Reliance on the market is misplaced - Planning for an older population

There are myriad examples of how that vague, mercurial entity “the market” has not delivered on the promise of the better future its champions assured us was inevitable once we placed our faith in investors and entrepreneurs. 

Competition, they promised, was the catalyst that would turn the tide and lift all boats. Our housing crisis, our struggling two-tier health service, runaway insurance costs — not to mention the unaccountable tech giants and the banks — and the blank-cheque broadband fiasco show how misplaced that optimism was and is.

There were few champions of the market more certain — unhinged if you prefer — than Margaret Thatcher. However, 40 years after she became Britain’s prime minister academics conclude that the consequences of her policies, ones that devasted swathes of Britain, were a driving force behind the vote to quit the EU. 

That Britain has five of the poorest regions in the EU shows how wrong Thatcher was even if that sorry fact may help explain the unexplainable vote of June 2016. Her legacy is as shaming as its failure is indisputable.

Even if these examples show how very unwise it is to buy the idea that the market is always a force for good we persist with the hope that it will deliver on well-flagged and growing social obligations. 

The decision to change the terms of the nursing homes Fair Deal scheme to allow farmers enjoy the protection of a new cap on care contributions is another example of our hope that private businesses will fill social service needs. 

Whether this is prferential treatment or not is a question for another day but is a reminder that there is a growing need for nursing home care. This was recognised when tax incentives were offered to encourage expansion in the sector. Whether that investment keeps pace with the needs of an aging population is an open question. 

So too is the level of service provided across the sector.

This has been recognised in new guidelines aimed at making care contracts more transparent so elderly people or their families do not face unexpected “top-up” charges for services that seem basic rather than additional. 

Two years ago, an investigation concluded that more than 300 nursing homes charged over €16m a year in add-on charges for social activities, games, or various therapies. 

Age Action Ireland described a case where a woman was charged close enough to €100 a week in excess fees. 

A Government review was promised two years ago but it has not been published, at least partially because many nursing homes have not co-operated. Reliable social partners indeed.

Last September the Department of Finance warned that our aging population will cause a huge increase in public debt. 

That report foresaw massive increases in age-related costs and warned policy changes are needed. That these alarm bells ring so loudly in a country with a two-tier, if not a three-tier, system of pension provision shows the scale of the challenge. 

Anyone who believes the market, a mechanism that prioritises profit, will fill that need in a way that offers dignity and comfort to old people, is as deluded as those Tories who imagined Thatcher a saviour.

More on this topic

ALONE holding first ever 'Donation Day' in Dublin

Housing designed for aging population neglected, according to new report

Reach out to elderly neighbours in 2019, charity pleads

Nursing home residents share their stories and offer life advice in new book

More in this Section

Grenfell Tower: warnings might have been heard if not for the collapse of local journalism

Companies still confused about data protection requirements

Worrying trends in the effects of internet use among primary school children

Clune in danger as Cork vies for three seats from five in election


Talented Waterford hurler Seanie Barry surprised to learn he has Type 1 diabetes

From snail facials to blood moisturiser: the strangest things people have done for their skin

Thrill of the grill: 7 reds to fire-up the taste buds this barbecue season

How to make Selina Periampillai’s sunny-side-up egg, chicken and pak choi rice bowl

More From The Irish Examiner