Football’s fines, bans, and hashtags are powerless in face of racism scourge

Football’s fines, bans, and hashtags are powerless in face of racism scourge

Working on the Irish TV coverage of Bulgaria v England on Monday night acted as another reminder of how silly a job it can be at times.

I refer to that moment when you are debating whether to spend half-time discussing the depressing scenes of racist abuse to which black England players were subjected, or Harry Winks’ performance in midfield.

Winks or racism? Hmmm.

With the planet in a state of chassis, it is now quite a regular occurrence to have the comfort zone of football chat invaded by nasty, real-world stuff.

Racism, terrorism, the FAI’s finances — any of these grave topics are liable to crop up in a realm normally restricted to debates about dubious penalties and Paul Pogba’s hair-dos.

It can be tricky to strike the right tone when one is asking football men to comment on matters outside their purview.

Most are not experts in what are usually complicated, nuanced issues worthy of 5,000-word articles in The Economist rather than three minutes between commercial breaks.

Too often there is little more to be said than, “it really puts football in perspective,” and then move on.

Take BBC’s coverage of the 2010 World Cup, for example, when they sent pundits to film segments about South Africa’s dark history.

Alan Shearer wandered around townships and gazed glumly into Mandela’s cell in Robben Island.

“Tough times for your family when that happened,” he observed to a local whose brother had been gunned down in gang violence. (To be fair, Mark Lawrenson on the Battle of the Spion Kop was surprisingly good.)

Fortunately, in Brian Kerr, we had someone who is not only well able to hold forth on matters outside football, but has also specifically campaigned against racism in sport for some time.

Brian told us about his work with Sport Against Racism Ireland who, through the European body Football Against Racism Europe, have long been pushing Uefa to take much stronger action on this issue.

“They’ve been far too lenient,” said Kerr. “Mickey Mouse fines, partial ground closures, it’s not enough, and putting the onus on the referee and putting the pressure on the players is not enough.

"It’s time that they stood up and took real, real action. It’s a horrendous carry-on.”

Well said, and the circumstances of Monday night meant it was hard to argue about the weakness of Uefa’s pea-shooter diplomacy.

Bulgaria, remember, were literally being punished for past racist incidents in this very match, in the form of a partial stadium closure, a measure whose ineffectiveness was grimly self-evident.

In the aftermath of Sofia, the Nazi salutes were followed by the pointing of fingers. Many observers joined Brian in scorning Uefa’s preference for feather duster over iron rod.

Others pointed out the hypocrisy of the English media in downplaying the xenophobia of their own support, with their conquests of European town squares and booing of opposition national anthems.

Herein lay the irony of the Brexit brigade in Sofia singing: “You racist bastards, you know what you are!”

On it went. The English attacked the Bulgarians. The Bulgarians shrugged their shoulders and said they heard nothing.

The Bulgarian prime minister called on the head of the Bulgarian FA to stand down.

The Bulgarian prime minister’s critics pointed out how his own racist rhetoric and tolerance of the far right had led to this point.

The British prime minister demanded strong action from Uefa. The British prime minister’s critics pointed out how his own racist rhetoric and tolerance of the far right meant he was hardly one to talk.

Defending Uefa’s record on racism, president Alexander Ceferin looked to the bigger picture.

“Football associations themselves cannot solve this problem. Governments too need to do more in this area,” he said.

Racism is society’s problem, so leave me to my rinky-dink hashtags and €15,000 fines, he seemed to say.

It’s easy to point the finger in situations like this, especially when there is so much blame to go around.

Few bother to look at what makes a bunch of young Bulgarian lads decide it was a good idea to spend a Monday night abusing black footballers from a faraway land.

If it feels inadequate to be talking about it on TV soccer panels, that’s because of the sheer vastness and complexity of the issue.

After all, Monday night’s scenes crystallised some of the great existential challenges of our time.

Bulgaria is the EU’s poorest country. Corruption and organised crime are rife. Far-right organisations have capitalised by scapegoating immigrants and racial minorities.

Needless to say, none of these issues are unique to Bulgaria.

Football’s fines, bans, and hashtags are powerless in face of racism scourge

Increased immigration, exacerbated by the effects of climate change, vast income inequalities caused by rapacious capitalism and the abuse of Big Tech’s omnipotence to promote hate speech: that’s pretty much the global shitstorm right there.

Anyone of influence in Britain should see the parallels between their own societal breakdown and what we saw in the stands in the Vasil Levski Stadium.

It turns out the No Surrender yobbos and the neo-Nazi hoodies have more in common than they realise, but “You racist bastards, we understand and empathise with the deeper socio-economic causes of your actions!” doesn’t scan as well.

Maybe Uefa should kick Bulgaria out of football until it cleans up its act. And then all the other countries with racist fans.

But that won’t butter many parsnips for Alexander Ceferin in the next presidential election, so it’s not going to happen.

Football, with its fines, bans, and hashtags, feels pretty powerless with this one, even if it should do better.

This is a big problem that needs a big solution, but we’re pretty bad at that sort of thing right now.

Alas, finger-pointing is all we are going to get from the people who could make an actual difference here; if they won’t come together to sort out the actual apocalypse, then the well-being of Tyrone Mings must be pretty low on their list of priorities.

Maybe we should have gone with Harry Winks after all.

More on this topic

Italian sports newspaper accused of fuelling racism with ‘Black Friday’ headlineItalian sports newspaper accused of fuelling racism with ‘Black Friday’ headline

Aleksander Ceferin insists UEFA is ‘trying’ in fight against racismAleksander Ceferin insists UEFA is ‘trying’ in fight against racism

Amazon remove Auschwitz-themed Christmas adsAmazon remove Auschwitz-themed Christmas ads

‘Institutional racism in its rawest form’‘Institutional racism in its rawest form’

More in this Section

The bond exists forever’: John Giles misses Premier League punditry to be with old Leeds palsThe bond exists forever’: John Giles misses Premier League punditry to be with old Leeds pals

Jose Mourinho gets reminder of scale of Spurs rebuildJose Mourinho gets reminder of scale of Spurs rebuild

Divock Origi double leaves Everton boss Marco Silva on the brinkDivock Origi double leaves Everton boss Marco Silva on the brink

Provinces to be redrawn in GAA’s bold new eraProvinces to be redrawn in GAA’s bold new era

More by this author

Tommy Martin: As soon as Jim averts his gaze, Dublin’s gone to the Bleedin’ RapidsTommy Martin: As soon as Jim averts his gaze, Dublin’s gone to the Bleedin’ Rapids

Tommy Martin: Driven by an internal flame, Sonia got it all out of herselfTommy Martin: Driven by an internal flame, Sonia got it all out of herself

Spurs swap romance for a quick but costly reboundSpurs swap romance for a quick but costly rebound

Southgate may pay for making ‘Saipan-lite’ publicSouthgate may pay for making ‘Saipan-lite’ public


Lifestyle

The Marquee in Cork dominated the gig news this week, with a string of announcements for what is expected to be the final year at the Monahan Road venue before the site is developedScene + Heard: The most played artist on Spotify and all the latest music news

Esther N McCarthy picks perfect paperweights, brilliant books and Christmas collectables this week.Brilliant books and Christmas collectables - here's our wish list

John Spillane tells Ellie O’Byrne how he’s hoping to fund his next album by taking the bardic route of writing unique compositions for people on whatever they’d like‘I’ll write you a song for €1,000' - John Spillane's unique way to fund new album

From starring in a Cork-set film, to securing a role in Ridley Scott’s major new HBO series, it has been quite a year for Niamh Algar, writes Esther McCarthyIreland’s next big thing: Niamh Algar on her incredible year

More From The Irish Examiner