Macron’s five-year plan to rebuild Notre Dame questioned

Macron’s five-year plan to rebuild Notre Dame questioned

Doubt has been cast on a pledge by French President Emmanuel Macron that the restoration of Notre Dame will be completed within five years.

Mr Macron said the renovations to restore the cathedral’s iconic 19th century spire, vaulting and two-thirds of its roof would be completed in time for the Paris 2024 Olympics.

“We will rebuild the cathedral to be even more beautiful and I want it to be finished within five years,” he said.

But experts have said that the ambitious timeline appears insufficient for such a massive operation.

Even French Prime Minister Edouard Philippe – while supporting the government timeline – acknowledged that it would be difficult.

“This is obviously an immense challenge, a historic responsibility,” Mr Philippe said.

Edouard Philippe, left, and French President Emmanuel Macron
Edouard Philippe, left, and French President Emmanuel Macron (Philippe Wojazer/Pool via AP)

Prominent French conservation architect Pierluigi Pericolo told Inrocks magazine it could take triple that time.

“No less than 15 years … it’s a colossal task,” Mr Pericolo said.

Mr Pericolo worked on the restoration of the 19th century Saint-Donatien basilica, which was badly damaged by fire in 2015 in the French city of Nantes. He said it could take between “two to five years” just to check the stability of the massive cathedral that dominates the Paris skyline.

“It’s a fundamental step, and very complex, because it’s difficult to send workers into a monument whose vaulted ceilings are swollen with water,” Mr Pericolo told France-Info.

“The end of the fire doesn’t mean the edifice is totally saved. The stone can deteriorate when it is exposed to high temperatures and change its mineral composition and fracture inside.”

PA Graphics

The comments came as Notre Dame’s rector said he would close the once-functioning cathedral for “five to six years” acknowledging that “a segment” of the near 900-year-old edifice may be gravely weakened.

Firefighters said Notre Dame’s rose windows are in good shape after the fire, but that their support structures are at risk.

Spokesman Gabriel Plus told reporters that the rose windows are “in good condition” but that “there is a risk for the gables that are no longer supported by the frame”.

He said firefighters took down statues inside the gables above the rose windows to protect them, and took care not to spray water too hard on the delicate stained glass.

He said firefighters and experts are still closely monitoring the building to determine how much damage the structure suffered and what needs to be dismantled to avoid collapse.

A Paris fire official said the towers of Notre Dame would have fallen if firefighters had not deployed massive equipment and acted swiftly.

Philippe Demay denied there was any delay and said firefighters acted as fast as they could.

Notre Dame Cathedral
Notre Dame’s towers could have fallen without swift action taken by firefighters, a Paris fire official said (AP Photo/Francois Mori)

Mr Demay told reporters that the operation was extremely difficult and that the towers could have collapsed “if we hadn’t put heavy equipment in place”.

The questions over the timeline came as nearly a billion euro poured in from ordinary worshippers and high-powered magnates around the world.

Contributions came from near and far, rich and poor – from Apple and magnates who own L’Oreal, Chanel and Dior, to Catholic parishioners and others from small towns and cities around France and the world.

Experts have put this in the threshold of realism – estimating the restoration would cost into to the hundreds of millions, although they acknowledge it is too early to be certain.

Debris inside Notre Dame cathedral
Debris inside Notre Dame cathedral (Christophe Petit Tesson, Pool via AP)

Presidential cultural heritage envoy Stephane Bern told broadcaster France-Info on Wednesday that €880 million has been raised in just a day-and-a-half since the fire.

The French government was gathering donations and setting up a special office to deal with big-ticket offers.

Some criticism has already surfaced among those in France who say the money could be better spent elsewhere, on smaller struggling churches or workers.

Mr Philippe said a competition will be held to see if the spire should be rebuilt.

“The international competition will allow for the question to be asked, should the spire be rebuilt?” he said. “Should we rebuild the spire envisaged and built by Viollet-le-Duc under the same conditions … (or) give Notre Dame a new spire adapted to the technologies and the challenges of our times?”

- Press Association

More on this topic

Melted scaffolding to be removed from fire-ravaged Notre DameMelted scaffolding to be removed from fire-ravaged Notre Dame

Notre Dame work resumes with new anti-contamination measures in placeNotre Dame work resumes with new anti-contamination measures in place

Stones fell from damaged Notre Dame ceiling amid heatwaveStones fell from damaged Notre Dame ceiling amid heatwave

Work to decontaminate Paris streets around Notre Dame to get under wayWork to decontaminate Paris streets around Notre Dame to get under way

More in this Section

British tourist, 50, shot dead in robbery outside Buenos Aires hotelBritish tourist, 50, shot dead in robbery outside Buenos Aires hotel

Violence flares in New Delhi over Indian citizenship lawViolence flares in New Delhi over Indian citizenship law

Greta Thunberg stuck on floor of crowded German train after climate summitGreta Thunberg stuck on floor of crowded German train after climate summit

Gove seeks to quash calls for Scottish independence vote amid Sturgeon warningsGove seeks to quash calls for Scottish independence vote amid Sturgeon warnings


Lifestyle

Last week, en route to La Gomera in the Canary Islands, I decide to stop off in Tenerife and take the 1.2km cable car ride to the top of Mount Teide, 3,660m above sea level. Cable cars are invariably an exciting way to travel.Dursey Island is a special place because of its remoteness

It can be considered offensive by some but generally the word ‘tinker’ is not considered rude says the Traveller’s advocacy group Pavee Point. Over time the term became synonymous with ‘Traveller’ and it is this which is current today.The Islands of Ireland: Tinkering with the past on Tinker’s Island in West Cork

Dr Naomi Lavelle explores some questions about walking upside-downAppliance of Science: Could humans copy insects' ability to walk upside-down?

Emer Corridan is the general manager at the award-winning four-star, Cahernane House Hotel in Killarney, Co. Kerry.You've Been Served: Emer Corridan, general manager at Cahernane House, Killarney

More From The Irish Examiner