Murphy makes case for sin bin

Frank Murphy

Cork GAA secretary Frank Murphy has asked clubs to consider, for non-championship inter-county fixtures, a player being sin-binned, as opposed to sent off, when receiving a second yellow card.

Clubs are being invited to propose football and hurling rule changes to the standing playing rules committee, which could be recommended to Central Council to form a motion for Congress or come into operation on a temporary basis for next year’s pre-season and Allianz League games.

At Tuesday’s Cork county board meeting, Murphy outlined the merits of having a player sin-binned, instead of being sent off, when picking up a second yellow.

The sin bin was experimented with in pre-season competitions in early 2005 — whereby a player was put off for 10 minutes upon being shown a yellow card — but didn’t survive the league. Cork brought a motion to Congress that year which proposed 10 minutes spent on the sideline be the sanction for receiving two yellow cards. It failed to garner sufficient backing.

“My recall of that Congress is there was tremendously strong approval for it from Congress,” said Murphy, “but the point was made by Kingdom representatives relative to its operation at club level and the difficulties that might be experienced at club level in being able to control the time of play a player would be off for. I would say had this point not been made, it would have likely been fairly well carried.

That influenced Congress because at that time, whatever rule you had it applied to inter-county and club, but there have been changes since in terms of that approach. The question I am asking you to give a viewpoint on is; why not experiment once more with it at inter-county level?

Continued the Cork GAA secretary: “In regard to yellow cards generally, they are often very harshly imposed. The referee, maybe, at the beginning of the match, can be more strict than later on.”

This can lead, said Murphy, to players being sent off for “minor offences”.

Although 2020 is the normal year for the consideration of the revision of playing rules, the standing playing rules committee has the power to propose to Central Council motions on any given year and there is also the facility for playing rules changes to be trialled in non-championship games next year.

Elsewhere at Tuesday’s county board meeting, John O’Donovan of Clann na nGael remarked: “There is something systemic wrong with Cork football at the moment”.

More on this topic

Cork forward Luke Connolly out of crucial Armagh tie

Clinical Cody sends St Kieran's back to All Ireland final

Duhallow cruise to victory over Imokilly

Avondhu crash out of championship following defeat by Muskerry

More in this Section

Anscombe hopeful Wales can keep their winning habit going at the World Cup

Birmingham deducted nine points after breaching EFL financial rules

The major talking points ahead of Republic of Ireland’s game with Gibraltar

Cork's Brian Lenihan tackles mental health at exhibition talk


Has KRIB sounded the death knell for the immersion?

Bake: Delicious recipes with chocolate - the ultimate dessert ingredient

Trend of the week: How to simmer in a boiler suit

Ask an expert: Is my IVF child more likely to have behaviour problems?

More From The Irish Examiner