Poor planning and overcrowding blamed as third climber dies on Everest

Poor planning and overcrowding blamed as third climber dies on Everest

An Indian climber has died while being helped down Mount Everest, just days after two others died near the peak.

Two other Indian climbers are missing, with experts suggesting some of the tragedy could have been avoidable.

Poor planning and overcrowding on the world's tallest peak may have led to bottlenecks that kept people delayed at the highest reaches while waiting for the path to clear lower down, Ang Tshering of the Nepal Mountaineering Association said.

He said: "This was a man-made disaster that may have been minimised with better management of the teams.

"The last two disasters on Everest were caused by nature, but not this one."

Many had hoped this year's climbing season would bring success and restore confidence in the route, after deadly disasters cancelled climbing the previous two years.

But as hundreds of eager climbers, joined by local Sherpa guides and expedition experts, scrambled to take advantage of good weather to make it to the peak, reports of tragedy began trickling down the mountain.

First, a 35-year-old Dutch man, Eric Arnold, died on his way down from the peak from altitude sickness.

"Hours later, a 34-year-old Australian woman, Maria Strydom, died near the top, also after apparently suffering from altitude sickness.

On Monday, Subhash Paul of India was reported as the third death after succumbing to altitude sickness overnight as he was being helped down the mountain by Sherpa guides, said Wangchu Sherpa of the Trekking Camp Nepal agency in Kathmandu.

An Indian woman from, Sunita Hazra, was resting at a lower-altitude camp after becoming ill higher up.

But two other Indian climbers - Paresh Nath and Goutam Ghosh - have been missing since Saturday.

Dozens of other climbers have developed frostbite or become sick near the summit in recent days, including the Australian woman's husband, Robert Gropal, who was taken by helicopter to a hospital in Kathmandu on Monday for treatment.

Mr Tshering said the competition between expedition organisers has become so fierce that they are dropping their prices, which can lead to compromises in hiring equipment, oxygen tanks and experienced guides to help get climbers to the top.

He said: "Teams are hiring raw guides that have no knowledge of responding to situations of emergency."

Belgian climber Jelle Vegt, who reached the peak on May 13, said he made his attempt when there were fewer climbers on the narrow route snaking to the top, but that bad weather then forced many others to wait for a few days.

"A lot of people tried to go on the same weather window," the 30-year-old from Deldermond said after returning to Kathmandu.

Since Everest was first conquered by New Zealander Edmund Hillary and Sherpa Tenzing Norgay in 1953, more than 4,000 climbers have reached the 8,850-metre-high peak.

Nearly 400 of those climbers reached the summit since May 11. Nepal's government had issued permits this year to 289 climbers, each of whom paid 11,000 US dollars (£7,000) to the government, plus another 25,000-50,000 dollars (£17,000-£34,000) to an expedition company that provides guides, equipment and, often, bottled oxygen to use at high altitudes where the atmosphere is thin. The climbers are accompanied on the mountain by around 400 local Nepalese Sherpa guides.

Nepal and the Everest climbing community had been anxious for a successful season this year. The industry brings more than 3 million dollars (£2 million) from permit fees alone into the poor, Himalayan country each year, and thousands of locals depend on the climbing season for secondary work as porters, hotel keepers or cooks.

Last year, a devastating earthquake unleashed an avalanche that killed 19 people at Base Camp, effectively ending all attempts at the peak for 2015. A year earlier, a massive ice fall on a glacier that is part of the route to the top killed 16 and made the route impassable for the season.

Before that, the worst disaster had been caused by a fierce blizzard in 1996 that killed eight climbers and was memorialised by Jon Krakauer in the book Into Thin Air.

But while hundreds have died trying to reach the top of Everest due to avalanches, altitude sickness, exposure and other dangers, the use of bottled oxygen and better equipment had helped reduce the number of deaths each year.

Satellite communication equipment and better medical facilities have also helped prevent tragedy.

Yet, some criticise expedition companies for taking novice climbers without any mountaineering experience.

There are no regulations to require climbers to have any past experience before trying Everest.

More on this topic

Death of Séamus Lawless on Everest 'a freak accident'Death of Séamus Lawless on Everest 'a freak accident'

Everest queues: Limit numbersEverest queues: Limit numbers

Family pay tribute to ‘aspirational’ British climber who died on EverestFamily pay tribute to ‘aspirational’ British climber who died on Everest

Search for Everest climber Séamus Lawless has been called off Search for Everest climber Séamus Lawless has been called off

More in this Section

Cheers for Oscar-winning director Bong Joon-ho on his return to KoreaCheers for Oscar-winning director Bong Joon-ho on his return to Korea

More than 3,000 tested in UK for coronavirusMore than 3,000 tested in UK for coronavirus

Facial expressions do not reflect our innermost feelings, new research suggestsFacial expressions do not reflect our innermost feelings, new research suggests

White House hopeful Pete Buttigieg says he is proud of his husbandWhite House hopeful Pete Buttigieg says he is proud of his husband


AS Joaquin Phoenix rose to the podium to collect his Academy Award for Best Actor, ears were peeled as the actor made his speech about inequality and our disconnect with the natural world.Paul McLauchlan: Leading men lead the way on Oscars red carpet

The new season blood oranges have arrived, they’ve been trickling into the shops ever since Christmas — such joy. I long for their delightful fresh taste after the rich food of the festive season.Darina Allen: Blood Oranges have a delightfully fresh taste after the rich food of winter

She’s the Cork singer dubbed the next Kate Bush, shortlisted by Universal, the world’s biggest record label, as their artist to watch in 2020. This will be the year of Lyra, writes Ed PowerLyra: Meet the new Kate Bush - and she's from Cork

For relationships to endure, we need to be loving not just on Valentine’s Day but all year round, a Buddhist teacher tells Marjorie BrennanOpen hearts: The Buddhist approach to love and loving

More From The Irish Examiner