New show seeks solutions to some of the damage done by the world’s appetite for meat

New show seeks solutions to some of the damage done by the world’s appetite for meat
Liz Bonnin with a fistulated cow at University of California, Davis. The opening cut into the cow’s stomach doesn’t interfere with the cow, but allows scientists to study what goes on inside.

From farming practices in Europe to forest clearances in the Amazon, Liz Bonnin’s new show seeks solutions to some of the damage done by the world’s appetite for meat, writes Gemma Dunn.

When hard-hitting BBC One documentary Drowning In Plastic aired last autumn, Liz Bonnin had no idea of the reaction it would cause.

The ground-breaking film — which highlighted the devastating global impact of plastic on our oceans and marine wildlife — saw the presenter in tears as she witnessed the horror of flesh-footed shearwater chicks vomiting up shards of plastic, or seal pups strangled by fishing nets.

It was scenes such as these that drove viewers to take to social media, first to express their dismay, and more importantly to pledge change. And change, albeit slowly, is happening.

Today, one year on, Bonnin, 43, says she has her comrade to thank for paving the way.

“It was Blue Planet II and Sir David Attenborough who really had the impact with plastic,” she insists, her film picking up where the devastating final episode of Blue Planet II left off, “that’s why we called it ‘the Blue Planet effect’.

“Our job was to further investigate the impact of plastics on the ocean, but we played a role in helping to further the conversation.”

That she did. And she hopes to do the same with her next BBC project, too: Meat: A Threat To Our Planet?

With the UN recently branding meat “the world’s most urgent problem”, stating that our excessive consumption is pushing us toa climate catastrophe, the wildlifebiologist (a meat-eater herself)embarks on an ambitious mission to uncover the true extent of this environmental “crisis”.


Yet delving into a contentious subject matter doesn’t come without its challenges, Bonnin admits.

“It took us more research to even get to the pre-production stage, just to cut through all the noise and to get the scientific consensus,” elaborates the Paris-born star, who moved to Ireland when she was nine years old.

“Because there’s a lot of scientists that would disagree with some of what we’ve said.

“But [we] worked like crazy to get to what is now accepted as being the scientific consensus and that is always the driving force of making a programme, particularly for the BBC, to make sure that we are deeply rooted in the scientific facts.”

Taking her search far and wide, the 60-minute film sees Bonnin learning about the colossal growth of the meat industry, and the harrowing predictions of its effect on our planet’s climate and resources.

Plus, in the US and Europe, she investigates how humans can continue to eat meat — how to rear it, how to feed it, how to graze it — without killing our planet.

On her travels, she meets characters on all sides of the debate —dietitians who believe that meat is an essential part of our lives; environmentalists drawing a road map to a meat-free world; and food scientists developing “Franken food” meatless alternatives to our everyday meals.

She even takes to the skies above the Amazon rainforest where zoologists are urgently trying to save rare animal and plant species whose habitat is being cleared for cattle.

Visibly emotional on screen, the latter was a real eye-opener for Bonnin.

“I’m an animal biologist, I’ve presented environmental films for the BBC for 11 years now, science films, natural history films, and I thought I knew, number one, the value of the Amazon,” she confides.

“I didn’t really fully understand just how important that particular rainforest is for our survival, period. Case closed. There’s no kind ofdebate about that.

“It’s the lungs of the planet, it’s a carbon store!” she relays, passionately.

Each tree draws up a thousand litres a day to create what the indigenous people call ‘flying rivers’ over the treetops, which is a mist that then contributes to the rain cycle of our planet.

“They call it the beating heart, the circulatory system of the planet, and at the research stage, at my desk with my big mug of tea, what I relish is getting stuck in to all that stuff,” she continues.

“[There], I began to understand the role that the Amazon plays to our health, every single one of us, so by the time I was in that plane, it’s hard to put into words the harrowing realisation of what each of us is responsible for,” she warns.

“The stark realisation of just how much we’re destroying it and what that means for your future.”


So how has the show affected her own meat consumption?

“I was already eating very little amount of meat, and I was conscious of buying organic, although organic has its own challenges...” Bonnin reasons. “But I’ve now stopped eating red meat altogether.

“It wasn’t even a stage of going ‘I must’, I just naturally have lost the taste for it at the moment,” she reveals.

“I saw these pigs in the barns and that was it for me; I think it’s just propelled an inherent instinct without a big old, ‘Right, that’s it, I must force myself not to’,” she muses.

“And to be honest with you, I can see myself getting into complete vegetarianism very soon. It’s just a natural progression.”

She follows: “I was at a climate talk with Chris Packham yesterday, he was talking about how it’s a stage thing for most people, the more they learn.

“And I think that’s part of the message here: we’re not telling people what to do and to turn vegetarian, but I think inherently we are evolving in our understanding of how our relationship with the planet potentially needs a little bit of a harder look,” she notes.

“If we can just make gradual changes, it will go a long way.”

It’s the reality of the impact of our modern world, she says simply.

As the latest scientific research is saying, if we reduce to two portions [of meat] a week we could mitigate some of those impacts —that’s the information and after that it’s each and everybody’s personal choice.

“Of course livelihoods come into it, economics comes into it, human health comes into it, welfare comes into it...” she realises.

“But what we set out to make, and I hope what we achieved, is to inform and to educate about what exactly meat production does to the environment.

“From that there will be lots of tangential, hopefully, talks, more discussions and hopefully more programmes,” she finishes.

“Did we achieve the brief?” she wonders. “I hope we did.”

Meat: A Threat To Our Planet? airs on BBC One on Monday November 25.

More on this topic

Paul Hollywood’s ex-wife explains why she is not changing her surnamePaul Hollywood’s ex-wife explains why she is not changing her surname

Barbara Windsor does not recognise me sometimes, says husband Scott MitchellBarbara Windsor does not recognise me sometimes, says husband Scott Mitchell

James May gives his verdict on current Top Gear presenting line-upJames May gives his verdict on current Top Gear presenting line-up

Phoebe Waller-Bridge reveals how she pitched Fleabag role to Andrew ScottPhoebe Waller-Bridge reveals how she pitched Fleabag role to Andrew Scott

More in this Section

The great escape: What's life like off the grid?The great escape: What's life like off the grid?

Jazz Connective Festival: Intriguing, exciting and uncompromisingJazz Connective Festival: Intriguing, exciting and uncompromising

Album review: Stormzy remains a work in progressAlbum review: Stormzy remains a work in progress

Your chance to buy drawings by Roald Dahl illustrator Quentin BlakeYour chance to buy drawings by Roald Dahl illustrator Quentin Blake

Latest Showbiz

Fans shared their disappointment with the online voting tool.Strictly fans complain of online voting issues during live final

The former Emmerdale star was speechless and tearful as he was awarded the Glitterball Trophy.Kelvin Fletcher and Oti Mabuse win Strictly Come Dancing

The singer said the far right use platforms to spread ‘disinformation and lies’.Lily Allen quit Twitter because social media ‘gives voice to far right’

Piers Morgan was among the judges.Jamaican model crowned Miss World 2019

More From The Irish Examiner