Man City sought damages from UEFA over alleged leaks concerning Financial Fair Play case

Man City sought damages from UEFA over alleged leaks concerning Financial Fair Play case

Manchester City sought damages from UEFA over what they alleged were leaks of confidential information to the media concerning their Financial Fair Play case, court documents show.

Details of City’s appeal against UEFA’s FFP investigation are contained in written reasons published by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS).

In November last year CAS announced City’s appeal to halt UEFA’s FFP investigation was “inadmissible” because UEFA’s Club Financial Control Body (CFCB) had not yet determined what, if any, punishment the club should face if found guilty of breaching spending controls.

These ongoing and egregious breaches undermine the very integrity of UEFA’s adjudicatory process, which is a consensual dispute resolution mechanism with confidentiality at its core

The full appeal judgement shows that City argued a decision by the CFCB investigatory chamber to refer the case to its adjudicatory chamber had been taken “improperly and prematurely”.

They also argued UEFA had “systematically breached, and continues to breach, its express obligations of confidentiality”, claiming individuals working within the governing body were briefing journalists. As a result, they said, the investigation should be suspended, and UEFA should conduct an inquiry into the alleged leaks.

“These ongoing and egregious breaches undermine the very integrity of UEFA’s adjudicatory process, which is a consensual dispute resolution mechanism with confidentiality at its core,” City said in their written appeal submission.

The New York Times published an article days before UEFA announced the referral decision in May 2019 that investigators were seeking a Champions League ban over the alleged FFP breaches.

The head of the CFCB’s investigatory chamber Yves Leterme responded to City’s claims of leaks in an angry letter sent in May last year, just after the decision to refer City to the AC was announced.

Your allegations are groundless in the merits and unacceptable in tone

In it, he wrote: “I must vehemently reject your allegations of unlawful activities, either by myself or by any of the members of the UEFA CFCB, in particular of its Investigatory Chamber (IC).

“Your allegations are groundless in the merits and unacceptable in tone.

“Please be advised that I will not continue such an exchange of correspondence and that I will not respond further to groundless accusations directed against me personally and/or against my fellow members of the IC.”

City argued in its appeal that “the Swiss law personality rights of the appellant (City) have been violated by the leaks and that the respondent (UEFA) is responsible for such violation”.

CAS ruled City’s appeal inadmissible, and all further motions were dismissed. In respect of the claim for damages and City’s call for an investigation into alleged leaks, CAS said it could not be pursued solely before any decision had been rendered by the adjudicatory chamber.

Allegations that City had breached FFP rules were published by German magazine Der Spiegel.

No announcement on the outcome of City’s case has yet been made by the CFCB’s adjudicatory chamber. City strenuously deny any wrongdoing.

More on this topic

Shane Casey's trip to Anfield: What about Bob? What about me?Shane Casey's trip to Anfield: What about Bob? What about me?

Leeds goalkeeper Kiko Casilla handed eight-game suspensionLeeds goalkeeper Kiko Casilla handed eight-game suspension

Concussion substitutes could be trialled at Olympic GamesConcussion substitutes could be trialled at Olympic Games

FIFA president Infantino favours ‘daylight’ offside lawFIFA president Infantino favours ‘daylight’ offside law

More in this Section

Five key storylines to follow at the National Indoor ChampionshipsFive key storylines to follow at the National Indoor Championships

Weekend previews and predictions: Old rivalries renewed as League campaigns enter crunch phaseWeekend previews and predictions: Old rivalries renewed as League campaigns enter crunch phase

Only chosen few may be allowed speak to refereesOnly chosen few may be allowed speak to referees

Harty Cup postponement may have big impact on sidelinesHarty Cup postponement may have big impact on sidelines


Lifestyle

Prepare to fall for leather, whatever the weather, says Annmarie O'Connor.Trend of the week: It's always leather weather

The starting point for Michael West’s new play, in this joint production by Corn Exchange and the Abbey, is an alternative, though highly familiar, 1970s Ireland. You know, elections every few weeks, bad suits, wide ties, and a seedy nexus of politics and property development.Theatre Review: The Fall of the Second Republic at Abbey Theatre, Dublin

The Cork-led band played a superb gig in Dublin, writes Ed Power.REVIEW: The Murder Capital, Vicar Street

Lack of physical activity also causing disturbance of children’s sleep patterns.Under-fives suffering lack of sleep from extended screen time, doctor says

More From The Irish Examiner