vandalism than those were the breakage is repaired.

If the overseers of an industry turn a blind eye to some kinds of misbehaviour, they’re opening the door to a culture that regards rules and regulations as obstacles to be dodged rather than standards to be observed.

So while the US Environmental Protection Agency and its peers around the world can probably be excused for not spotting the VW dodge — the idea of software that can switch engine emissions behaviour when it detects that there’s a test underway is the stuff of an Austin Powers movie, if not a Bond flick — the entire regime of testing seems riddled with the kinds of flaws that should have been fixed years ago.

Korea’s Hyundai paid $100 million (€90m) last year, as well as foregoing $200m in emissions credits and spending $50m on preventive measures, to settle charges that it exaggerated both fuel efficiency and carbon emissions to the EPA.

A June 2013 article by Steve Abrams for the website Road and Track explained how electronic management systems can be tailored to game the EPA’s tests.

 Martin Winterkorn chairman of Volkswagen which programmed 11 million cars with software made to deceive when testing for emissions
Martin Winterkorn chairman of Volkswagen which programmed 11 million cars with software made to deceive when testing for emissions

Engineers know exactly how their vehicles will be evaluated. They know exactly how fast the car will go, and how long and how quickly it will accelerate or decelerate.

When engineers programme the control logic, they can monitor parameters that correspond to the test cycles, such as speed, acceleration and pedal position, and select the gear ratios, throttle positions and air-fuel ratios that will deliver the minimum possible fuel consumption.

Even before the Volkswagen bombshell, there was plenty of evidence that carmakers aren’t exactly adherents to Google’s “Do No Evil” corporate pledge.

While logic suggests that reputational concerns, if not outright litigation risks, dictates high standards of probity, it took General Motors more than a decade to recall cars that had a faulty ignition switch that’s been blamed for at least 124 deaths, costing the company more than $1.5 bn in this month’s settlement.

It took a four-year criminal investigation before Toyota conceded last year that its accelerator pedals were jamming, leading to 10 million vehicles being recalled and a settlement worth $1.2bn.

VOLKSWAGEN EMISSIONS: The question is, who else did the same?

Arguably, what’s being uncovered in the car industry is even worse than the wrongdoing in finance. In the bank scandals, it’s only money. But, as US District Judge William Pauley said in March, when Toyota reached its deal with the authorities, “corporate fraud can kill” when safety is involved. As Wired magazine points out, the reason for having auto emissions regulations in the first place is because nitrogen oxides hurt health. Exposure to nitrogen oxide and ozone is linked to increased asthma attacks, respiratory illnesses and in some cases premature death. Ozone also worsens existing cardiovascular and lung disease.

Volkswagen shares were already in a funk; Friday’s revelations have wiped a third off the value of its shares, leaving the company’s value at less than half of where it was in mid-March.

That drop of €23bn between Friday and Tuesday reflects expectations for how much the company might pay in fines. But given that the banking industry has paid $10bn just for rigging currency rates — deplorable and dishonest, but not actually a health hazard — maybe investors in car company shares should brace themselves not only for more bad news, but for fines that might make the banking scandals look like small beer.

More on this topic

Proceedings under way in Volkswagen diesel emissions scandal lawsuitProceedings under way in Volkswagen diesel emissions scandal lawsuit

Volkswagen working with Amazon to improve worldwide factory efficiencyVolkswagen working with Amazon to improve worldwide factory efficiency

Volkswagen sued in US over diesel cheatingVolkswagen sued in US over diesel cheating

Volkswagen wins appeal against diesel car owner: German courtVolkswagen wins appeal against diesel car owner: German court


It never ceases to stop me in my tracks when I hear my husband intone to our children one of the oft overused phrases from my stockpile of, “Can you just not?” categories.Lindsay Woods: If my children feel I’m doing it wrong then I must be doing it right

In honour of our Made in Munster special edition, Joe McNamee creates a four-course meal showcasing the best produce from the province. And there’s a lot to celebrate.The Menu's Made in Munster six course dinner - One from each county

More From The Irish Examiner