Oliver Moore: Charles sets model for rest to follow

Dr Charles Merfield, a leader for organic farmers all over the globe.

In light of the pesticide and herbicide restrictions being imposed on conventional horticulture and tillage, as well as the ongoing need to manage weeds on an organic farm, this column has spent the last number of weeks looking at different ways to weed without chemicals.

We’ve covered the context, some of the non-mechanical options and over a dozen mechanical weeding devices. 

The final week in the series examines one small and one big weeding machine. 

Many in the Irish organic sector will have fond memories of New Zealander Dr Charles Merfield, better known as Merf. Merf spent two years in Ireland and was a whirlwind of knowledge for the organic sector.

It was very obvious, very quickly, that he was playing senior hurling and everyone else at best intermediate.

Merf developed a four-wheel hoe, some of which he brought around to conferences and farm walks from time to time. 

According to his own website, this four wheel hoe “fills a gap among weeding machines being created for growers producing crops on the bed system, i.e., not on ridges, with cropping areas too large to hand hoe and too small to justify tractor mounted hoes.

“It can control both inter-row (between the crop row) and intra-row (in the crop row) weeds by a combination of horizontal knife blade ‘T’ hoes and ‘mini-ridger’ hoes.”

For just 90 New Zealand dollars, you can purchase the plans and make it yourself, by emailing him at physical.weeding@merfield.com.

Merf has also developed steam weeders, flame weeders, and false seed bed tillers, which you can find out more about on his site: www.physicalweeding.com.

For larger tillage plantations using tractors regularly, Swedish manufacturers JCS have developed the Combcut. It was developed by Swedish organic farmer Jonas Carlsson. 

There he farms 100 acres, growing heirloom grains and vegetables, along with forestry. He also has a farm shop on site. 

In Scandinavian tillage farms, creeping thistle is a major problem. 

The Combcut works by being able to differentiate between weeds and crops, in terms of the rigidity and thickness of the stems/stalks of both plants.

The machine combs through the crop but only cuts the weed. So a physical difference between the crop and the weed is required, in terms of thickness or branching pattern.

These knives are on adjustable steel beam, while the whole machine comes in either over 6.24m or 8.48m diameter models.

According to Joel Magnusson of Combcut “CombCut makes it possible to cut weeds down in unbranched crops like e.g. cereals, grassland and maize cutting coarser weeds like thistles, charlock, lambs’ quarters and many others. 

If the crop is branched, as for soy or some vegetables, it’s possible to use CombCut by cutting weeds growing above the crop canopy. Cut weeds will fall down and, depending on the weather, decompose rather quickly.”

So CombCut can also cut weeds above branched crops like rapeseed, soy or some coarse crops. 

He adds: “Of course the weeds should be cut before seeds got so mature that they will survive and mature when flowers/seed pods are cut.”

As with the System Camelon we featured last week, there are numerous videos where you can see the machine working in different fields with different crops.

For these go to www.justcommonsense.eu or their youtube channel “Just Common Sense AB”.

To conclude this series, it’s important to reiterate that full weed elimination is neither possible nor desirable in organics. To help with the crucial tasks for making weeds uncompetitive, there are other techniques and practices too, from mulching to rotations.

As I finish this article, and head off to bed, I’m a little stiff after another day spent in part hand weeding. 

I‘ll be getting up tomorrow morning to hand weed on the farm here in Cloughjordan, again. It has to be said, many of these machines do look very tempting indeed.


Kim Sheehan is an opera singer from Crosshaven, Co Cork, and is this year’s recipient of the Jane Anne Rothwell Award from Cork Midsummer Festival.A Question of Taste: Cork opera singer, Kim Sheehan

Developed in Ireland by Dublin-based indie gaming house Dreamfeel, If Found follows university graduate Kasio as she returns to Achill, Co Mayo, from the big city.'If Found': a story of belonging from the Irish videogame scene

B-Side the Leeside: Cork's Greatest Records - Giordaí Ua Laoghaire tells Don O’Mahony about the offbeat outfit who created some of the most innovative music on the Irish scene in the 1990sB-Side the Leeside: Nine Wassies from Bainne - A quirky slice of creativity

More time indoors is a chance to consider how we buy for our homes without being slaves to fleeting trends, writes Carol O’CallaghanMore time at home offers a chance to consider how we buy for our interiors

More From The Irish Examiner