A new Tesco supermarket in Ballincollig, Cork, is now set to be built by O’Flynn Construction, after the High Court this week rejected a challenge to its planning by the owners of a nearby SuperValu.
With approval for a new 70,000 sq ft store just west of the main Ballincollig Town Centre complex, which is anchored by Dunnes Stores, Tesco will now join rival traders such as Dunnes, SuperValu (two Ballincollig stores), Aldi (who also have two Ballincollig shops) and Lidl.
The judicial review to An Bord Pleanála’s July 2012 grant of planning to O’Flynn Construction for the new Tesco units was made by Tramore, Co Waterford-based Leefield Ltd, who own a Ballincollig SuperValu. They argued that the new supermarket would reduce the viability of existing retailers in Ballincollig Town Centre. And, they argued that the planning appeals body had failed to give adequate reasons why it had overruled its own planning inspector on the case, who had recommended rejecting the Tesco plan because of insufficient connectivity to the existing town centre, favouring car-borne shoppers, and encroachment on adjacent woodland. The new phase or addition to the Ballincollig Town Centre, on the former Murphy Barracks, includes parking for 330 cars.
The judicial review action was taken by Leefield Ltd against An Bord Pleanála, with Cork County Council, O’Flynn Construction (O’FC) and two other individuals as notice parties.
The value of the scheme has been put at €15m, and when planning was approved by Bord Pleanála in July, O’FC said it would take a year to build, and provide up to 150 construction jobs, with 200 full and part-time jobs when trading.
O’FC’s planning consultants McCutcheon Halley Walsh welcomed the High Court’s judgment in favour of Bord Pleanála’s grant of permission, noting “it pointed out that the inspector was primarily concerned with urban design and had rejected Leefield’s concerns with regard to location, scale and retail impact.”
Ballincollig Town Centre was developed at an overall cost of €500m.
© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved