Nurses who carry out smear tests on behalf of CervicalCheck have received no formal guidance from the national screening programme about how to handle the current crisis.

The Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation (INMO), whose annual delegate conference begins in Cork today, said members are in the invidious position of trying to encourage women to go for screening, while at the same time unable to reassure them the programme works.

“This situation is really difficult for our members, who have worked very hard to increase the numbers going for screening,” said general secretary Phil Ní Sheaghdha.

“They are carrying out an intimate procedure in doctors’ surgeries around the country every day. They are trying to reassure the women, make them comfortable, but what has happened now is outside the control of those performing the screening and they are absolutely devastated.”

She said the INMO has written to the HSE’s national director of quality assurance, Patrick Lynch, to ask for guidance vis-à-vis what reassurance to give women concerned about the accuracy of smear test results.

Mr Lynch is chairing a HSE serious incident management team, investigating the circumstances that led to 43-year-old Vicky Phelan not being told for three years that a previous screen had failed to detect cancer warning signs. Ms Phelan now has terminal cancer and it has since emerged that 17 women who took part in the screening programme, and were initially given incorrect test results, have died.

Ms Ní Sheaghdha said they wanted Mr Lynch to pass on information that would allow them to reassure women they need not worry about faulty results.

“We presume they have sought that information from the US labs, who are analysing the smears, and we need that information passed onto our practice nurses,” she said.

The INMO represents about 1,500 practice nurses around the country, many of whom conduct smear tests. They also represent nurses working in Well Woman Clinics, as well as midwives.

Ms Ní Sheaghdha said members are currently looking at patients’ clinical histories, their family history, and screening history when trying to advise women about the need for repeat smears.

More on this topic

CervicalCheck IT glitch is 'unacceptable and shouldn’t have happened'CervicalCheck IT glitch is 'unacceptable and shouldn’t have happened'

52 more positive for HPV in test scandal52 more positive for HPV in test scandal

HSE reveals 50 women whose results were delayed by IT glitch tested positive for HPV virusHSE reveals 50 women whose results were delayed by IT glitch tested positive for HPV virus

Update: Head of CervicalCheck Rapid Review begins investigation into latest scandalUpdate: Head of CervicalCheck Rapid Review begins investigation into latest scandal


As YO! switches out its statement conveyor belt at its new, upcoming London concept restaurant, Ella Walker visits Tokyo – the brand’s inspiration.Eating your way round Tokyo is a lesson in tradition and technology

Least Like The Other at the Galway International Arts Festival provides an intense musical take on the life of Rosemary Kennedy, writes Cathy Desmond New operatic work focuses on JFK's sister Rosemary

It’s 40 years since the tragic drowning of Booker Prize winner JG Farrell in West Cork, writes Richard Fitzpatrick.Bantry recalls a great writer 40 years on

Could it be that we’re actually kind of getting something akin to a summer?The Skin Nerd: Summer skin woes - heat rash and back spots

More From The Irish Examiner