Judge orders halt to life-support for baby girl who suffered brain damage at birth

A baby who suffered brain damage after being starved of oxygen when born in a car during a hailstorm should no longer receive life support treatment, a British High Court judge has decided.

The little girl’s parents wanted treatment to continue, but Mr Justice Peter Jackson has ruled against them after a hearing in the Family Division of the High Court in Manchester.

He said the only benefit the little girl – who was born in January – would get from continued treatment was the “prolongation of her life by intensive medical intervention”.

The judge said, in a written ruling, that the little girl had been in an intensive care unit all her life.

He said she had no quality of life, no “future to look forward to” and could experience “none of the joys of life”.

Mr Justice Jackson said the “likely consequence of his decision” was that the little girl would soon die.

He said no-one involved could be identified.

The judge named the girl only as “Chloe” in the ruling.

He said she was being treated in a specialist unit run by the Bolton NHS Foundation Trust.

Trust bosses had asked for an order authorising the withdrawal of respiratory support.

“Chloe is her parents' only child,'' said Mr Justice Jackson in the ruling.

“After an uncomplicated pregnancy, her mother went into labour at home on 28 January.

“Her parents set out to drive to hospital.

“It was an icy road and there was a hailstorm.

“Chloe was born in the car on the journey.

“When she arrived at hospital, she was in a critical condition with no spontaneous breathing or cardiac activity.

“She was resuscitated and her heart began to beat.

“The next day, she was transferred to (a) neonatal intensive care unit.”

He said doctors had concluded that she had suffered brain damage as a result of a lack of oxygen at birth.

“Chloe has remained in intensive care all her life, receiving continuous medical support at the highest level,” said the judge.

“For some considerable time, the doctors treating her have been concerned that this treatment is not in her best interests.

“After many discussions with the parents, who wish for treatment to continue and for Chloe to be moved to another hospital, the trust began these proceedings.”

Mr Justice Jackson said he was in ``no doubt'' that the trust's application should be granted.

“The benefits to Chloe of continued treatment consist only in the prolongation of her life by intensive medical intervention,” said the judge.

“The burdens, which only she has to bear, are considerable.

“She has no quality of life beyond remission from pain and distress.

“Even if she survives, she has no future to look forward to.

“She can experience none of the joys of life, but at best a continuous series of medical interventions.”

He added: “The likely consequence of this decision is that Chloe will soon die. Given her sad experience of life, I hope that she will have a peaceful death.”

The judge expressed his sympathy to Chloe’s parents and his appreciation for the “dedicated professionalism” of medics.

More in this Section

Common gut bacteria may contribute to bowel cancer, scientists sayCommon gut bacteria may contribute to bowel cancer, scientists say

Early worm lost lower limbs for tube-dwelling lifestyle, research suggestsEarly worm lost lower limbs for tube-dwelling lifestyle, research suggests

Delhi riots leave dozens dead amid rising tensions over citizenship lawDelhi riots leave dozens dead amid rising tensions over citizenship law

Britain First leader Paul Golding denies terror chargeBritain First leader Paul Golding denies terror charge


Posh Cork's agony aunt: sorting out Cork people for ages.Ask Audrey: why aren't William and Kate coming to Cork?

Festival season approaches, legends come to the Opera House, and a young Irish phenomenon continues to impact on UK telly, writes Arts Editor Des O'Driscoll.Scene and Heard: 'the major voice of a generation'

In advance of this weekend’s Ortús festival of chamber music in Cork, musician and co-organiser Mairead Hickey talks violins with Cathy Desmond.Máiréad Hickey: ‘If money was no object, it would be lovely to play a Stradivarius’

Pink Floyd drummer Nick Mason is thrilled to be playing the band’s older material in a new group that he’s bringing to Ireland. But what chances of a final reunion, asks Richard Purden.Pink Floyd's Nick Mason: over the moon

More From The Irish Examiner