All’s fair in love and war in Carrigstown as Fair City marks 4,000 episodes

Fair City has seen it all in the past 27 years: Sex, violence, domestic abuse, forbidden love on the fictional streets of Carrigstown.

The Dublin-set soap, which this week marked 4,000 episodes, brought us the first gay kiss on Irish television (technically, an almost kiss, though the impact was no less profound).

When likely lad Bella Doyle was diagnosed with cancer, doctors reported a surge in men seeking prostate examinations. A battered husband storyline was so skilfully wrought that Coronation Street pinched it and made it its own.

“As the Berlin Wall was coming down we were creating our own cultural history in Ireland,” says Finola Doyle O’Neill, broadcast historian at UCC School of History. “Fair City felt like a microcosm of the culture. After Bella Doyle’s prostate cancer there was an uptake in people going to the doctor. In 1996, we almost had the first gay kiss [on Irish television] between Eoghan and Liam.”

All’s fair in love and war in Carrigstown as Fair City marks 4,000 episodes

When Fair City debuted in September 1989, the country was becoming increasingly urbanised. Yet this reality was rarely reflected on screen. The two iconic Irish soaps — The Riordans and Glenroe – were unapologetically, almost polemically, rural. Irish television had failed to hold a mirror up to our lives or wrestle meaningfully with social issues.

“Fair City was the second urban soap opera,” says Dr Doyle O’Neill. “Tolka Row went from 1964 to 1968. While admired, it was very staged — it was Abbey actors on a closed set. It didn’t engage with social realism. Being plot-driven, there wasn’t any relevance to everyday life.”

Fair City was not an immediate hit. Original show-runner Tony Holland had been hired from EastEnders and was not always sensitive to the differences between Ireland and Britain.

“It wasn’t popular because he [Holland] wasn’t able to engage with Irish audiences,” says Dr Doyle O’Neill. “He didn’t realise Irish people were blunt. British people were far more reserved.”

All’s fair in love and war in Carrigstown as Fair City marks 4,000 episodes

“The scripts were all in a different idiom,” said Niall Matthews, the executive producer brought in to replace Holland told the New York Times, which, in 1997, expressed disbelief at an Irish soap tackling gay storylines and gangland violence.

“They were written in Londonese rather than Dublinese. It didn’t work With an Irish writing team parachuted in, the show found its voice. One early controversy was the gay kiss that wasn’t (the characters were interrupted as they were about to embrace). And yet the producers denied smuggling social commentary onto the airwaves. The only ambition was to serve the story, they insisted.

“We don’t hang out a banner saying we are dealing with rape and murder as issues.

“One of our characters gets raped and the story is how it affects her, her family, and the community. We are not doing issue-driven programs. We use issues to illuminate the characters more than to illuminate the issues.”

Today, Fair City’s distinct Irishness remains both a strength and an weakness. It will never be mistaken for EastEnders or Coronation Street, let alone a US version.

All’s fair in love and war in Carrigstown as Fair City marks 4,000 episodes

In a crowded market, this is an invaluable selling point. However, it also means Fair City is doomed to never expand beyond an Irish audience. This is in contrast to racier shows such as Love/Hate and Red Rock, which have been sold abroad — with Red Rock, in particular, thriving on BBC One’s lunch-hour slot.

“Fair City hasn’t been syndicated. Maybe that is because it is ‘too Irish’,” says Dr Doyle O’Neill.

As to the future… the soap must continue to interweave compelling plotlines and social commentary, say observers. Too much sensationalism or playing to the shorter attention span of millennials and it risks losing its unique tone.

“Fair City is getting a good run for its money from Red Rock, which is taking away younger viewers,” says Dr Doyle O’Neill. “With lesbian kissing and bisexual characters, you have to be careful you don’t throw the whole kitchen sink in. Older viewers may feel it is becoming too much.”

Fair City’s most shocking moments

  • Father Malachy gets hot under the collar (1999): With the Church reeling from scandals, Malachy quitting the priesthood to be with Kay could have been ripped from the morning headlines. Their marriage hit a rocky patch when, discovering their baby would be severely disabled, Kay had an abortion.
  • Billy Meehan’s death (2001): Thuggish Meehan met his maker in brutal fashion after he copped a golf club to the head in an episode watched by nearly a million viewers. In classic soap opera fashion, the identity of the killer was kept as a cliff-hanger.
  • Heather and Floyd kiss (2008): Half-siblings Heather and Floyd had fought their natural attraction to one another — but when Floyd was given weeks to live, they set taboo to one side, to the disgruntlement of Heather’s husband.
  • Suzanne abuses Damien (2010): Male domestic abuse is rarely portrayed on screen and Suzanne hitting partner Damien with a snooker cue generated controversy.
  • Spar pitches its tent (2011): With a change to product placement regulations, Carrigstown had its first Spar in 2011. Depending on your stance, it either added to the veracity of the show or marked the point at which it sold its soul.


These are the nail hues to choose this season, says Katie Wright.Perfectly polished: 5 autumn/winter nail trends you’ll actually want to wear

This early 19th-century table is one of a number of Irish lots at Sotheby’s Style, Furniture and Ceramics sale in New York on Thursday (October 24).Irish lots poised to add bite to Big Apple sale

Something for all at Hegarty’s auction in Bandon, says Des O’SullivanSomething for all at Hegarty’s auction in Bandon

Des O’Sullivan gives a preview of the Irish selection on offer at two sales in DublinPreview of the Irish selection on offer at two sales in Dublin

More From The Irish Examiner