Isolationist policies spell danger for developing countries

Isolationist policies spell danger for developing countries
The 17 Sustainable Development Goals adopted by UN, which it hopes to achieve by 2030. However, with trade wars and an increasing lurch to isolationism, developing countries must increasingly look to at how they collect their own tax revenues, and how they are spent.

Developing countries can no longer rely on foreign aid, but reform could boost tax revenue, write Tania Masi, Roberto Ricciuti, Antonio Savoia, and Kunal Sen

WITH objectives such as ending poverty in all its forms and delivering quality education to all by 2030, the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are highly ambitious — much more ambitious than their predecessor, the Millennium Development Goals. Whether or not the world achieves them will depend crucially on money — particularly public finance.

Traditionally, official development assistance (ODA) would play a pivotal role in financing an agenda like the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda, which encompasses the 17 SDGs.

But at a time when nationalist rhetoric and isolationist policies are gaining traction in some of the world’s biggest traditional donor countries — beginning with the United States — ODA will not be sufficient.

In fact, foreign aid has remained flat, at best, in the last few years — and there is no increase in sight. On the contrary, the spectre of global recession, heightened by US President Donald Trump’s trade war, makes a reduction in donor governments’ revenues, a distinct possibility. None of this bodes well for foreign aid flows.

This means that, to implement the SDGs, developing countries will need to rely increasingly on their own resources. And, in fact, the 2030 Agenda anticipates this imperative: SDG17’s first target is to “strengthen domestic resource mobilisation — to improve domestic capacity for tax and other revenue collection”. The question is how.

Poor fiscal management means that developing countries — particularly in Africa, home to 27 of the world’s 28 poorest countries — are often plagued by debt crises and inflation, and many are at the mercy of commodity-price cycles.

Tax collection is a major challenge for these economies: the tax revenues low-income countries collect amount to about 10%-20% of GDP, on average, compared to about 40% of GDP in high-income countries.

One major reason for this is that these countries tend to have large informal economies; another is that they invest little in the infrastructure needed to implement personal taxation, relying instead on sales taxes, which are easier to administer, but bring in less revenue.

Add poor management of what is collected to that, and these countries consistently fail to deliver necessary public goods and services, let alone ensure fiscal sustainability.

The effectiveness of tax collection and the strength of budgetary systems, our research shows, depend crucially on the extent to which political institutions place constraints on executive power. Governments with credible, institutionalised systems of checks and balances tend not only to collect more tax revenues, but also to have more transparent and predictable budgetary processes.

A major reason for this is accountability. Giving a single executive virtually unchecked control over a government’s financial resources raises the risk of sudden changes in budgetary priorities, and nurtures the temptation to spend on projects that enrich a few at the expense of the public good.

But when political leaders are unable to use state revenues

freely — say,

to enrich themselves or their cronies, they may be more likely to invest in strengthening the government’s fiscal capacity, including its ability to design, implement, and monitor the budget.

In a well-functioning parliamentary system, for example, the state budget is overseen by a group of elected authorities in a relatively transparent manner. No one person has the power to shape the process in self-serving ways. Instead, leaders are under pressure to respond to the voters’ needs and preferences.

In such a context, taxation becomes an informed, consensual transaction between citizens and the state. This bolsters trust in official institutions, in turn boosting revenues and supporting social and political stability.

According to our research, placing institutional constraints on the executive would, over about nine years, lead to a 2.4-percentage-point increase in the GDP share of both total revenues and income-tax revenues.

Such changes would also raise the quality of fiscal planning above the global average.

These gains could translate into more textbooks in local schools, more vaccines for local health services, and more resources for poverty-reduction programs. In other words, a taxation system constrained by institutions that ensure transparency and accountability could support progress toward achieving the SDGs.

Of course, the effects will not be instantaneous. Institutional reform is a gradual process, and legal changes do not immediately translate into behavioral ones. But embedding checks and balances into governance — particularly to limit the executive’s discretionary budgetary authority — is integral to accomplish the kind of structural transformation developing countries need if they are to create more stable, prosperous futures well beyond 2030.

Tania Masi is a researcher at the University of Milano-Bicocca. Roberto Ricciuti is an associate professor at the University of Verona. Antonio Savoia is a senior lecturer at the University of Manchester. Kunal Sen, a professor at the University of Manchester, is director of UNU-WIDER.

Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2019

More on this topic

President Higgins leads tributes at National Day of Commemoration eventPresident Higgins leads tributes at National Day of Commemoration event

UN urges Security Council to protect women's rights 'before, during and after' conflictUN urges Security Council to protect women's rights 'before, during and after' conflict

Migrant fisherman in Ireland - A modern form of slaveryMigrant fisherman in Ireland - A modern form of slavery

Nóirín O'Sullivan appointed as UN Assistant Secretary-General for Safety and SecurityNóirín O'Sullivan appointed as UN Assistant Secretary-General for Safety and Security

More in this Section

Is the Irish salmon doomed to a watery grave?Is the Irish salmon doomed to a watery grave?

Dangerous times for Trump if he faces into process of impeachmentDangerous times for Trump if he faces into process of impeachment

Letter to the Editor: Ramifications of America abandoning the KurdsLetter to the Editor: Ramifications of America abandoning the Kurds

Why artificial intelligence needs to be handled with careWhy artificial intelligence needs to be handled with care


Fiann Ó Nualláin follows in the footsteps of the Fianna as he explores a province’s hills and vales.Munster marvels: Plants that are unique to a province

Cupid must be something of a motoring enthusiast, as he had most definitely steered his way in the neighbourhood when Amie Gould and Shane O’Neill met at the Rally of the Lakes 12 years ago.Wedding of the Week: Cupid steers couple to right track

When it comes to podcasting, all it takes is one idea — and who knows where it can take you.Podcast Corner: Crimes and creatures rule at Cork’s first podcast fest

Claymation meets science fiction in this enchanting film, writes Esther McCarthy.Latest Shaun adventure is out of this world

More From The Irish Examiner