Regulator brands Sky News MH17 report a 'significant lapse of judgment'

Regulator brands Sky News MH17 report a 'significant lapse of judgment'

A live report in which Sky News journalist Colin Brazier was seen picking through the belongings of victims of the MH17 air disaster in Ukraine amounted to a “significant lapse of judgment”, according to Ofcom.

The UK's broadcasting regulator said the report, screened in July following the apparent shooting down of the Malaysia Airlines jet, was “capable of causing considerable offence” and breached its programme code.

But it said it is to take no further action bearing in mind the need to make decisions in challenging circumstances and apologies which were later issued, and considered the matter had now been “resolved”.

During the live item during Sky News With Lorna Dunkley, shortly after noon on July 20, Brazier was seen crouched among some of the salvaged possessions and picking up items, telling viewers: “Here are, I think it’s a small girl’s bag by the look of things ... a set of keys ... toothbrush.”

He quickly returned them to a suitcase and said: “We shouldn’t really be doing this, I suppose really.”

It prompted 205 complaints to Ofcom from viewers who claimed his actions were offensive.

Sky said the reporting of such events meant difficult editorial decisions “need to be made at speed and with conviction”, but it acknowledged that it “fell short of the high standards” to which it aspired. Within hours the broadcaster and Brazier had issued their apologies.

Sky also reminded news teams to exercise sensitivity and pledged to update guidelines to journalists.

In a report published today, Ofcom said Brazier’s action were “capable of causing considerable offence” and said the “offence was not justified by the context”, breaching programme guidelines.

But it said editorial decisions for reporters were “particularly challenging” in those circumstances and noted the apologies which were made.

Ofcom’s report went on: “Despite the offence caused in this case, Ofcom considered that this brief but significant lapse of judgement by a news reporter should not prevent broadcast journalists from reporting live on sensitive and challenging news stories.”

An Ofcom spokesman said: “Ofcom has a responsibility to protect viewers from offensive content, including issues such as distress and the violation of human dignity.

“After careful consideration, and taking into account steps taken by the broadcaster after the incident, the investigation has been resolved.”

:: Ofcom is to take no further action after offensive language was broadcast during a live performance of a Monty Python comeback show from the O2 Arena in London as a result of human error in July. The regulator said the matter – for which TV channel Gold apologised – has been “resolved”.

More in this Section

France records 1,000 more Covid-19 deaths bringing death toll to 6,500France records 1,000 more Covid-19 deaths bringing death toll to 6,500

Member of British armed forces becomes first confirmed coronavirus case on FalklandsMember of British armed forces becomes first confirmed coronavirus case on Falklands

Keir Starmer elected as the next leader of the UK Labour PartyKeir Starmer elected as the next leader of the UK Labour Party

Competition for supplies sharpening as pandemic worsensCompetition for supplies sharpening as pandemic worsens


Lifestyle

This year has been particularly difficult and stressful, and I think that’s an even more important reason to make time for your health.Derval O'Rourke: Resistance is far from futile and necessary

Best-selling author Faith Hogan is keeping the faith during the lockdown, thanks to her Moy Valley haven in Ballina, Co Mayo.Shape I'm in: Keeping the Faith during lockdown

Are you and your family venturing into the room outside? Peter Dowdall has some useful advice.Now that the world’s on gardening leave, are you venturing into the room outside?

The virus crisis doesn’t have to dampen our enthusiasm for Easter treats, writes Roz CrowleyWe've got it cracked: Top 8 Easter eggs

More From The Irish Examiner