Birmingham end Clough's cup dream in injury time

Derby 1 Birmingham 2

Nigel Clough’s dream of winning the one domestic trophy that eluded his father, Brian, was shattered as Birmingham defender Liam Ridgewell snatched an injury-time winner in the FA Cup fifth-round tie at Pride Park.

Jay McEveley’s 54th-minute strike put the Rams on course for a quarter-final spot for the first time in 11 years, although Blues keeper Joe Hart will shoulder some of the blame.

But Scott Dann headed home a James McFadden corner to level matters and then Ridgewell popped up with the decider.

It was rough justice on the home side and their inspirational skipper Robbie Savage and they deserved a second chance against a below-par City, with Kris Commons a constant handful for the away defenders.

Derby more than matched their high-flying Barclays Premier League opponents for long periods.

But Blues have a never-say-die spirit about them these days and it surfaced again to seal their place in the last eight.

Birmingham fans were quick to vent their feelings towards their former player Savage after his controversial departure from St Andrew’s.

The first half-chance fell to Dann but he directed his first-time shot wide from a Sebastian Larsson corner.

Derby keeper Stephen Bywater then had to come racing out of his area to hack the ball clear from Cameron Jerome.

It was 31 minutes before the first shot on target arrived and Bywater needed two attempts to cling onto a dipping effort from Lee Bowyer.

Birmingham started to pass the ball about with a bit more authority and a through pass from Larsson was latched onto by Jerome but Bywater manager to turn his shot around the post.

City central defender Roger Johnson got on the end of McFadden’s resulting corner at the far post but could not keep his header down.

Derby retaliated and twice went close to breaking the deadlock.

First Stephen Pearson hit the post from a narrow angle, although Hart was well positioned had the shot been on target.

Then a dangerous low centre from Commons fizzed right across the City area with no-one able to provide a finishing touch.

But Hart produced a splendid point-blank range save to deny Shaun Barker from an inswinging Savage free-kick five minutes before the interval.

A left-wing cross from McEveley had Hart back-pedalling at the start of the second period and was only a couple of feet too high.

The play was generally as scrappy as in the first 45 minutes but Derby appeared to be growing in belief that they could cause an upset.

There was a moment of danger for the home side when Christian Benitez played in Jerome but he delayed his shot and the Derby defence were able to get back and cover.

After 54 minutes, McEveley broke the deadlock, although Hart will be disappointed with his part in the goal.

The left-back tried a speculative shot from 25 yards out and the ball bounced awkwardly in front of Hart before entering the net.

Derby were now in the ascendancy and Hart almost let a low shot from Commons creep through his hands after good play by Savage.

Savage became the first player to be yellow-carded after 61 minutes for a challenge on Benitez.

Blues boss Alex McLeish made a double change after 64 minutes, with Larsson and Benitez replaced by Kevin Phillips and Keith Fahey.

Phillips was immediately in the action and forced Bywater to turn his shot behind for a corner.

With 18 minutes remaining, Dann brought Birmingham back on level terms.

A corner from McFadden picked out the former Coventry player, whose header powered past Bywater, although it appeared to take a deflection.

McLeish made his final substitution in replacing McFadden with Craig Gardner, although the Scotland international looked unhappy with the situation and was shaking his head as he took his place in the dug-out.

In injury-time Ridgewell snatched a winner for City after Phillips’ initial shot had struck the post.

Hart then produced a superb save to tip over a Savage pile-driver.

More on this topic

FA Cup: Wilder rages at divers as Arsenal seek Cup consolation at SheffieldFA Cup: Wilder rages at divers as Arsenal seek Cup consolation at Sheffield

FA Cup: Kevin De Bruyne eases Man City past Newcastle in quarter-finalFA Cup: Kevin De Bruyne eases Man City past Newcastle in quarter-final

Pep Guardiola: Winning FA Cup would be best way to prepare for Real Madrid clashPep Guardiola: Winning FA Cup would be best way to prepare for Real Madrid clash

Chelsea have played better and lost games, says Frank Lampard after FA Cup winChelsea have played better and lost games, says Frank Lampard after FA Cup win


More in this Section

Frank Lampard not worried about Tammy Abraham’s contract situationFrank Lampard not worried about Tammy Abraham’s contract situation

Mikel Arteta keen to extend midfielder Dani Ceballos’ time at ArsenalMikel Arteta keen to extend midfielder Dani Ceballos’ time at Arsenal

Hugo Lloris plays down clash with Son Heung-minHugo Lloris plays down clash with Son Heung-min

County managers want clarity on return date for trainingCounty managers want clarity on return date for training


Lifestyle

Liz O’Brien talks to Niall Breslin about his admiration for frontline staff, bereavement in lockdown, his new podcast, and why it's so important for us all just to slow down.Niall Breslin talks about losing his uncle to coronavirus

Podcasts are often seen as a male domain — see the joke, 'What do you call two white men talking? A podcast'.Podcast corner: Three new podcasts from Irish women that you should listen to

Esther McCarthy previews some of the Fleadh’s Irish and international offerings.How to attend the Galway Film Fleadh from the comfort of your own couch

Whether you’re on staycation or risking a trip away, Marjorie Brennan offers suggestions on novels for a wide variety of tastesThe best fiction books for the beach and beyond this summer

More From The Irish Examiner