VAR turning into a search for refereeing perfection

Canada’s Kadeisha Buchanan, right, reacts after scoring against Cameroon in the Women’s World Cup Group E clash in Montpellier last night. Picture: AP Photo/Claude Paris.

Former Uefa president Michel Platini always opposed the introduction of technology in football because he felt that, once it gained a foothold, it would quickly expand and change the character of the sport altogether.

Football, he warned, was about to open Pandora’s Box. Several years later, the Frenchman may feel he has been proved right by the pervasive use of video assistant referees (VAR).

When it initially presented VAR in 2016, soccer’s rule-making body IFAB said the purpose was to stamp out glaring refereeing mistakes such as Diego Maradona’s ‘hand of God’ goal in the 1986 World Cup.

But, less than 18 months after its introduction, it has turned into what seems to be a search for refereeing perfection.

Matches are now stopped for two to three minutes and goal celebrations put on hold while VAR officials in a room full of television monitors conduct a forensic examination for the slightest hint of contact or offside in the build-up.

In the Women’s World Cup, Griedge Mbock Bathy had a wonderful strike for France disallowed against South Korea because the tip of her foot was ahead of the last defender, even though the rest of her body was in line.

Meanwhile in the Nations League in Portugal, England had two goals disallowed after VAR reviews when not even their opponents complained of an infraction.

Callum Wilson’s late goal against Switzerland on Sunday was chalked off after VAR spotted that he pushed Manuel Akanji in the build-up, while Jesse Lingard’s effort against The Netherlands was ruled out because part of his body was a fraction offside.

All three decisions were technically correct, but was that what VAR was intended for? And were they in the spirit of the offside rule which is designed primarily to stop forwards goal-hanging?

When preliminary testing began, IFAB’s technical director David Elleray said that “VAR isn’t designed to end referee mistakes, but it’s to deal with those very clear match-changing ones.”

As an example, he cited Thierry Henry’s goal, scored after he controlled the ball with his arm, which took France to the 2010 World Cup at Ireland’s expense — hardly the same as a player having their finger three centimetres offside.

In a briefing to reporters earlier this year, Uefa’s refereeing chief Roberto Rosetti said that the incidents were reviewed if they were obvious to VAR officials — not simply players, coaches, or spectators.

Linesmen are now told to keep their flags down when they suspect an offside so the incident can be reviewed in the studio once the move finishes, effectively reducing their role.

Sometimes, VAR can be as controversial as a decision taken with the naked eye, such as the penalty awarded to England against Scotland in Sunday’s Women’s World Cup match for handball by Nicola Docherty, when there seemed to be no way she could get her arm out of the way.

Equally contentious was a penalty given to Switzerland against Portugal in the Nations League for the slightest of tugs on Steven Zuber.

Former World Cup final referee Arnaldo Cesar Coelho warned last year that slow motion could make fouls and handballs appear deliberate when they really were not.

“Slow motion distorts the incident because it does not always reflect the intensity of the movement,” he said.

The Zuber incident raised another awkward question — when to stop play for a review — after Portugal immediately broke down the other end and were awarded a penalty of their own. Amid huge confusion, Portugal’s penalty was revoked and a spot-kick was awarded to Switzerland.

Portugal coach Fernando Santos suggested that VAR was a good idea — but only if properly used.

I think VAR is important, I think it can help, but those who are in charge have to pay attention to this.

“Otherwise we will all start saying that VAR is no good when it could be a really useful tool.”

More on this topic

Lindahl's super save sends Sweden through to World Cup quarter-finals

Norwich sign Switzerland striker Josip Drmic on a free transfer

Rapinoe strikes twice from the spot to guide USA into World Cup quarter-finals

Ireland international Andy Boyle rejoins Dundalk

More in this Section

Laois end Kildare reign in U20 Football Championship

U19 manager Tom Mohan bids to make most of Ireland options

Mullen endures European Games frustration

Luca Connell: ‘Robbie Keane asked us to strike the bar from 30 yards...I did it first time’


Hozier adds more believers to his church after Cork gig

Simply off the wall: Your go-to guide to shelving

Peter Dowdall shares his top 4 flower picks to add a splash of summer colour to your garden

Ask a counsellor: ‘Why does my husband hate that our daughter’s dating a man going through divorce?’

More From The Irish Examiner