Pledge to settle cancer cases ‘quickly’

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar

Women suing the State over inaccurate cervical cancer screening tests will not be dragged through the courts.

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar confirmed he has asked Attorney General Seamus Woulfe to settle cases “quickly” without legal action.

The Cabinet met yesterday and discussed the fallout from the Vicky Phelan case and the fact that of 208 women with cancer, three quarters were not told of a delayed diagnosis.

Ms Phelan was forced to go to court where her case was settled but this was after the Government was aware of her situation.

Facing Dáil questions, Mr Varadkar said that it would be months rather than years before an inquiry would finish its work into the cancer tests scandal.

He also ruled out, for the moment, a commission of inquiry looking into the failed communications and inaccurate tests controversy as it would take too long and involve lawyers.

But Labour’s Brendan Howlin warned that an investigation led by the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa), as is proposed, may have limited powers, including the inability to make adverse findings. Nonetheless, Mr Varadkar believes Hiqa will get answers about the scandal.

“We believe that is the best and quickest way to do it. We need answers in months, not years, and it has the skills and the statutory powers to do so,” he said.

Mr Varadkar also told the Dáil that, as a former minister for health over two years ago, he was not aware of patient safety issues around cervical cancer checks or any audits of such.

During leaders’ questions, he said: “I was never informed of any patient safety concern or potential scandal relating to CervicalCheck and certainly not the outcome of any audit such as this. I have asked officials in the Department to check that for me in case my recollection is incorrect.”

Mr Varadkar also stood over his health chief, Tony O’Brien. The HSE director general is under fire over the cancer scandal, with calls for him to quit.

But he stopped short of expressing confidence in Mr O’Brien, who is set to leave his role later this year.

“Everyone, even Mr Tony O’Brien, deserves a fair hearing before being condemned. We need to assess whether that decision was wrong. It may turn out not to be wrong.”

The Taoiseach said he was “angry” about the scandal and was “determined” to get to the bottom of it.

Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin told the Taoiseach: “It seems to me that the fact there was a deliberate policy decision that, in the event of women having died, the information was merely to be noted on a file and the family denied that information, which is their entitlement in terms of knowing the circumstances surrounding their mother’s death, is truly shocking.”

It has also emerged that legislation to make it mandatory for clinicians to inform patients of test results or health updates will go to Government next week.

Mr Varadkar said: “It will be in the patient safety bill. The minister expects to bring a memorandum to Cabinet next week.”

More on this topic

CervicalCheck IT glitch is 'unacceptable and shouldn’t have happened'CervicalCheck IT glitch is 'unacceptable and shouldn’t have happened'

52 more positive for HPV in test scandal52 more positive for HPV in test scandal

HSE reveals 50 women whose results were delayed by IT glitch tested positive for HPV virusHSE reveals 50 women whose results were delayed by IT glitch tested positive for HPV virus

Update: Head of CervicalCheck Rapid Review begins investigation into latest scandalUpdate: Head of CervicalCheck Rapid Review begins investigation into latest scandal


As YO! switches out its statement conveyor belt at its new, upcoming London concept restaurant, Ella Walker visits Tokyo – the brand’s inspiration.Eating your way round Tokyo is a lesson in tradition and technology

Least Like The Other at the Galway International Arts Festival provides an intense musical take on the life of Rosemary Kennedy, writes Cathy Desmond New operatic work focuses on JFK's sister Rosemary

It’s 40 years since the tragic drowning of Booker Prize winner JG Farrell in West Cork, writes Richard Fitzpatrick.Bantry recalls a great writer 40 years on

Could it be that we’re actually kind of getting something akin to a summer?The Skin Nerd: Summer skin woes - heat rash and back spots

More From The Irish Examiner