Criticism of child abuse mandatory reporting plans

Proposed laws on mandatory reporting of suspected child abuse must oblige people to inform both the gardaí and the HSE, according to an international child protection organisation.

One Child International criticised a recent report by the Oireachtas Justice Committee which recommended people should be able to report to the HSE, rather than the gardaí.

The Oireachtas committee came to its decision after holding a series of public consultations with organisations working in the area, many of which expressed concern over aspects of the proposed new law, including an obligation to report cases to both gardaí and HSE.

Some of the groups expressed concern over the impact on victims who might be reluctant to talk to the groups if they knew the organisations were legally compelled to tell gardaí.

The groups said such concern was particularly relevant in cases of family abuse where people might not want gardaí involved.

At the launch of the report last January, committee chairman David Stanton said mandatory reporting of child sex abuse was not a “black and white” issue.

He said it was “extremely complex and difficult” to draft legislation in this area. The report was sent to Justice Minister Alan Shatter prior to publication of the Criminal Justice (Withholding Information on Crimes Against Children and Vulnerable Adults) Bill 2011.

In a letter to Mr Stanton, Evin M Daly of One Child International said the legislation should not be complex and should in fact be “relatively simple”.

He said: “Mandatory reporting is designed to protect our children from abuse; all four types of abuse, not just sexual abuse.

“The abuse of children is a criminal offence. As such it must be reported to — and investigated by — the gardaí and the HSE child protection unit. The HSE has no law enforcement powers. There is therefore no ‘lack of clarity’ as to whom it should be reported.”

He said the majority of abuse had always happened in the home: “No intervention in child abuse in a home can be made without the involvement of the gardaí who will be required to protect an investigator on an abuse call.”

Mr Daly said a proposed “reasonable excuse” clause which would exempt a person from possible criminal sanction if they failed to report a case of suspected abuse, was a “red herring”.


A parent coach says parents are often the best judge of how to care for their baby – and explains how they can learn to have faith in their intuition.Ask an expert: How can I know what’s best for my baby?

We take a trip down memory lane and check out what happened on this day in years gone by by looking back at some Irish Examiner front pages and highlighting other events which went down in history across the world.August 23, 2019: A look back at what happened on this day in years gone by

RP O’Donnell says it is hard to find anywhere better than Boston to show your family a great time as he returns to a city he used to call homeA family friendly holiday guide to get the best out of beautiful Boston

Leslie Williams sampled the seafood at Cavistons in Dublin.Restaurant Review: Cavistons - Charming staff, the freshest fish, solid cooking

More From The Irish Examiner