Mayo-Galway was the kind of game a ref doesn't want

Mayo-Galway was the kind of game a ref doesn't want

As a referee, there are games you look at and are so glad that you aren’t involved in. Mayo-Galway on Saturday night was as difficult a match to officiate as you can get. 

It got very nasty towards the end and the amount of flashpoints both on and off the ball made it a damn tough evening for Joe McQuillan.

How anyone could expect somebody to keep proper tabs on it, I don’t know. Joe was a little bit hard on Galway early on, but the main talking points affected both counties. 

For one, he booked the wrong men in Cillian O’Connor and Ian Burke when it was Antain Ó Laoi and Kevin McLoughlin who were wrestling on the ground.

Burke was later shown a black card, which ended up as a red because of that yellow.

Later, O’Connor avoided a yellow

when he and Declan Kyne were involved in an off-the-ball matter. He was perhaps lucky to avoid picking up a second yellow.

Joe did make a good call for the penalty as Chris Barrett did catch him, but then earlier Damien Comer could easily have been shown a black card for a trip. 

Mayo-Galway was the kind of game a ref doesn't want

He made three fouls in a short space of time and wasn’t shown anything.

As the teams left the field for half time, Fionn McDonagh and Seán Kelly were booked for an incident. Donie Vaughan was shown a yellow card for a sliding tackle and Gary O’Donnell’s booking was correct too. 

The same for Peter Cooke when he pulled back, and a high tackle on Colm Boyle was also punished correctly.

Both Dalys ended up off the field at the end, Michael for a foot-trip, although John’s was off the ball. Again, it was a nightmare type of game for Joe, and what made matters worse towards the end was the foul-at-all-costs approach taken.

When a player in possession doesn’t release the ball, I believe there should be more of a sanction shown. It really leads to tricky situations, and the whole thing becomes so messy. 

Like Maurice Deegan last week, Joe incorrectly chose to bring forward a free when it is only permissible as the ball is in play.

Kevin Walsh had a go at some of the decisions made by Joe, and this habit of blaming anyone but yourself seems to be more in fashion with managers than ever before. 

Mayo-Galway was the kind of game a ref doesn't want

I could understand some of Kieran McGeeney’s frustrations the week before, even though Maurice Deegan wasn’t as bad as Armagh people made him out to be on social media. But what I can’t entertain is managers using referees to cover themselves.

Barry Cassidy’s time in Clones wasn’t half as eventful as Joe’s. He can be satisfied with his evening and will feature in the Super 8s, although his issuing of a black card means Peter Harte faces a night or two in Dublin before Tyrone’s first Super 8 game against Roscommon on Saturday.

When you look at it again, it is on the harsh side, but he did give enough cause to warrant the black. Tyrone are contesting the cumulative one-match ban imposed for three black cards, but they will likely have more joy in questioning the one against Longford than the one this past weekend or the other picked up against Donegal.

Yesterday, Derek O’Mahoney took charge of the Meath-Clare game in Portlaoise and also gave a good display. 

Mayo-Galway was the kind of game a ref doesn't want

The yellow card for a high foul by Jamie Malone was right, but he could have been harder on Kevin Harnett for an off-the-ball foul on James Conlon. 

He showed a yellow, but it probably merited a black.

Gordon Kelly was right to be shown a black for pulling down Cillian O’Sullivan, as was Meath’s Bryan McMahon later on, and Graham Reilly’s yellow card. 

Derek tried to keep the game flowing as best he could while keeping control, but as the season develops the balancing act is getting finer.

Mike Quirke's Football Show: Tactical Mayo but never boring. How Cork changed tack. Tyrone always learning. Fixing the fouling carnage

More on this topic

Ger Cunningham: 'Flaky' is harsh but Cork have no excuses leftGer Cunningham: 'Flaky' is harsh but Cork have no excuses left

Hurling podcast: The Cork inquest: no excuses this time. Cody the firefighter. Tipp try gegenpressingHurling podcast: The Cork inquest: no excuses this time. Cody the firefighter. Tipp try gegenpressing

Quirke's Football Podcast: Killarney picnic zone not war zone. Gavin bombshell. Two questions for CorkQuirke's Football Podcast: Killarney picnic zone not war zone. Gavin bombshell. Two questions for Cork

Patrick Horgan's 3-10 leads the way for scoring feats in defeatsPatrick Horgan's 3-10 leads the way for scoring feats in defeats

More in this Section

5 of the most memorable Wimbledon finals5 of the most memorable Wimbledon finals

Gerrard eager to raise the standards at RangersGerrard eager to raise the standards at Rangers

Novak Djokovic wins fifth Wimbledon title – the final in picturesNovak Djokovic wins fifth Wimbledon title – the final in pictures

England secure cricket World Cup with champagne super overEngland secure cricket World Cup with champagne super over

More by this author

John O’Dwyer and Ronan Maher lucky to escape redsJohn O’Dwyer and Ronan Maher lucky to escape reds

Anthony Nolan’s inconsistency confused and angered CorkAnthony Nolan’s inconsistency confused and angered Cork

GAA must get tough on sideline spatsGAA must get tough on sideline spats

Lyons should have allowed another minuteLyons should have allowed another minute


Lifestyle

This year heralds the return of a much-maligned shade, pulled from the design doldrums and now paired with some unexpected complementary colours, materials and tone-on-tone activity, writes Carol O’Callaghan.Fifty shades of beige

Their romance took Laura Roset and Ken Mohally from Mallow to Moldova and back again.Wedding of the Week: Love spreads from Mallow to Moldova

Every day, I take my wife a cup of tea in bed. However, we sometimes make love in the mornings and she pauses to finish her cup before it goes cold.Sexual healing: Her long tea breaks cools the moment

As the Caped Crusader hits 80 years of protecting Gotham City, Chris Wasser looks at the history of the world’s darkest superhero.80 years on, Batman still packs a punch

More From The Irish Examiner