National security decision ignored human rights plea

The Government’s decision to exclude national security from the remit of the forthcoming Policing Authority was made despite calls from the State’s human rights body for it to be included.

The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission told the Government that the authority should oversee “national security policy and practice”.

It said independent oversight of this area was a “requirement” under the European Convention of Human Rights and lessened the risk of the State being found in violation of it.

However, the Government rejected this advice and decided this secretive area of Garda work would not be overseen by the authority, due to be established by the end of the year.

The Government’s decision was reflected in advertisements for the job of Garda commissioner last September and authority chairperson this month.

Justice Minister Frances Fitzgerald last month said there was “no question of divesting security from the State”.

Replying to questions from the Irish Examiner as to the reason for this, a spokeswoman for the minister said: “The minister has indicated that the Garda commissioner will be responsible to the Policing Authority in relation to policing matters and to the minister in respect of security matters. This takes account of the fact that the preservation of national security is a primary function of the Government.”

Although national security has no clear definition, it includes countering terrorism, espionage and sabotage, and the protection of parliamentary democracy and the institutions of the State.

The IHREC said: “Issues of national security policing should be overseen by an independent body.”

More on this topic

Government told to stop looking at gardaí as 'some kind of financial imposition'Government told to stop looking at gardaí as 'some kind of financial imposition'

Garda Representative Association loses court case on paid sick leaveGarda Representative Association loses court case on paid sick leave

Fresh bid to trace killers of Detective Garda Adrian DonohoeFresh bid to trace killers of Detective Garda Adrian Donohoe

Inspectorate calls for single Garda control centreInspectorate calls for single Garda control centre


Much has been said about the perils of being stuck in the house 24/7, like family pets interrupting your important conference calls, your partner leaving their dirty dishes everywhere and the lack of respite from the kids.Silver lining: Seven enforced money-saving habits you might want to continue after lockdown

Put you and your loved ones' pop-culture knowledge to the test with Arts Editor Des O'Driscoll's three fiendishly fun quiz rounds.Scene and Heard: the Arts Ed's family entertainment quiz

A passion for heritage and the discovery of some nifty new software has resulted in an Irish architect putting colour on thousands of old photographs, writes Marjorie BrennanBringing the past to life

Richard Hogan, family psychotherapist, addresses a reader's question about life during lockdownHolding on: how to help your child through the crisis

More From The Irish Examiner