Moon and Mars not top priorities for Americans on space programme wishlist

Moon and Mars not top priorities for Americans on space programme wishlist

Americans prefer a space programme that focuses on potential asteroid impacts, scientific research and using robots to explore the cosmos over sending humans back to the moon or on to Mars, a new poll shows.

The poll by The Associated Press and the NORC Centre for Public Affairs Research, released today, one month before the 50th anniversary of the Apollo 11 moon landing, lists asteroid and comet monitoring as the number one desired objective for the US space programme.

About two-thirds of Americans call that very or extremely important, and about a combined nine in 10 call it at least moderately important.

Apollo astronaut Buzz Aldrin poses beside the replica Apollo 11 lunar excursion module Eagle at the Science Museum, London (Anthony Devlin/PA)
Apollo astronaut Buzz Aldrin poses beside the replica Apollo 11 lunar excursion module Eagle at the Science Museum, London (Anthony Devlin/PA)

The poll comes as the White House pushes to get astronauts back on the moon, but only about a quarter of Americans said moon or Mars exploration by astronauts should be among the space programme’s highest priorities.

About another third called each of those moderately important.

Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin, on July 20 1969, or July 21 Irish time, became the first humans to walk on another celestial body.

In all, 12 Nasa astronauts stepped on the moon.

Jan Dizard, 78, a retired environmental studies professor living in Chico, California, acknowledges there was more to learn on the moon and it would be “miraculous” to send astronauts to Mars.

But now is not the time, he stressed.

“There are all kinds of other things, not the least of which is climate change, that deserve our attention,” Mr Dizard said.

Mars, the red planet (Nasa/Esa/PA)
Mars, the red planet (Nasa/Esa/PA)

“This other stuff can wait.”

After asteroid and comet monitoring, scientific research to expand knowledge of Earth and the rest of the solar system and universe came next on the list of Americans’ space priorities, about six in 10 said that was very or extremely important.

Close to half said the same about sending robotic probes, rather than astronauts, to explore space, and about 4 in 10 said the same about continued funding of the International Space Station.

Searching for life on other planets came in fifth with 34% rating it at least very important, followed by 27% for human Mars expeditions and 23% for crewed moonshots.

In a dead heat for last place among the nine listed goals: setting up permanent human residences on other planets, with 21% ranking it as a very high priority, and establishing a US military presence in space with 19%. While other goals were considered at least moderately important by majorities of Americans, about half called a military presence and space colonies unimportant.

Toni Dewey, 71, a retired clerical worker in Wilmington, North Carolina, said space exploration should benefit life on Earth and the explorers should be machines versus humans.

“It would cost a lot of money to send somebody to Mars,” she said, “and we have roads and bridges that need repaired here.”

As for the moon, Ms Dewey noted, “We’ve been there.”

But Alan Curtis, 47, of Pocatello, Idaho, considers moon and Mars trips a top priority, especially if the US is to remain a world leader in space.

It's pretty bad that we have to rent a spot on a Russian spacecraft to get to the space station

Compared with its feats of the 1960s and 1970s, the US space programme is now a second thought, he said.

“It’s pretty bad that we have to rent a spot on a Russian spacecraft to get to the space station,” said Mr Curtis, a store cashier who says he was an occasional bounty hunter.

He pointed to the first-ever landing by a spacecraft on the far side of the moon, by China in January.

Abdul Lotiff, 28, a retail security company manager in Mason City, Iowa, also favours a return to the moon.

He sees economic benefits there, with the resulting new tech spilling into areas outside the space business.

In addition, he said, if and when Earth becomes overpopulated, the moon could serve as a springboard for humanity’s expansion into space.

The survey asked Americans to directly choose between the moon and Mars for exploration by US astronaut.

The red planet was the winner by about double: 37% compared with 18%.

However, 43% said neither destination was a priority.

For Americans under 45, born after Nasa’s Apollo moonshots, Mars came out on top by an even larger margin: 50% prefer a Mars trip, versus 17% for the moon.

A third said neither should be a priority.

Emirates Air Line cable cars are silhouetted against the backdrop of the moon (Yui Mok/PA)
Emirates Air Line cable cars are silhouetted against the backdrop of the moon (Yui Mok/PA)

For those 45 and older, 52% said neither Mars nor the moon should be a priority as a human destination. Of that age bracket, 26% preferred sending astronauts to Mars and 19% to the moon.

As for the White House’s deadline of returning astronauts to the moon within five years, Nasa is aiming for the water ice-rich lunar south pole by 2024, about four in 10 Americans favoured the plan, versus two in 10 against.

The remainder had no strong opinion either way.

The good news, at least for Nasa and its contractors, is that 60% of Americans believe the benefits of the space programme have justified the cost.

In 1979, on the 10th anniversary of the first manned moon landing, 41% of Americans said the benefits were worth the cost, according to an AP-NBC News poll.

If given an opportunity to experience space travel themselves, about half of Americans said they would orbit the Earth, while about four in 10 would fly to the moon and about three in 10 would go to Mars.

Among those willing to travel to the red planet, about half, or 15% of all Americans, said they would move to a Mars colony, even if it meant never returning to Earth.

Astronaut Buzz Aldrin poses for a photograph beside the US flag (Neil Armstrong/Nasa/PA)
Astronaut Buzz Aldrin poses for a photograph beside the US flag (Neil Armstrong/Nasa/PA)

Men were more likely than women to want to travel to any space destination: Earth orbit, moon and Mars.

Mr Curtis contends the US might have a colony on the moon by now “if we had put our money in the right places”.

“We haven’t been there in so long,” he said.

“Is the flag even still there?”

US flags were planted on the moon during each of the Apollo landings through 1972.

The first was knocked over by engine exhaust when Apollo 11’s Armstrong and Aldrin blasted off the moon.

- Press Association

More on this topic

World UFO Day: 'Take me to your Taoiseach'World UFO Day: 'Take me to your Taoiseach'

No constellation prize — Irish scientists ponder mystery of missing starNo constellation prize — Irish scientists ponder mystery of missing star

Astronomers witness ‘monster star’ mysteriously disappearing into darknessAstronomers witness ‘monster star’ mysteriously disappearing into darkness

Solar Orbiter prepares to capture closest image of the sun ever takenSolar Orbiter prepares to capture closest image of the sun ever taken


More in this Section

Covid-19 patients can suffer serious heart damage – studyCovid-19 patients can suffer serious heart damage – study

21 injured after explosion and fire on US navy ship21 injured after explosion and fire on US navy ship

Poland presidential election too close to call, exit poll suggestsPoland presidential election too close to call, exit poll suggests

Global outbreaks of Covid-19 continue as deaths top 566,000Global outbreaks of Covid-19 continue as deaths top 566,000


Lifestyle

The long-tailed tit’s nest is an architectural marvel.Richard Collins: Altruism of the long-tailed tits or not

The flight that brought us home to Ireland after our seven months sojourn in the Canary Islands (half our stay intended, half not) was the most comfortable I’ve experienced in years. With a large plane almost entirely to yourself, you could again pretend you were somebody.Damien Enright: Wonderful to see the green, green grass of home

IRISH folklore is replete with stories of priests praying for fine weather to help farmers save their crops in wet summers. However, the opposite could soon be happening when divine powers may have to be invoked to provide rain. And not just for farmers.Donal Hickey: Praying for rain — in Ireland

Geography is often the defining factor for the destiny of an island. Those islands that lie close to the shore have often been snapped up by interests on the mainland and their morphology changed to something completely different.The Islands of Ireland: Tarbert morphed onto the mainland

More From The Irish Examiner