Ireland’s culture of fear, Manchester United’s lost culture

Ireland’s culture of fear, Manchester United’s lost culture

Kevin Kilbane seems a nice guy. He was, as Gilesy might say, a good servant. But as the latest Ireland inquest rolled on, he did an extraordinary thing on Newstalk’s Off The Ball: he blamed Aaron Connolly for Switzerland’s first goal in Geneva last Tuesday night.

Indeed, Kevin went so far as to suggest the youngster will be lucky to start against Denmark next month because of this gaffe, and the inexperience he showed in making it. He is learning on the job, Kevin warned.

A rewind of the goal finds Connolly winning a free kick deep in his own half. He trudges dutifully upfield, ready to ‘run the channels’ for the latest hopeful launch forward, a miserable exercise that was already visibly annoying him.

The free-kick is taken short to James McClean who slices his ‘delivery’ wildly to find touch in a manner that would gain generous acclaim in Tokyo this morning. Stephan Lichtsteiner throws to Granit Xhaka, off whom Allan Browne had briefly wandered, on the halfway line and there are six more touches before the ball ends up in Ireland’s net.

Sure, it’s possible to make the case that Connolly might have positioned himself better at the throw-in to prevent the ball getting to Xhaka, or being moved on to the advancing Manuel Akanji. Just as you could query James Collins’ position, or Browne’s, or the conservative deployment of Ireland’s wing backs, at that moment.

You could argue Jeff Hendrick and Glenn Whelan should have done better with headers in the seconds that followed. That Ireland shouldn’t have been camped on the edge of their own penalty area. Or that HarisSeferovic might have been closed down quicker before his fine finish.

You might even blame Ronnie Whelan in commentary, who assumed George Hamilton’s traditional jinxing role by declaring that everything was going very well, as the throw-in was being taken.

But to pick out Connolly, when the genesis of the entire passage was McClean’s wild hoof, perhaps shows how immersion in Irish international football’s unique ways over many years can shape your mindset.

If you are exposed to enough of it, if you are in deep, you will instinctively worry first about what might go wrong if all safety measures haven’t been applied, rather than what might go right if you passed the ball to your teammates. You will be concerned primarily about what might happen if you’re not blocking space, rather than ask what might happen if you try to create it.

It’s a way of thinking that sees expendable luxury in footballers whose natural instinct is to use the ball constructively. I suppose it is what they mean when they talk about culture. And it should cause us genuine fear about just what young Connolly will learn on this job.

Ireland’s culture of fear, Manchester United’s lost culture

But enough about Ireland. The debate about our ‘style’ will never end until something different is tried. Until then, we will never truly know if we just, as so many of our managers have assured us, don’t have the players.

The week allowed us to hear from another nice guy, someone uniquely positioned as a witness at a pivotal moment in history, at a time when a great empire has crumbled. Juan Mata’s new book Suddenly a Footballer reaches us just as Manchester United prepare to face Liverpool. And remain intent on emulating the nineties disintegration of their bitter rivals’ glory era.

Back then, the steepness of decline was as much of a mystery. Did stress take Kenny’s eye off the ball? Did Graeme Souness purge too much experience? Did his strictness break the spirit? Or did Roy Evans go too soft as a corrective? Was it all down to chairman David Moores’ laissez faire stewardship? Did they just, for whatever unfathomable reason, stop signing good players?

A witness, the young Jamie Carragher, has recalled Julian Dicks being lapped on circuits of the training ground and it not being an issue. A way of thinking had set in. A culture, you could say. United’s collapse is another stew of many ingredients.

Was Fellaini a totem of Moyes’ devaluation of technical quality? Did van Gaal’s efforts to restore order suck out the excitement? Did the Mourinho quick fix inject terminal levels of toxicity? In trying to reset, did they turn to a man who’s bringing nothing at all?

Maybe it’s just bad signings. Or all the Glazers’ fault. Or Ed Woodward’s reassurances that results don’t really impact the bottom line. Mata, who arrived at the club months into the great fall, could be a perfect witness. Alas, we have to read this book between the lines.

The Spaniard appears a likable, thoughtful man, with a social conscience — 99% of the book’s proceeds go to Common Goal, the charity he co-founded. He is also a loyal employee. What has gone wrong in the dressing room stays in the dressing room.

But there are hints as to his way of thinking. He bemoans the “society of ego” and that “the need for attention, for followers, for recognition is developing beyond sanity”. He’d have preferred to play in a bygone era, with greater passion, when “the business side was less important”.

He selects, as his perfect dressing room, the Spanish World Cup winners. But as he worries about what place slower creators like him have in the game’s future, you can’t help wonder why United just tied him to a new three-year contract at 31, when they clearly can’t work out quite what to do with him.

And as we reflect on mysterious shifts in mindset, it is notable, late in the book, that Mata complains about the importance given to “the result”, and wishes that winning shouldn’t be regarded as the only thing. A reminder he arrived a few months after Alex Ferguson’s departure. And that he wasn’t exposed to a very different way of thinking.

More on this topic

Parrott: 'Walking out in green in my home town was the best feeling ever'Parrott: 'Walking out in green in my home town was the best feeling ever'

Sean Maguire: Ireland victory important for qualifier against DenmarkSean Maguire: Ireland victory important for qualifier against Denmark

Player ratings from Ireland's victory over New ZealandPlayer ratings from Ireland's victory over New Zealand

Ireland ease to comeback victory on night of firsts against New ZealandIreland ease to comeback victory on night of firsts against New Zealand

More in this Section

Catriona Matthew to captain Europe again in 2021 Solheim CupCatriona Matthew to captain Europe again in 2021 Solheim Cup

Football rumours from the mediaFootball rumours from the media

Mullins plans another light campaign for Photo en route to CheltenhamMullins plans another light campaign for Photo en route to Cheltenham

Nathan Collins confident of U21 chances in ArmeniaNathan Collins confident of U21 chances in Armenia

More by this author

We were all wrong about VAR but it’ll be grandWe were all wrong about VAR but it’ll be grand

When life’s a bench in Crouchy’s sub-cultureWhen life’s a bench in Crouchy’s sub-culture

Connolly’s quantum leap to upset Ireland’s time travel plans?Connolly’s quantum leap to upset Ireland’s time travel plans?

Who's been laughing at Rugby Country?Who's been laughing at Rugby Country?


In an industry where women battle ageism and sexism, Meryl Streep has managed to decide her own destiny – and roles, writes Suzanne HarringtonJeepers Streepers: Hollywood royalty, all hail queen Meryl

'Ask Audrey' has been the newspaper's hysterical agony aunt “for ages, like”.Ask Audrey: Guten tag. Vot the f**k is the story with your cycle lanes?

Daphne Wright’s major new exhibition at the Crawford addresses such subjects as ageing and consumerism, writes Colette SheridanFinding inspiration in domestic situations

Christian Bale and Matt Damon tell Laura Harding about their roles in Le Mans ‘66, the tale of the men paid by Ford to take on the dominance of Ferrari in the motor-racing worldFoot to the floor: Christian Bale and Matt Damon talk about Ford, Ferrari and the 24 hours of Le Mans

More From The Irish Examiner