Evidence showed sex offences by Cardinal Pell in Australia were impossible, appeal told

Evidence showed sex offences by Cardinal Pell in Australia were impossible, appeal told

Lawyers for the most senior Roman Catholic found guilty of child sex abuse have argued in his appeal that he could not have molested two choirboys in an Australian cathedral undetected moments after Sunday mass while he was dressed in an archbishop’s robes.

Cardinal George Pell, 77, wore a black suit and black shirt with a cleric’s collar when he appeared for the Victoria state Court of Appeal hearing before three judges.

He came and went from the court as the sole occupant of a prison van, and said nothing during the hearing.

Pell’s lawyer Bret Walker argued for more than five hours that the five verdicts against Pell were “unsafe and unsatisfactory” and should be overturned.

Cardinal George Pell arrives at the court (Julian Smith/AAP/AP)
Cardinal George Pell arrives at the court (Julian Smith/AAP/AP)

The lawyers cited former High Court Justice Michael McHugh, who said “juries are likely to be affected by the prejudices and even the hysterias that from time to time are found in the community”.

The prosecution will argue on Thursday why the verdicts were sound and should stand. Whoever wins, the case could reach the High Court, Australia’s ultimate arbiter.

A jury unanimously convicted Pell in December of orally raping a 13-year-old choirboy and indecently dealing with the boy and his 13-year-old friend in Melbourne’s St Patrick’s Cathedral in the late 1990s.

Pell had become archbishop of Melbourne only months before.

Court orders had for months prevented publication of the details of that trial and an earlier trial on similar charges that had ended in September with a deadlocked jury.

Pell was sentenced in March to six years in prison, and is held in special protective custody.

Pope Francis (Andrew Medichini/AP)
Pope Francis (Andrew Medichini/AP)

While Pell remains Australia’s highest-ranking Catholic, the Vatican is conducting its own investigation into the convictions of Pope Francis’s former finance minister.

Francis’s papacy has been thrown into turmoil by clerical sexual abuse and the church’s handling of such cases worldwide.

In a little more than a year, the Pope has admitted he made “grave errors” in Chile’s worst case of cover-up, Pell was convicted of abuse, a French cardinal was convicted of failing to report a paedophile, and a third cardinal, former US church leader Theodore McCarrick, was defrocked after a Vatican investigation determined he abused children and adults.

Mr Walker told the three judges the main ground for appeal was that the jury could not have found Pell guilty beyond reasonable doubt on the evidence.

In written submissions, Pell’s lawyers said more than 20 prosecution witnesses who had an official role in the Sunday mass in 1996 gave evidence that the offences did not or could not have occurred.

“This evidence constituted a catalogue of at least 13 solid obstacles in the path of a conviction,” the lawyers said.

“No matter what view was taken of the complainant as a witness, it was simply not open to a jury to accept his words beyond reasonable doubt,” they added.

Pell’s lawyers argue in their submissions that the “the evidence showed the offending was impossible”.

Joe Mitchell (Rod McGuirk/AP)
Joe Mitchell (Rod McGuirk/AP)

Demonstrator Joe Mitchell, 83, drove more than 600 miles from his home in Newcastle, New South Wales, to Melbourne to protest outside the court against the church response to child abuse.

“I’m a victim. I hope they put a rope around his … neck,” a tearful Mr Mitchell said. “They say ‘how could you remember back 70 years?’ I remember everything.”

- Press Association

More on this topic

Religious order did not want 'eternal besmirching of names of good people' by keeping abuse recordsReligious order did not want 'eternal besmirching of names of good people' by keeping abuse records

Kiss but don’t tell: How Ireland enabled Cleary’s sexual hypocrisyKiss but don’t tell: How Ireland enabled Cleary’s sexual hypocrisy

Inquiry hears of ‘sexual abuse’ at home run by religious order in ScotlandInquiry hears of ‘sexual abuse’ at home run by religious order in Scotland

'Beyond time' that Government acknowledges failure to compensate abuse victims, says survivor'Beyond time' that Government acknowledges failure to compensate abuse victims, says survivor

More in this Section

£1m campaign to keep notebooks of Charles Darwin’s mentor in UK£1m campaign to keep notebooks of Charles Darwin’s mentor in UK

Moonwalker Buzz Aldrin marks Apollo 11 anniversary at launch siteMoonwalker Buzz Aldrin marks Apollo 11 anniversary at launch site

Astronauts blast off on moon landing anniversaryAstronauts blast off on moon landing anniversary

British Airways suspends flights to Cairo as security ‘precaution’British Airways suspends flights to Cairo as security ‘precaution’


Lifestyle

Celebrate the anniversary by finding lift off without even leaving the earth, at these stateside visitor centres and museums, says Sarah Marshall.America’s top space-age attractions to celebrate 50 years since the moon landing

For bookworms and classic movie buffs, the notion of a London park will forever conjure up images of Mary Poppins with the Banks children in tow.Inside/ Out: Park life is looking up in London by Eve Kelliher

“Does anyone want to be my friend?” roared my five year old as he walked into the playground at our French campsite on holidays.Learner Dad: 'It can be heartbreaking watching your kids try make friends on holiday'

These handy product edits are so useful for travelling, says Katie Wright.Palettes pack a punch: The travel must have

More From The Irish Examiner