Taoiseach Enda Kenny’s hopes and British Prime Minister Theresa May’s promise to maintain a seamless and friction free Irish border is unenforceable, it has been claimed.
Talk of a frictionless border after Brexit are just nice words, according to a customs expert appearing yesterday before the House of Commons Northern Ireland Affairs Committee yesterday.
Michael Lux, the former head of the European Commission’s customs procedures, for the first time set out the practical implications of Brexit. Independent unionist MP Sylvia Hermon asked Mr Lux if Mrs May could achieve “a seamless border”.
He replied: “If you define seamless as no border controls then the answer is no, at least for Ireland because it is obliged to apply EU law.
“If the UK is outside the EU it can do whatever it likes,” he said.
However, he said “there will be a lot of fraud going on” if the UK does not implement some form of border measures.
He told MPs: “If Northern Ireland is not part of the EU customs territory then there is a customs border. I think what [Mrs May] meant was to keep the burden as small as possible.”
Earlier this month, the prime minister said Brexit will mean the UK leaves the European Customs Union.
There were gasps from some MPs when Mr Lux gave another example of problems that would arise post-Brexit.
“If a Northern Ireland person has a walk and takes its dog over the border there are specific rules on what kind of document you have to have,” he told the committee.
“You need a specific document. If you bring a horse riding you also need a specific document.”
Ms Hermon responded: “We have a significant number of farms straddling the border. There will be lots of dogs on farms. I cannot imagine a form has to be filled out when a dog runs from the Republic of Ireland to Northern Ireland.
"This is just unenforceable,” she said. Mr Lux said he had suggested the EU allows Northern Ireland to remain in the customs union during a “transitional phase”.
He believes this could be for a period of up to 10 years.
A Taoiseach’s spokesman told the Irish Examiner that the two governments are determined to ensure a seamless border is in place post Brexit. This was again made clear following the recent meeting between the Taoiseach and Ms May, he said.
Meanwhile, Special status for Northern Ireland after Brexit would be the wrong approach amid fears such a deal could undermine its place in the United Kingdom, Northern Ireland Secretary James Brokenshire has said.
Mr Brokenshire said special status would be “the wrong approach”.
© Irish Examiner Ltd. All rights reserved