Brawn rejects ‘cheating’ charge

ROSS BRAWN yesterday insisted his team are innovators rather than cheats as he endured a grilling in the diffuser row hearing.

Brawn was pointedly described as “a person of supreme arrogance” as Formula One’s newest team boss came under fire at one stage during the International Court of Appeal hearing in Paris.

But the Brawn GP head stood his ground as personal slurs and the weight of the FIA regulations were thrown at him at motor sport’s headquarters overlooking the Place de la Concorde.

FIA technical director Charlie Whiting was also forced to endure a 75-minute cross examination as he and the organisation were accused of “getting it wrong, and not understanding the point”.

The brickbats were hurled during a marathon sitting that lasted over eight hours as Ferrari, Renault, Red Bull and BMW Sauber squared up to Brawn GP, Toyota and Williams in front of five ICA judges.

At the heart of the matter is the conceptual design of the diffuser – an aerodynamic body part that aids performance – towards the rear of the cars belonging to the three teams in the firing line. Reference was made to the fact that it was a new approach, and therefore had to be ratified by the FIA before being applied to the car.

But a defiant Brawn said: “We didn’t consider this to be a radical new design. It was an innovative approach of an existing idea, and Formula One is all about innovative design.”

On a more personal level, Brawn was twice asked to retract remarks made in his personal submissions in which he criticised Rory Byrne and Adrian Newey. Byrne is Ferrari’s former chief designer, a long-standing colleague of Brawn as they won five drivers’ and six constructors’ titles together earlier this decade, and who now works as a consultant to the Maranello-based team. Brawn had claimed the appellants’ case was “a vindictive response... that amounted to a fishing expedition”.

Asked to withdraw his comment as it was claimed it served as a slight against Byrne, Brawn said: “I have the highest regard for Mr Byrne. But we are on opposite sides in this argument, so I stand by my statements.”

In his written submission, Brawn also accused Red Bull’s technical guru Newey of “being unethical and of bringing the sport into disrespute”.

Leading the debate was Ferrari’s legal representative Nigel Tozzi QC, who successfully argued the team’s case over ‘spygate’ and at last year’s inquest into Lewis Hamilton’s chicane-cutting move at the Belgian Grand Prix.

At one stage, Tozzi noted of Brawn that “only a person of supreme arrogance would think he is right when so many of his esteemed colleagues would disagree”.

Tozzi, aside from trying to stoke up Brawn, also attempted to tie Whiting up in knots with regard to the regulations.

He argued that “the position of the FIA is totally baffling ... we urge you to save the FIA from itself”.

However, it could be argued Tozzi baffled the judges – one of whom, Malta’s Guido de Marco, occasionally nodded off – with his lengthy inquests into the wording of the rules and what constitutes a hole.

As Paul Harris, representing Brawn GP, noted: “What we have seen is a sideshow, irrelevancies, or to coin an English phrase, a red herring.”

The tables were seemingly turned, though, when Brawn made reference to a number of cars – including Ferraris – from recent years that included various slits in other parts of the bodywork which could be construed as contrary to the regulations.

The judges will now deliberate on a ruling made by the stewards at the Australian Grand Prix that the Brawn GP, Toyota and Williams cars are indeed legal. A verdict is due today, although their full findings are not due until later this week or early next.


Put provenance first this season and make 'Made in Munster' the label to be seen in. With outstanding craftmanship and commitment to quality, these homegrown designers are making Munster-made fashion wish list worthy around the world. Shopping local has never looked so good. Carolyn Moore reports.Made in Munster: Shopping local has never looked this good.

Karen Cunneen-Bilbow Owner, Fabricate IrelandMade in Munster: ‘I turned my hobby into a business’

An invitation is extended to all to pay a visit to Bride View Cottage, writes Charlie WilkinsSeasonal cheer will spread early in Co Cork as an invitation is extended to all to visit Bride View Cottage

After a week of Fortnite Chapter 2, we think it’s fair to say Epic lived up to their name with the game’s ‘re-launch’.GameTech: Happy after a week of Fortnite Chapter 2

More From The Irish Examiner