Three things we learned: Officials erred with HawkEye call

Stephen Barry picks out three takeaways after Tipperary snatched a draw against Cork in Thurles.

HawkEye shouldn’t have been the final act

We’ll leave aside the fact that Jake Morris’ equaliser split the posts clear as day, making one wonder why HawkEye was required at all. No harm in double-checking and all that. But that shouldn’t have been the final play. HawkEye was signalled for with 40 seconds remaining on the clock.

Had HawkEye not been called for, we’d have had an extra play. Tipperary deserved their chance to push for a comeback-completing winner. Cork deserved their right to re-establish a lead once more. Such an enthralling encounter should’ve been allowed to play out its finale, win, lose or draw. We’ll never know how it could’ve ended.

Time for Tipperary’s class of 2016 to step up

It’s been two years since Tipperary last showed their full scope in championship fare. That 2016 All-Ireland final win over Kilkenny has not been built upon to its potential, but perhaps the minors who also lit up Croke Park that day could be the answer. They were endlessly impressive in a year which included the seven-goal rout of Galway.

Yesterday, we saw the first flash from that team at senior level to end an impressive, if belated, backlash. Jake Morris, who was only recently called into the panel, has the potential to be the real deal. So do fellow panellists Ger Browne, Mark Kehoe and a few others.

Cork’s collapse won’t damage their All-Ireland ambitions

Having been in position to complete back-to-back victories in Thurles, a second-half deficit of 0-8 to 1-14 fell far below Cork’s standards. They had their chances to kill off Tipperary and send them into crisis but didn’t do so. A fair share of wrong options and needless turnovers contributed to that but Tipp forced them into mistakes too. What happens most recently remains in the mind longer, however, it’s not just about how Cork lost their lead, but how they rebuilt a three-point cushion before Tipp’s final charge.

It shouldn’t just be about Sean O’Donoghue fumbling with the ball late on but his two second-half block-downs. It shouldn’t just be about the goals conceded but Anthony Nash’s mind-bogging reaction save, nor the scores conceded but Shane Kingston’s 1-5.

They withstood a Tipperary storm and emerged in good nick. If they can make a few fixes, there’s so much to work with.

This story first appeared in the Irish Examiner.


Related Articles

Transfer rule change would help city clubs

The week when we were all Mullinalaghta

Cork's divisional debate: Time for change or maintain the status quo?

Tipperary give Liam Sheedy winning start against All-Ireland champions Limerick

More in this Section

Sarri calls on Chelsea players to keep up winning ways

Rocky Fielding floored four times as Saul Canelo Alvarez romps to victory

Real Madrid coach Solari happy to end 2018 on winning note

Unflappable Taylor sees off challenge from Wahlstrom in New York


Lifestyle

Renegade cattle make bid for freedom

Preserving the past, looking to future

Allie’s in wonderland

Wild salmon at risk

More From The Irish Examiner