Christopher R Hill: Trump’s departure will not cure America’s political malaise

Americans may have a well-known love affair with their cars, but it was the South Koreans who first introduced drive-through testing for Covid-19 — a simple measure that drastically minimises the risk of infection, writes Christopher R Hill

President Donald Trump’s concern during this crisis has been more on the plunging stock market than the human cost.
President Donald Trump’s concern during this crisis has been more on the plunging stock market than the human cost.

Americans also have a well-known preference for straight talk, bluntness, and clarity of thought. And yet, it is the South Koreans who have met the coronavirus pandemic head on.

To be sure, South Korea is one of the world’s most advanced countries (though many Koreans would modestly dismiss such accolades). But so, too, is the United States. 

Why, then, has the US lagged so far behind in its response to the pandemic?

The short answer is that the US has a president who is fundamentally unfit for the job, both intellectually and temperamentally. 

The majority of Americans already reached this conclusion years ago. 

If current trends in public opinion continue, Donald Trump is set to lose the election this November, to be replaced by his polar opposite: the likely Democratic presidential nominee, Joe Biden.

If that happens, many Americans will celebrate their country’s return to dignity and decency. 

As Biden so often puts it, “character is on the ballot.”

But Trump’s departure would not necessarily cure America’s political malaise. 

The country is plagued by a pervasive ideological tribalism, and Trump himself is merely a prominent carrier of this disease.

As any casual observer of US politics knows, the country is deeply divided by “negative partisanship,” with both parties motivated more by their opposition to the other than by advocacy for their own ideas.

But one of these camps, Trump’s Republican Party, has combined this adversarial approach with a deep suspicion of expertise and of governance generally. And while such anti-establishment attitudes pre-date Trump, he has eagerly stoked them further for his own political gain.

His disturbing appearance at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and his press conferences on March 13 and March 14 all demonstrated that the weight of his concern has been on the stock market rather than on people’s health.

As for the administration’s actual response to the crisis, Trump has primarily pushed the theme of “public-private partnership,” relying on US companies to pledge voluntary support. 

Yet, apart from an offer by Walmart’s CEO to make available his stores’ half-empty parking lots for drive-through testing, the private sector’s commitments have fallen far short of what is needed.

As always with Trump, these corporate pledges were turned into political theatre. 

At a White House press conference, Trump introduced each executive by offering a promotional blurb about their company, and each executive dutifully approached the microphone to offer vague promises of support.

This particular episode had all the hallmarks of a campaign fundraising event. But it also clearly had been choreographed to remind Americans that the backbone of the economy is business, not government-employed public-health officials.

Trump wants the country — and the rest of the world — to trust his ability to marshal the private sector.

As if it wasn’t obvious previously during his administration, Trump is in over his head.

He plans for only one thing: assigning blame. For example, he continues to refer to the contagion as the “Chinese virus,” even though ‘coronavirus’ and ‘Covid-19’ have already become the universal parlance around the world.

For weeks, while much of the world got to work fighting the pandemic, Trump saw it as an opportunity to reinforce his anti-immigration policies, even claiming — absurdly — that his infamous wall on the Mexican border would keep the virus out.

One of America’s longest-running ideological disputes concerns how to ensure universal health care. Those who fear the spectre of “socialism” regularly attack, denigrate, and have ultimately thwarted the Obama administration’s attempt to mandate health insurance for all.

Trump and Republicans routinely attack public education on ideological grounds. 

Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos and others in the administration have taken to calling public schools “government schools,” and want to expand the scope of so-called charter schools. 

While these efforts are justified in the name of “school choice,” the ultimate motivation is ideological: namely, to weaken and ultimately abolish the 250-year-old institution of free — and ultimately universal and mandatory — public education.

Character is indeed on the ballot. 

But so is the prospect of restoring more practical, non-ideological approaches to solving problems. 

In November, Americans will have a chance to embrace governance that is guided by values and knowledge. 

Both are among the first things shunted aside when ideology takes center stage.

In addition to confronting the coronavirus, America must address this pre-existing condition.

Christopher R Hill, former US assistant secretary of state for East Asia, is chief adviser to the chancellor for global engagement and professor of the practice in diplomacy at the University of Denver

He is also the author of 'Outpost: A Diplomat at Work.'

More on this topic

Michael Clifford: Dazed and confused in the Trump worldMichael Clifford: Dazed and confused in the Trump world

Donald Trump threatens states over postal votingDonald Trump threatens states over postal voting

Trump talks from the top of his head, says ex-UK scientific adviserTrump talks from the top of his head, says ex-UK scientific adviser

Fergus Finlay: Trump to force Biden on defensive with strategy of scattershot liesFergus Finlay: Trump to force Biden on defensive with strategy of scattershot lies

More in this Section

Michael Clifford: Hot under the collar over shirtless LeoMichael Clifford: Hot under the collar over shirtless Leo

Irish Examiner View: Let’s prepare for threat of rising seasIrish Examiner View: Let’s prepare for threat of rising seas

Irish Examiner View: Questions for parents after teenage gangs in brawlsIrish Examiner View: Questions for parents after teenage gangs in brawls

Irish Examiner View: Inspiring Oliver Lynch raises over €20k for charityIrish Examiner View: Inspiring Oliver Lynch raises over €20k for charity


Lifestyle

Struggling to stick to your work routine at home? You’re not alone.10 tips for greater productivity working from home

Relaxing the rules at home has helped Karen Koster and her young family to get through lockdown, says Helen O'CallaghanEasy does it: Relaxing home rules the 'perfect tonic for kids'

PARENTS who homeschool must feel very confident of their choice these days, surely this global event will add to their number even after schools reopen. Their pioneering spirit isGet the Look: The eco-friendly beauty products you need to buy now

The penultimate instalment of Normal People, and a Champions League goal-fest are among today's top picksTuesday TV Highlights: The penultimate instalment of Normal People and a Champions League goal-fest

More From The Irish Examiner