Dublin and Mayo have to do it all again this weekend after drawing their All-Ireland SFC semi-final.
The game had a breathless, controversial ending – but did the football fail to live up to the billing?
There was huge focus on Joe McQuillan’s performance as referee – but was that game impossible to referee?
What do you put Dublin’s collapse from the 62nd minute on down to?
And having been out of the game for long periods - is there anyway Mayo can be that poor again?
The panel also discussed who they felt would have learned most from the game and predicted who they expect to come out on top in the replay.