Death threats won't stop Jodi Picoult taking on difficult subjects

Jodi Picoult’s new novel opens during a hostage crisis at an abortion clinic in Mississippi.

Jodi Picoult’s status as the queen of ethical fiction hasn’t stopped the death threats over her latest novel on abortion, writes Hannah Stephenson

She's the queen of ‘ethical fiction’, having tackled subjects such as teenage suicide, stem cell research, racism, prejudice and child abuse in her novels.

Her books have sold millions of copies and garnered a clutch of awards during her career — but Jodi Picoult’s writing hasn’t been well received by everyone, and has even prompted death threats from trolls on social media.

Picoult, 52, whose 2004 novel My Sister’s Keeper was adapted into a film starring Cameron Diaz, is determined to ignore all this, though, and soldier on.

Her latest novel, A Spark Of Light, which focuses on the abortion debate and reproductive rights, has already fuelled the Twitter trolls.

“I had death threats for Small Great Things (her 2016 novel which tackles race and prejudice) as well because white supremacists came after me and, surprise surprise, many of them are also pro-life,” says the American author.

Trolls don’t scare her, she adds.

One of the things I’ve learned is that extremists get on to social media to sow seeds of hate and discord by making it look like there are many of them coming after you, when in reality there are six or seven.

“What’s scarier to me are the pro-life extremists who camp outside the Deep South clinics, who have the licence plate numbers of the (abortion) doctors and follow them and post their home addresses online and encourage people to go and commit violence against them.”

A Spark Of Light opens during a hostage crisis at the only women’s health clinic providing legal abortions in Mississippi, a detail rooted in fact.

The eclectic mix of characters locked inside — after a gunman storms in opening fire, killing and injuring people before taking the rest hostage — are banded together by crisis.

Told in reverse order, with each chapter moving back an hour — so there’s no ‘whodunnit’ element — the plot focuses on the characters inside the clinic and the dilemmas they each face.

Like all Picoult’s novels, the ethical dilemmas are far reaching. How do we balance the rights of pregnant women with the rights of the unborn they carry? What does it mean to be a good parent?

The idea was sparked from a personal experience. “When I was in college, I had a very good friend who found out she was seven weeks pregnant, and she and her boyfriend made the decision to have an abortion. I supported her 100%,” Picoult recalls. “Years later, when I was pregnant with my third child, I was seven weeks pregnant as well and there was a complication. My doctor told me that the pregnancy might not make it and I was absolutely wrecked.

“I tried to understand how both those things could be true to me at the same time. I realised that where we stand on the spectrum of reproductive rights isn’t just a matter of whether we define ourselves as pro-life or pro-choice. An individual woman may change her mind over the course of her lifetime. What you believe when you’re a teenager is not what you believe when you’re in your 30s or in your 50s.

“In America, we legislate reproductive rights. Laws are meant to be black and white but the situations in the lives of women that cause them to make these decisions to terminate are thousands of shades of grey.”

For research, she interviewed 151 women who had terminated a pregnancy. Of those, only one regretted that decision. Yet years later, the vast majority still hadn’t told anybody.

It completely broke my heart because when women don’t tell their stories, the narrative that gets written about them is one of shame. We’ve seen over and over again that the woman who terminates a pregnancy is cast as somebody who is evil and selfish.

She also spoke to pro-life advocates who, she says, were not religious zealots but simply felt deep personal conviction. All were appalled by acts of violence committed in the name of unborn children. She shadowed Dr Willie Parker, an abortion provider and devout Christian in the Deep South who chose his work because of his faith, not in spite of it.

“I observed a five-week abortion, an eight-week abortion and a 15-week abortion,” she recalls. “The five-week and the eight-week abortions took less than three minutes and the products of conception look nothing that would suggest a dead baby.

“The 15-week abortion took seven minutes, was more complicated, and mixed among the tissue and products of conception were tiny, recognisable body parts, like a tiny hand, an elbow. Of course, that gives you pause.

“But I also interviewed the woman who had the abortion. She has three children under the age of four, could barely afford to feed them and she knew if she had a fourth child, she would not be able to feed them.

“So, is she a good mother or a bad mother? It really depends on which side of the divide you’re standing on.”

The abortion issue throws up much deeper questions concerning the economic and social problems in the US, she agrees.

What drives Picoult to write about such uncomfortable subjects?

“I write about things that keep me up at night, things that I worry about as a woman, as an American and as a mother. There’s no shortage of them.”

Picoult herself had a blissfully normal childhood. She was born on Long Island, New York. Her mother was a nursery school teacher while her father worked on Wall Street.

After studying English and creative writing at Princeton, she had a succession of jobs while writing in her spare time. Today, she writes in her attic at large colonial-style home set in 11 acres in New Hampshire, which she shares with her husband Tim Van Leer, her college sweetheart. They have three grown-up children.

More movie adaptations are on the cards, despite the fact she wasn’t happy with the My Sister’s Keeper film because the ending was changed.

Small Great Things, which is owned by Steven Spielberg’s production company Amblin Entertainment and set to star Viola Davis and Julia Roberts, is in development.

Picoult seems to thrive on being busy. She’s going to Egypt to research her next book, then she’ll co-write a different novel with a transgender woman.

But she can switch off from her fictional dilemmas when she finishes for the day, she reflects. “I have an amazing husband and four awesome dogs, and when I come downstairs there is such a clear line of demarcation between the very fraught situation I’ve been writing about and the life that I live, that it’s not hard for me to separate them.”

- A Spark Of Light by Jodi Picoult is available now

More on this topic

Rotunda Hospital now taking patients seeking abortions from across Dublin

Third protest held outside Kilkenny health clinic which has been subject to past intimidation

European Court of Human Rights to raise NI abortion issue with UK Government

Derry Girls stars help deliver abortion petition to NI Secretary

More in this Section

Five celebrities open up about male anxiety

Out of Africa and into Cork's Live at the Marquee

Sex advice with Suzi Godson: We’re getting divorced — but we’re still having sex

Open your mind to making an entrance


Latest Showbiz

John Cleese claims he was snubbed by Netflix over comedy special

Marvel shares new Avengers: Endgame character posters

Diana Ross celebrates birthday: 75 is a good number

Sophie Turner explains decision to get engaged to Joe Jonas when she was 21

More From The Irish Examiner