Letter to the Editor: Civilian control of defence is democratic

File photo
File photo

A number of former officers of the Irish Defence Forces (including Dorcha Lee and Ray Cawley) have very justifiably criticised the present depleted condition of our Defence Forces and the manner that recent governments have treated our serving soldiers, and I agree with their concerns.

However, I urge caution on the suggestion in the report — ‘Ex-senior officer seeks commission to examine Defence Forces’ (Irish Examiner, May 27) that a former army officer should be appointed as Irish defence minister.

I have no doubt that former officer Cathal Berry was a very capable officer and will make a very capable politician. 

We need people with this level of intelligence and capability in our government and this is demonstrated by the incompetence of so many of our senior politicians over recent decades.

Since the 1930s especially, there has been very clear civilian democratic control over our defence forces and this is essential in a democracy.

In many other countries, the Eoin O’Duffys of this world have done serious damage to democracy, although I have no doubt that Cathal Berry TD is not in this category.

Doctors don’t necessarily make the best ministers of health, former police don’t necessarily make the best
ministers of justice (remember Sean Doherty?), and teachers don’t necessarily make best ministers of education, due to being too close to the vested interests of their professions.

I think that Cathal Berry should set his sights a little bit higher than minister for defence.

- Edward Horgan (Comdt, retired)

Newtown,

Castletroy,

Limerick

More on this topic

Army reserves at just a third of full strengthArmy reserves at just a third of full strength

Simon Coveney briefed on manpower issues at Haulbowline naval baseSimon Coveney briefed on manpower issues at Haulbowline naval base

PDForra not backing independent pay review model for militaryPDForra not backing independent pay review model for military

Defence forces group PDForra lodges High Court case to allow Ictu linkDefence forces group PDForra lodges High Court case to allow Ictu link

More in this Section

Irish Examiner view: Poland's narrow vote a threat to the EUIrish Examiner view: Poland's narrow vote a threat to the EU

Irish Examiner view: Political parties should clear the air before votes are cast in electionsIrish Examiner view: Political parties should clear the air before votes are cast in elections

Irish Examiner view: A weak link in coronavirus battleIrish Examiner view: A weak link in coronavirus battle

Paul Hosford: Cowen presents early headache for MartinPaul Hosford: Cowen presents early headache for Martin


Lifestyle

The world is in chaos and fascism is on the march. But enough about 2020 – what about America in 1940?The Plot Against America: Sky Atlantic series shows a parallel history that has echoes of today's world

Ubisoft has given us a look of some of their upcoming releasesGame Tech: A glimpse of Far Cry 6 and Assassin’s Creed Valhalla

Exfoliating cleansers are the first step in upgrading your skincare routine.The Skin Nerd: How to get active when it comes to cleansing

The arrival of the new baby has led to a tricky family dynamic in the Cork-set show, writes Georgia HumphreysBaby's arrival leads to more adventures as the Young Offenders return

More From The Irish Examiner