Nanny’s lawyer says case made US system look bad

The lawyer who represented Aisling Brady McCarthy, the Irish nanny who spent 27 months in prison before charges against her of murdering a baby in Boston were dropped, has admitted the case made the US justice system look bad.

The 37-year-old Cavan native was accused of killing one-year old Rehma Sabir who she was minding in January 2013. The prosecution had alleged Rehma suffered injuries after being shaken, but two weeks ago, the charges were dropped when an earlier decision that the baby’s cause of death was homicide was reversed.

It was put to her lawyer Melinda Thompson on RTÉ’s Prime Time programme last night, that the US justice system did not come very well out of the saga. Ms Thompson replied: “It does not look good for the justice system. I could not explain what was going on [to Aisling and her family] because I had never seen anything like this. I was a prosecutor for a long time. I could not believe this was happening... things we should have been getting very easily (from the prosecution), we were having to go court to get.”

Ms Brady McCarthy’s sister, who accompanied her back to Ireland at the start of the month, said bringing her sister home was very emotional.

“There were a lot of tears a lot of joy, a lot of calls, so much support, people have been just wonderful,” Sharon Grehan said. “Landing in Shannon was just surreal, the people at Shannon were great, they just got us out, at that point you were just so overwhelmed. There was not time to speak with media, we really just wanted to get her home.”

Ms Grehan, who lives in Boston, said her sister is currently still in Ireland with her husband Don and their extended families. She also said that Aisling may have more to say on her side of the story at a later date.

“There are a lot more facts that haven’t been reported on,” she said. “Aisling is doing amazingly well, despite what she’s been through. She’s been through hell. What happened to her was terrible. It should never have happened.”

More on this topic

Sister describes Aisling Brady McCarthy's ordeal in US on charge of murdering babySister describes Aisling Brady McCarthy's ordeal in US on charge of murdering baby

Ashling Brady McCarthy: 'What was done to me was scandalous'Ashling Brady McCarthy: 'What was done to me was scandalous'

Aisling Brady McCarthy arrives back in Ireland after ticket delayAisling Brady McCarthy arrives back in Ireland after ticket delay

Aisling Brady McCarthy arrested by US immigrationAisling Brady McCarthy arrested by US immigration


Timothy Grady is in Bantry this week to host a concert, and read from his classic book about the Irish in London, writes Don O'Mahony.Giving voice to the emigrant experience

A care home builds links with kids, writes Helen O’Callaghan.Inside out: Children learn what it's like to live with dementia.

When you think of someone who is “into skincare”, you probably imagine someone in a face mask.The Skin Nerd: Why face masks aren’t as important as you’d think

With the evenings closing in and a welcome chill in the air, it’s time to embrace the new season now.Make the Transition: Turn over a new leaf this fall

More From The Irish Examiner