Whistleblower's information 'gives grounds of suspicion Vote Leave campaign broke law' in Brexit campaign

Whistleblower's information 'gives grounds of suspicion Vote Leave campaign broke law' in Brexit campaign
Christopher Wylie.

Information provided by whistleblowers provides grounds to suspect that the UK's Vote Leave campaign broke Britain's electoral law during the 2016 EU referendum campaign, according to a legal opinion obtained by the men's lawyers.

And the opinion said there were "reasonable grounds" for the UK's Electoral Commission to investigate the possibility of a conspiracy involving two senior members of the Leave campaign now working as advisers to Theresa May in 10 Downing Street.

The 50-page opinion obtained by Bindman's solicitors, acting on behalf of Christopher Wylie and Shahmir Sanni, called for an "urgent investigation" to establish whether a prosecution could be brought over allegations the campaign broke spending limits.

The allegations have all been denied by Vote Leave and its former officials, who reject all accusations of wrongdoing.

Witness statements and documents provided by the whistleblowers "strongly suggest" that a donation of almost £680,000 made by the campaign to a youth Brexit group called BeLeave was actually used for

the benefit of Vote Leave, to pay data firm Aggregate IQ for targeted messaging services, said the legal opinion, prepared by barristers from Matrix Chambers.

Christopher Wylie.
Christopher Wylie.

If this cash was recorded as Vote Leave expenditure, it would take the campaign's spending over the £7m limit, establishing a "prima facie case" that electoral law has been breached.

There are "realistic prospects" that the group and official David Halsall might be convicted, said QCs Clare Montgomery and Helen Mountfield and barrister Ben Silverstone.

And they said there were "reasonable grounds" for the Electoral Commission to investigate whether any offences where committed "with the knowledge, assistance and agreement" of senior figures in Vote Leave, including Stephen Parkinson and Cleo Watson, who are now advisers to the British Prime Minister, as well as the campaign director Dominic Cummings.

"Given the very close working relationships at all material times between Vote Leave and BeLeave, the way in which Mr Parkinson and Ms Watson supervised the work of the young BeLeave volunteers and that Vote Leave and BeLeave staff worked closely together on a daily basis, in the same office, throughout the referendum campaign, it can be properly inferred that Mr Parkinson and Mr Watson must have known about BeLeave's campaign activity, of which the AIQ targeted messaging was a significant part," said the opinion.

"In these circumstances, there are certainly reasonable grounds for the Commission to use its powers... to investigate whether any election offences committed by Vote Leave and Mr Halsall were committed with the knowledge, assistance and agreement of other senior figures/officers in Vote Leave, including Mr Parkinson and Ms Watson."

Christopher Wylie.
Christopher Wylie.

Bindmans partner Tamsin Allen said the information upon which the legal opinion was based had been passed to the Electoral Commission, which did not have access to it at the time of its earlier inquiry into Vote Leave.

She said no communication had been obtained proving that Vote Leave ordered BeLeave to pass money to AIQ but there was a "strong inference" that this had happened.

Ms Allen said the solicitors were funded by anonymous donors to assist Mr Wylie at the time of his initial revelations regarding data collection by Cambridge Analytica, but this money had now run out.

"He was facing really serious personal and legal risk," she said. "I started working for him unpaid, then several donors were found.

"Given the risk to Chris and the risk that these people felt too, I have agreed to keep their names confidential and I will respect that confidentiality obligation.

"That money is now exhausted. Both I and counsel have done a significant amount of unpaid work and we are continuing to do so."

Cash was being raised via the crowdfunding site crowdjustice.com, she said.

Mr Wylie said he believed Mr Parkinson and Ms Watson should lose their jobs at Downing Street.

It was "absolutely outrageous" that a Number 10 official had passed on to a New York Times journalist a copy of a blog by Mr Cummings in which Mr Parkinson effectively outed Mr Sanni as gay, he said.

Ms Allen said Bindmans had successfully requested that references to Mr Sanni's sexuality should be removed from the blog and believed the issue had been "contained", only to find it had been sent out by the Downing Street official.

"At that point, it was clear to us that there was no containing that information anymore," she said.

"That email, to us, meant that he had effectively been outed in a statement from an official Downing Street email."

Mr Wylie said that if wrongdoing was proved, the referendum should be re-run.

"If you are caught doping in the Olympics, you get the medal taken away," he said.

"This is about the integrity of the democratic process and can we trust a result where it is highly likely that overspending happened.

"British democracy is about listening to the voice of the people, not how much money you can spend, so it's important that we enforce the law where overspending happened."

More on this topic

Remaining EU 27 are not united: The other Brexit (beach) partyRemaining EU 27 are not united: The other Brexit (beach) party

US trade deal ‘highly unlikely’ with Irish hard border, Boris Johnson warnedUS trade deal ‘highly unlikely’ with Irish hard border, Boris Johnson warned

Tánaiste: Ireland won’t be dragged out of EUTánaiste: Ireland won’t be dragged out of EU

Merkel sets 30-day deadline for Irish backstop alternativeMerkel sets 30-day deadline for Irish backstop alternative

More in this Section

Spacewalking astronauts add parking spot to space stationSpacewalking astronauts add parking spot to space station

UK Government facing calls to create ‘safe zones’ outside every UK abortion clinicUK Government facing calls to create ‘safe zones’ outside every UK abortion clinic

South African court restricts display of apartheid-era flagSouth African court restricts display of apartheid-era flag

Thousands sign up for Brexit party on Dutch beachThousands sign up for Brexit party on Dutch beach


Lifestyle

Triathlete Carolyn Hayes is flat out. Since October 2018, she’s literally been racing around the world.On the treble: Triathlete Carolyn Hayes goes flat out to win a place in the Olympics

Children starting or going back to school is a reminder of how we all need an energy boost when sitting at a desk for hours, no matter what our age.Energy fix: Top 8 snacks for children

A sommelier shares her top tips.The dos and don’ts of serving wine – you just might have been doing it all wrong

It’s that time of year again; the long summer days are numbered, summer’s lease is all too short as she takes her last few breaths.Learning Points: Top tips on coping with back to school stress for you and the kids

More From The Irish Examiner