Solicitor: ‘Review should not just be limited to cervical testing’

A solicitor representing another woman who was diagnosed with cancer after receiving an incorrect smear test result believes the scandal is far broader than just cervical screenings.

Vicky Phelan was diagnosed with cervical cancer after she received a false negative CervicalCheck result. Picture: Collins Courts

James McSweeney has called for any review or investigation to take in other screenings including breastcheck as he knows from experience and other cases that the “entire system is failing women”.

He is now representing another woman who is taking a case and who similar to Vicky Phelan, was diagnosed with cervical cancer after she received a false negative CervicalCheck result.

The case being taken by Mr McSweeney was lodged with the High Court in 2016 and is still ongoing.

Mr McSweeney told the Irish Examiner he has taken a number of cases for women who have been diagnosed with breast cancer, which the HSE has fought “tooth and nail” against.

He added that in many, many instances, confidentiality clauses are sought.

“If the one thing that comes out of this is that light on the manner in which cases are fought, that would be a good outcome,” he said.

“One woman we represent has now been told that her cancer may be terminal. Her case will be fully defended in my experience.”

Mr McSweeney said: “I suppose my concern would be that any review isn’t limited to cervical cancer screening and testing. I think the investigation needs to be more broad than is being reported.

“We represent a number of women who are affected by delayed diagnosis.

“However, it is really important not to get too focused on one aspect of an entire system that is failing women.

“A fatality as a result of a failure or delay in the breast cancer screening and treatment is no less disgraceful than the cases in the news today.

He highlighted cases surrounding delays in testing for breast cancer which would fall into the category of ‘urgent referrals’ as defined by the HSE but were not seen until significantly after the deadlines.

He said that delays have had “significant negative consequences” for the women involved.

“Several women that we have represented have had to undergo radical surgery and aggressive treatment that would not have been needed if they had been seen within the HSE guideline time or if there had been a proper follow up,” the solicitor said.


Related Articles

Smear tests inquiry cost set to exceed €200k amid delays

Medical Council president urged to clarify 'inaccurate information' CervicalCheck comment

Medical Council warns on ‘inaccurate’ info

Medical Council president's comments on CervicalCheck welcome says Health Minister

More in this Section

Paralysedman was attacked as he slept in camper


Breaking Stories

Cork pair overcome barriers to pick up Leaving Cert results

Inquest calls for rollout of roadcheck devices after jogger killed in hit-and-run by disqualified driver

'The least he can do is apologise,' says clerical sex abuse victim ahead of Papal visit

Hospital interns asked to perform duties they aren't qualified for, report finds

Lifestyle

New father’s life ‘changed forever’ after he was run over by surgeon

More From The Irish Examiner