Injuries to Munchin’s trio see Pres clash abandoned

Never in the history of Irish schools rugby has there been such a scene as witnessed in Musgrave Park yesterday when the Clayton Hotels Munster Junior Cup tie between Presentation Brothers College Cork and St Munchin’s College was hit by three serious injuries and ultimately abandoned after just nine minutes of play.

Following an hour-long delay for two separate incidents, two Munchin’s players — Dylan Higgins and Craig Carew — were removed separately by ambulance to Cork University Hospital.

St Munchin’s were then instructed to retake the field by the match referee Paudie Sheehan but declined to do so.

Pres went back onto the field and lined up as instructed to form a scrum which had been called just before the last play. But with no opposition to contest the set-piece, the match was abandoned, with Pres leading 5-0.

The abandonment appeared to mean Pres would advance to the semi-finals. However, a spokesperson for the Munster Branch said the issue would have to be raised at age-grade and schools committee levels in the next 24 hours to decide what to do next.

Distressed St Munchin’s coach Pat Cross said his distraught players were in no position to play on, having seen two of their colleagues suffer frightening injuries.

“These injuries are unprecedented. There is no way our young players were in any condition to continue,” said Cross.

The game was first delayed for 37 minutes when flanker Higgins was floored after a collision with one of his colleagues in an attempted tackle. St Munchin’s full-back Dean Callinan also had to leave the field with a head injury, although he managed to make his own exit rather than on a stretcher.

Minutes after the resumption, Carew fell heavily and suffered the same fate and was also taken to hospital.

There was already talk of the match being abandoned and St Munchin’s made such a request in the circumstances. However, the decision was taken to proceed, but it was clear the young St Munchin’s players had no desire for this game to continue.

Pres coach Barry Howell sympathised with the Limerick school and insisted that they had been instructed to take to the field to complete the game, irrespective of what St Munchin’s had decided.

“I’ve never come across anything like it. I suppose it’s not an ideal way to advance to a semi-final. But we’ll have to abide by whatever the proper protocol is.”

Pres had powered into the lead just over a minute into the game when winger Conor Morey stormed over in the right corner after a good lineout take from Jack Kelleher, a driving maul and a quick execution of a move out wide.

Morey was unlucky not to grab a second a couple of minutes later only to be held up inches out; a subsequent forward drive ended when Pres knocked on with the line at their mercy.

That action soon concluded and it remains to be seen whether the game will be refixed.

St Munchin’s appear likely to appeal any decision to award Pres the game.

However, the main concern right now is the welfare of their players.


D French, C Morey, M Hand, D O’Sullivan, J Holden, A Walsh, J O’Leary, D McSweeney, B Kingston, C Morris, J Kelleher, M Giltinan, M O’Leary, R Foley (captain), A Kendellan.


D Devlin, M Hayes, T Gough, D O’Halloran, J Forde, J Keohane, D Hurley, C Doyle, T Buckley, T O’Sullivan.

St Munchin’s:

D Callinan, J Campbell, K McInerney, C Carew, J Butler, J Ryan, D O’Callaghan, N Walsh, S Airey, N McNamara, C Duggan, L Neilan, D Higgins, E O’Brienm C Nesbitt (captain).


J Clohessy, S Mason, C Finn, G Kirwan, S Nestor, D Slattery, C O’Brien-Comerford, D Long, M Lawler, J Keane.


P Sheehan (M.A.R).

Related Articles

Johann van Graan will be ‘surprised’ if Conor Murray is named in Irish squad

'We might be a bit thin over the next few weeks': Johann van Graan counting the cost of Munster injuries

Keith Earls could be back for Munster next weekend

Gloucester boss questions red card as Johann van Graan describes injuries to Munster trio as 'serious'

Breaking Stories

Conor McGregor breaks down ‘fair and square’ defeat to Khabib Nurmagomedov

Usain Bolt offer requires ‘third party contribution’ – Central Coast Mariners

No laughing matter as comedian Brendan O’Carroll speaks from the heart

Tony Kelly hails the men who stepped up for Ballyea

Breaking Stories

Whole world in their hands: Icons design globes in aid of GOAL

Nerina Pallot dancing to her own tune

Little-known plan could save you inheritance tax

Murder they wrote: Authors prepare for Ireland's first crime writing festival

More From The Irish Examiner