Abbas Milani: Soleimani death may play into Iran’s hands

Abbas Milani: Soleimani death may play into Iran’s hands
Protesters outside the US embassy in Nine Elms, London, yesterday, holding photographs of Iran’s top general, Qassem Soleimani, head of Tehran’s elite Quds Force, who was killed by the US in a drone strike at Baghdad’s international airport last week. Picture: Gareth Fuller/PA.

Before the US assassinated its most senior general, Iran had contended with protests at home and resentment for its presence in Iraq. Not anymore, writes Abbas Milani.

The assassination last week,by the United States, of Qassem Soleimani, the commander of Iran’s Quds Force, was a major escalation in the two countries’ long-running conflict.

But it need not beget World War III (as some pundits are predicting).

Moreover, while the US might have achieved a short-term tactical advantage, the Iranian regime could yet benefit.

Iran has been taking drastic steps to ameliorate its severe regional and domestic challenges. For example, it recently confronted a sudden upsurge in nationalist fervour in Iraq over Iran’s influence there.

Iran’s diplomatic outposts were burned, and its goods boycotted.Even the Iranian-born Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, Iraq’s highest Shia cleric, has spoken out against foreign (meaning Iranian) interference in Iraqi affairs.

To divert this anti-Iranian sentiment, Soleimani’s allies in Iran — particularly the newspaper Kayhan, a mouthpiece for Iranian supreme leader, Ayatollah Khamenei — suggested, in October, that Iraqis should occupy the US embassy in Baghdad.

Iran needed to change the discourse in Iraq by redirecting nationalist fervour toward the US. And the conversation in Iraq has indeed changed, following the drone strike on Soleimani: many Iraqis are now wondering not when Iran will leave, but when the US will.

Meanwhile, Iran also has a significant domestic challenge.

The regime has moved with shocking brutality to repress massive demonstrations against deteriorating economic conditions. Several hundred people have been killed and thousands more arrested.

Since then, Khamenei has been besieged, criticised even by his traditional base for his mishandling of the situation.

As with the explosion of discontent in Iraq, he needed a way to change the story, and the US has now temporarily obliged.

To the outside world, Soleimani was the mastermind of the regime’s terrorist activities outside Iran, and the puppet master of its proxies across the region, not least Hezbollah in Lebanon.

Yet to Iranians, he was a more complicated figure. While regime hardliners regarded him as a hero, many Iranians, who have lost loved-ones in peaceful demonstrations, or who object to the regime’s attacks on Iranian dissidents in the diaspora, saw him differently.

Nonetheless, over the past few years, the regime has pushed a clever public relations campaign to depict Soleimani as a Napoleon- or Caesar-like warrior-poet.

And as one of the few Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) commanders not tainted with allegations of corruption, he was mooted as a likely presidential candidate in the next election.

Thus, inasmuch as there was public sympathy for Soleimani, it will now extend to the regime, at least in the short run.

Before these latest developments, Iran, increasingly isolated internationally, was looking for ways to flex its muscles on the world stage.

In December, it held its first-ever joint naval operations with Russia and China, and officials have announced plans to lease the Persian Gulf port of Bushehr to Russia.

It is hard to overstate the long-term strategic implications of robust Russian and Chinese naval presences in thePersian Gulf, given that these two countries are the most likely to challenge the US in the years and decades ahead.

With the change in mood following Soleimani’s death, the Iranian regime has a window in which to consolidate its ties with both.

To be sure, in prodding its Iraqi proxies to swarm the US embassy,the regime overplayed its hand and underestimated US president, Donald Trump’s willingness to respond with force.

But by targeting Soleimani, the US, too, might have miscalculated, by underestimating Iran’s own ability and willingness to retaliate.

Given the state of the economy and the level of discontent in Iran, Khamenei must keep the IRGC and loyal militias firmly on his side.

And right now, those forces are clamouring for revenge.

For Khamenei, then, the key will be to find a response that is forceful enough to satisfy his base, but not provocative enough to incite full-scale escalation.

For its part, the Trump administration has been operating under the assumption that the Iranian regime is so bereft of legitimacy, and so enfeebled by domestic discontent, that it could never countenance a major war with the US. And this dangerous assumption has been reinforced by Trump’s own oft-stated belief that a war with Iran would be very short.

But, in fact, the Iranian regime has deep cultural, economic, and intelligence ties throughout the region, and particularly in Iraq. It has mastered the art of asymmetrical war, and it now has no choice but to respond in some way to Soleimani’s death.

One hopes that their domestic woes, and deep desire for self-preservation, will lead Khamenei and his government to embrace symbolic acts of retaliation, rather than escalatory measures.

And one hopes that the US, too, will act with strategic prudence in responding to Iran’s next move.

Otherwise, we could end up with a war that almost no-one wants, and for which the endgame would be highly unpredictable.

Abbas Milani, research fellow and co-director of the Iran Democracy Project at the Hoover Institution, is director of Iranian studies at Stanford University.

More on this topic

Jason Lange: Billionaire Bloomberg willing to spend to oust TrumpJason Lange: Billionaire Bloomberg willing to spend to oust Trump

Middle East tensions after US drone strike could hit drivers at the pumpsMiddle East tensions after US drone strike could hit drivers at the pumps

UN official equates former US intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning incarceration as tortureUN official equates former US intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning incarceration as torture

Bernie Sanders raises $35m for White House bid in 2019’s final quarterBernie Sanders raises $35m for White House bid in 2019’s final quarter

More in this Section

Michael Clifford: Fianna Fáil face 'tough, closely fought election'Michael Clifford: Fianna Fáil face 'tough, closely fought election'

Michael Clifford: A young man’s death in custodyMichael Clifford: A young man’s death in custody

Hearings offer Trump a win-win possibilityHearings offer Trump a win-win possibility

Dead in a prison cell because of neglectDead in a prison cell because of neglect


The actor knows how to impress when it comes to high profile events.6 times Katie Holmes wowed on the red carpet

Glamour, fun and feathers all feature in this year’s hottest looks – but first and foremost, individual style rules.10 on-trend ways to transform your home in 2020

Abi Jackson shares the enduring appeal of Pooh Bear’s wisdom on Winnie-the-Pooh Day – author A.A. Milne’s birthday.Winnie-the-Pooh Day: The wellbeing lessons we can learn from Pooh Bear

We asked three experts for the low-down on shampooing frequency.How often should you really wash your hair?

More From The Irish Examiner