Review: Safe laughs in Gaiety production of The Lieutenant of Inishmore

Review: Safe laughs in Gaiety production of The Lieutenant of Inishmore

To say Martin McDonagh helps us laugh at ourselves is to oversimplify. With him, we laugh at representations of ourselves that have been presented over centuries: by writers, fabulists, mythmakers, self-appointed patriots, or indeed “terrorists”, as here, in The Lieutenant of Inishmore.

McDonagh brings the exile’s critical distance, but also the exile’s confusion: a kind of hand-me-down, Ireland-by-hearsay is his dramatic world, allowing him to eschew realism and chronology — characters straight out of bastardised Synge brush shoulders with ones who speak like they’re in Reservoir Dogs: pedantic psychopaths who quibble over quotations.

McDonagh, in other words, ransacks the culture, and, at his best, provokes laughter by his irreverence.

Certainly, there is no reverence in The Lieutenant of Inishmore, which puts the “physical force tradition” squarely in its crosshairs and lets rip. The play centres on Mad Padraic (Paul Mescal), a young man too crazy for the IRA, and considering splintering off from his splinter group, the INLA.

That plan is derailed by the apparent death of his best friend, Wee Thomas, the cat. So, he returns to Inishmore, bent on vengeance. Meanwhile, his bumbling father and local lad Davey, played by the Cork pairing of DonWycherley and Young Offenders’ Alex Murphy, hatch schemes to hide the truth of the cat’s fate.

So far, so ridiculous. And McDonagh’s targets are worthy of ridicule. Yet, the alphabet soup of initialisms and the tawdry antics of pathetic hardline provos has already played out for real in recent years. What use, then, is satire when the target is already, pardon the pun, exploded?

In our post-peace process age, what we get is a play in need of a new context. Unfortunately, in this production, by Andrew Flynn, it doesn’t get it. Flynn’s sure and steady approach has much clarity, and plenty of laughs. It might have made sense in the teeth of widespread political violence. But here, they are safe laughs, not even, really, cathartic ones.

McDonagh always approached his Irish materials with irreverence. Perhaps it’s time his own work was approached in a similar spirit.

More in this Section

Behind the scenes in The Great House RevivalBehind the scenes in The Great House Revival

How to grow your own mindfulness comfort zoneHow to grow your own mindfulness comfort zone

Secret Diary of an Irish Teacher: a nostalgic night in KerrySecret Diary of an Irish Teacher: a nostalgic night in Kerry

Ask Audrey: Why aren't William and Kate coming to Cork?Ask Audrey: Why aren't William and Kate coming to Cork?

Latest Showbiz

Director-general Noel Curran released a statement to mark the European Broadcasting Union’s 70th anniversary.Digital giants becoming ‘powerful gatekeepers’ to what we watch – EBU boss

The Invisible Man, based on HG Wells’ science fiction novel of the same name, tackles themes of domestic violence.Elisabeth Moss wants to honour abuse survivors in latest film

Pasha Kovalev announced he was quitting the BBC One show last year.Strictly stars Pasha and Aljaz to reunite on stage

The pop star performed the dramatic ballad at the Brit Awards earlier this month.Harry Styles dons lilac dress in underwater video for Falling

More From The Irish Examiner