Readers' blog: Female ordinations are scripture incompatible

Following the recent spat between Culture Minister Josepha Madigan and Archbishop Diarmuid Martin a few points are worth reflecting on. 

The heat in this altercation, I believe, is more about the views expressed by Minister Madigan on female ordination and other issues of Church practice.

Josepha Madigan

Of course, God in his essence is neither male or female, neither essentially masculine or feminine. However, God, in his relation to his creation, does have a masculine aspect. 

This is clear in the way God has revealed himself, and is fundamental to the Church’s understanding of priesthood.

The priest represents God who reveals himself as “father” (scripture never uses a female pronoun to refer to God). 

The priest acts in the person of Jesus Christ, God Incarnate, who became human as a man. The priest is made permanently into a living symbol of God. Thus, who he is matters.

While those who favour women priests often speak in terms of equality and fairness, we see, especially in the Catholic context, that those who agitate for female ordinations often have further agenda items.

Very often proponents of female ordination discuss the issue not only in terms like equality, but also “representation”, in a political sense, that women need to be represented in “decision-making”.

Dig deeper, and you will find that they want women to become clergy in order to change other teachings.

Female ordination advocates also routinely promote abortion, contraception, same-sex relationships, and any other of a number of the “usual suspects” of dissenters.

One irony jumps out. 

Proponents of female clergy often vociferously denounce clericalism, yet their position implies that the clergy are the “real Christians”, or the important ones, that one cannot participate meaningfully in the Church unless one is ordained.

A cursory look at other religious denominations who have gone down this path will demonstrate the even quicker decline in their numbers than the Catholic Church.

Don Cahalane



More on this topic

Priests’ group urge reform in open letter to bishops

Vatican bishops petitioned on votes for women at synod

Catholicism rejects new laws on abuse

'The Church is not listening' - Survey shows priests think 'ministry should be open to women'

More in this Section

Uphill battle against Trump’s emergency

Asleep at the wheel on public projects

It’s time to fire the three monkeys: Silence is still an engine of subjugation

Insect populations collapsing: We’re codding ourselves again


A fear of regret can lock us into bad relationships, jobs and habits – here's how to break free

Outside the box: A tale of two Calais and suffering beyond reason

Opening Lines: I feel sorry for the dogs. Even they have a sense of shame about having to poo in public

New TV show highlights lack of cycle lanes in Ireland in comparison to rest of Europe

More From The Irish Examiner