Irate county footballers can learn plenty from Thunberg defiance

Irate county footballers can learn plenty from Thunberg defiance
Special Congress 2017.

Some Friday protests are more powerful than others.

Seven days before schoolchildren around the world took to the streets to demonstrate the urgent need for climate action, the GPA issued a statement requesting that the GAA’s Central Council held off approving a proposal for a two-tier football championship to go forward at a special Congress in Cork next month; the fixtures task force would be reporting its recommendations in November, so why rush in some format that could be inconsistent with them?

Central Council paid no heed though, and the following day, just hours before the replayed All-Ireland football final, it proceeded with what Greta Thunberg might describe as “business as usual”.

At Special Congress on October 19, a proposal for a two-tier championship, very much along the lines and wishes of president John Horan, will duly be on the Clár.

Now it goes without saying that a Division Three footballer having an unwanted B championship foisted upon him hardly qualifies on the same scale of injustice and outrage as the climate crisis and the possible extinction of the human race that so alarms Thunberg and her army of followers, but there are some things about her and the movement she has inspired that players could learn from.

Twenty years on from its inception, and over a decade after on from the Cork crises and the threat of strike action over player grants, the GPA, like its more recently-born cousin the CPA, appears to have abandoned any form or spirit of militancy — not least because its various player welfare programmes are handsomely subsidised by finances from its agreement with Croke Park.

In turn, it has been awarded and represented on some of the GAA’s most high-power committees, including seats at Central Council and Congress, and indeed that fixture task group that is due to submit its findings within the next two months.

But they’re only one seat, one body, in all those settings. They are outnumbered, and consequently, sometimes ignored.

What they, or at least their constituency, needs to remember though, is that they need not be corralled to just the one table.

Often there is an air of resignation among the wider public, players, and media when it comes to some matters such as these B championship proposals.

There is almost an acceptance that because the ‘powers that be’ want something to get through, it will inevitably get through.

It was the case with Paraic Duffy and his Super 8 proposals — the director-general of the time wanted them through, and so he duly got his way.

The same now with Horan and these B championship proposals. They are his baby, his wanted legacy, and so, the perceived wisdom is, it’ll come to pass and he’ll get his way.

It doesn’t have to be that way, though.

If 32 counties vote against Central Council’s motion, then it will be blocked.

All but one of the 32 counties have a senior football panel. There is nothing stopping them convening in the coming days, that bit earlier before they’d meeting up for the resumption of collective training anyway, and coming to a group decision as to how they want their county board to vote on the matter at Special Congress in Cork.

According to the GPA’s chief executive Paul Flynn, the players aren’t necessarily against a two-tier championship per se.

“There is an appetite for one,” he clarified last week. “Not this one.”

Horan, to use a slogan from many of the placards on display last Friday, has no Plan B on a B championship. His is pure knockout, once more guaranteeing a Wicklow just the two games.

Part of the genius and appeal of Thunberg is how she speaks truth — with conviction — to power.

With or without the GPA, county footballers can do the same to their county board officials.

Tell them that they’re not interested in business as usual. That their eyes will be upon them. That they will hold them accountable.

It has long been the way of the world, be it that of politics or the GAA, that older people make decisions that hugely affect young people who can’t vote directly on the matter.

But what the Friday strike protests have shown is that just because they don’t yet have a vote, doesn’t mean they can’t have a voice.

The players also have another weapon, as another rebel — or at least how he was portrayed in a major film — once pointed out. In Neil Jordan’s Michael Collins, the main character, played by Liam Neeson, is at a rally when he reminds the natives of what weapon is.

“That weapon,” he says, “is our refusal.”

If players were to make it clear that they would not stick around next summer to participate in some token B championship, what county board could consciously vote for it when, after all, it’s supposed to be for the benefit of the players?

The alternative is that the players do not convene and inform their respective county board about their objection to Horan’s and Central Council’s proposal.

Should they choose that course, then they then can hardly complain after the fact should Horan’s motion was passed.

More in this Section

Is there a dawn to follow the darkest moment?Is there a dawn to follow the darkest moment?

A victory for bravery, a defeat reeking of stagnationA victory for bravery, a defeat reeking of stagnation

Emery believes Arsenal can achieve something important this seasonEmery believes Arsenal can achieve something important this season

Real Sociedad return to winning ways to go fourth in LaLigaReal Sociedad return to winning ways to go fourth in LaLiga

More by this author

Challenging times for Clare in hurling’s bold new eraChallenging times for Clare in hurling’s bold new era

Sadlier’s honesty can help others on road to recoverySadlier’s honesty can help others on road to recovery

Japan misstep stung, but Ireland may yet take down a big gunJapan misstep stung, but Ireland may yet take down a big gun

It’s time for football’s slumbering giants to awaken and help themselvesIt’s time for football’s slumbering giants to awaken and help themselves


'When a role became available in The River Lee following the refurbishment, I jumped at the chance!'You've Been Served: Sinead McDonald of The River Lee on life as a Brand Manager

It’s the personal stories from Bruce Springsteen that turn his new ‘Western Stars’ documentary into something special, the director tells Esther McCarthy.Bruce Springsteen's Western Stars documentary more than just a music film

Apart from the several variations in its spelling in Irish and English, Inishtubbrid, Co Clare is also recognised by three other names: Wall’s Island; O’Grady’s Island and Inishtubber which surely puts it up there as the island with most names — not counting say Inisvickillane, Co Kerry which has about 33 variations to that spelling.The Islands of Ireland: In search of tranquility

More and more communities and volunteers are taking on environmental tasks around the country. In Clonmel, Co Tipperary, for example, people have united to get rid of Himalayan balsam, an invasive plant, from the banks of the River Suir.‘Bashing’ invasive plants

More From The Irish Examiner