League talking points: Something for everyone in Tralee and Cork's defensiveness

League talking points: Something for everyone in Tralee and Cork's defensiveness

Our writers round-up the biggest talking points from the weekend's League action...

Something for everyone

Colm Cooper

It’s a toss-up who benefited more from the glamour clash of the football weekend in Tralee. Kerry’s talented youngsters passed a rigorous test of their mettle against the All-Ireland champions. In doing so, however, they’ve also given Jim Gavin’s season a proper leg-up. Kerry are coming, that seems pretty certain. I’m getting excited at what their forward line will look like come championship time.

Might they go with four out-and-out forwards and two grafters? Clifford, Geaney, O’Donoghue, Sean O’Shea, and Stephen O’Brien might have seemed in pole position at the start of the year, but suddenly there’s a different conversation kicking off.

Determined to stick with defensive setup

Kieran Shannon

Will Cork stick with their defensive-oriented setup and style of play when it has yet to win them a game in this year’s league as well as the hearts of any purist?

Ronan McCarthy made it clear after his team’s loss in Ennis yesterday that they would, alluding to the fact they had conceded just 0-8 (against Fermanagh) and 1-10 (against Kildare) before being hit for 3-13 by Clare.

“It’s disappointing to see what we did after being so defensively sound for the first two leagues.

“But we’re not going to go away from what we’re doing and we’ll try and keep it going and we have two weeks to get it right for the Meath game.”

The priority, obviously, is to be hard to score against and hard to beat ahead of being easy to watch. But if it’s hard to play that way — as in it’s not much fun to do so — can the players have the enthusiasm and verve to play well enough to win?

In trying to catch up with how football has evolved post-2010, Cork with this defensive system may be behind the times again.

Rules and rewards

John Fogarty

After setting the example of how to use the offensive mark against Dublin, Monaghan only managed two in Inniskeen yesterday.

Conor McManus caught the ball for both of them but none produced scores. Despite a strong wind in the first half which one might think would have given more cause to use the experimental rule, Galway virtually ignored it.

None of the new rules made this awful game of football any better, which will be some cause for concern given they are leading teams.

Narrow margins at play in Division 2

Eoghan Cormican

Division 2 has proven to be the most competitive and closely fought of the four tiers.

Three points is all that separates Meath (four points) at the head of the table and Cork (one) at the foot of Division 2, while there are only two points between counties in the promotion and relegation spots (second-placed Fermanagh are on four, while seventh-placed Armagh are on two).

This is one division where it is absolutely certain that nothing will be guaranteed until the final round of games.

“This division is all over the place,” said Tipperary’s Liam Kearns. “Everything is still up for grabs, promotion and relegation. To me, we need three more points to do what we want to do, which is to stay in Division 2.”

Donegal, despite their first loss of the campaign, remain favourites to finish top of Division 2, particularly with three of their remaining four games to be played at home. “We have to be better and have to be more clinical than we were here (in Thurles). We can’t make mistakes like that again,” Declan Bonner said.

Horan doesn’t understand Cafferkey critics

Edwin McGreal

Many in Mayo were quick to slam the selection of Ger Cafferkey at full-back ahead of Saturday night’s game, with many taking to social media to express their ‘thoughts’.

The Ballina man has, arguably, not been the same player since a severe hamstring injury in 2016.

However, he left with the man-of-the-match prize on Saturday evening with a display reminding everyone why he is an All Star full-back. His manager James Horan was clearly aware of the criticism when he was asked about it afterwards.

“Those fans who give out about Ger Caff... I really don’t understand it.

“We’ve open sessions here every Tuesday and Friday and if they want to come down and see how he’s playing, it might give them a better idea of the type of form that he is in. I think it (Cavan) was one of his best games.

“We gave away so many turnovers and they had numbers back so they were attacking in numbers and they tried to isolate Ger in there.

“I just thought he was superb, he was simply outstanding tonight.”

More on this topic

Personal touch lured O’Connor to LilywhitesPersonal touch lured O’Connor to Lilywhites

English: Tweak system to help Munster championsEnglish: Tweak system to help Munster champions

Cluxton should get footballer of the year awardCluxton should get footballer of the year award

Tipperary's Jerome Cahill named U-20 Hurler of the YearTipperary's Jerome Cahill named U-20 Hurler of the Year

More in this Section

Shouldering the nation’s hopes: three players Ireland cannot afford to loseShouldering the nation’s hopes: three players Ireland cannot afford to lose

McIlroy off to nightmare start at WentworthMcIlroy off to nightmare start at Wentworth

Spurs slip-up as City bounce back – 5 things we learned from Champions LeagueSpurs slip-up as City bounce back – 5 things we learned from Champions League

Shakhtar are no pushovers and can still cause us problems at Etihad – GuardiolaShakhtar are no pushovers and can still cause us problems at Etihad – Guardiola


The American heritage brand has put together a collection inspired by the most stylish Friends character.This is why Rachel Green’s style is the epitome of Ralph Lauren – as a new collection is announced

When starting out as a comedian, Cork man Andrew Ryan decided to go to straight to London, sidestepping the usual starting ground of Irish clubs and pubs.Cork comedian Andrew Ryan is 'a cross between Ardal O’Hanlon and Ed Byrne'

Rachel Marie Walsh knows the best eyeliners to try this season.Beauty is in the eye of the beholder: Essential eyeliners for a killer look

Paul McLauchlan has the lowdown from London Fashion Week. Here’s all you need to know about next season.London Fashion Week: How you’ll dress for the next decade

More From The Irish Examiner