Ministers from Holyrood and Westminster fail to reach Brexit agreement

Talks over the transfer of powers to Scotland after Brexit have resulted in "good progress" but failed to reach a deal.

The Scottish Government said the UK Government had not gone far enough for ministers to recommend that Holyrood gives legislative consent to the EU Withdrawal Bill.

The legislation - designed to transpose EU law into British law so the same rules apply on the day of Brexit as the day before - will see EU responsibilities in devolved areas initially transferred to Westminster.

The UK Government said this will allow common frameworks to be created ahead of further devolution.

Scottish Secretary David Mundell (left)and First Secretary of State Damien Green meet with Scottish Government ministers to discuss Brexit at St Andrew's House, Edinburgh.

Ministers in both Edinburgh and Cardiff said it amounts to a power grab and must be amended.

First Secretary Damian Green and Scottish Secretary David Mundell met with Deputy First Minister John Swinney and Scottish Brexit Minister Michael Russell in Edinburgh in an effort to resolve the dispute.

Mr Russell said: "Today's talks were held in a positive and constructive manner.

"Good progress has been made in several areas, most specifically on the issue of UK frameworks.

"This is to be welcomed, however it does not yet go far enough for the Scottish Government to recommend parliament agrees to give legislative consent to the EU Withdrawal Bill."

He added: "It is extremely important that the UK Government continue to engage with the devolved administrations so we can find a path that works for all the nations of the United Kingdom.

Scottish Secretary David Mundell arrives for a meeting with Scottish Government ministers to discuss Brexit at St Andrew's House, Edinburgh.

"This is particularly important in relation to future talks including trade as it is essential that Scotland's interests are represented in any negotiations.

"It must be recognised that fundamentally nothing can be agreed until agreement is reached on both frameworks and amendments to the Bill.

"We, therefore, look forward to the next discussions on these matters which will take place at the Joint Ministerial Committee (EU Negotiations) in London on December 12."

More in this Section

CIA officer who inspired Oscar-winning film Argo dies, aged 78

Police officers injured in clashes over Greece-Macedonia name deal

Colombian protesters flood streets after car bombing

Teenage girl tells of helping Skripals after Novichok poisoning


The more you spend on entertaining a small child, the less likely they are to enjoy it

Untying the Knot: How to divorce with love

Appliance of science: Why does my voice sound so different when recorded?

Let’s hear it for the girls: New book celebrate Cork's Scoil Mhuire

More From The Irish Examiner