Witness claims hearing Dundon plan killing weeks before Geoghegan's murder

Witness claims hearing Dundon plan killing weeks before Geoghegan's murder
John Dundon.

A 29-year-old Limerick woman has said that she heard John Dundon plan a killing a couple of weeks before rugby player Shane Geoghegan was murdered in a case of mistaken identity.

Lisa Collins was today giving evidence to Dundon’s trial, which is in its seventh day at the Special Criminal Court.

The 30-year-old of Hyde Road in Limerick has pleaded not guilty to murdering the Garryowen rugby player on November 9, 2008.

Mr Geoghegan was gunned down as he returned home to his girlfriend in Dooradoyle, Limerick around 1am that morning. The 28-year-old died of gunshot wounds to his head and trunk just metres from his home at Clonmore, Kilteragh.

Lisa Collins testified that in 2008, she shared a house with her partner and Dundon’s cousin, Christopher McCarthy.

She said that a couple of weeks before Mr Geoghegan’s murder, Dundon came to their home with Barry Doyle, referring to the convicted gunman in Mr Geoghegan’s murder.

“John Dundon used to be talking about John McNamara out in Raheen. Pitchfork he used to call him. Barry asked him what the story was with him,” she said.

“John Dundon said: ‘We’re going to kill the c**t’,” she testified.

She said that Dundon also asked her and Christopher McCarthy to steal a car. She said she didn’t know why he wanted the car and that she didn’t want to steal it, but they did.

“He was coming around to our house all the time telling us to get a car,” she said, adding that one day he got angry and said: ‘Get a f***ing car. I’ll slap you around the place’.

She said that he got really angry on the last day he came around and that, referring to her, he told Christopher McCarthy: ‘If you don’t get the f***ing car, I’ll kill her’.

She said that she, McCarthy and another man then stole a car and parked it in an apartment block.

She said that she and McCarthy later took Dundon and Doyle to see the car.

She identified herself on CCTV driving behind the stolen car at 5pm on October 16 that year.

Ms Collins said that she was woken by a phone ringing on the night Mr Geoghegan died. She said there was also knocking at the door.

“It was John Dundon and Barry Doyle,” she said.

“John Dundon was saying that Johnny Mac was dead,” she said. “He said it a few times. He was laughing.”

She said that the next morning she heard about Shane Geoghegan’s murder. She later saw a reconstruction of the crime on television and recognised the car used as the car she had helped steal.

She agreed with Brendan Nix SC, defending, that she lied to Gardaí when arrested in connection with Mr Geoghegan’s murder.

“I was afraid to say anything,” she said.

Mr Nix asked her if the television reconstruction had got at her conscience

“When I saw the car, I felt sick over it,” she replied.

She confirmed that she had also been questioned by Gardaí about two other murders.

“I don’t know why I was questioned,” she said.

Christopher McCarthy also gave evidence. He said he was a first cousin of Dundon and remembered him moving to Limerick from London around 1999.

He also said he didn’t know what use Dundon had for the car that he asked him and Ms Collins to get.

“He said he’d kill me or kill my girlfriend if we didn’t. I had to get him a car,” he said.

He also described stealing the people carrier from the side of a road outside Limerick city. He said that it was another man who actually got into to the car and drove it away.

He said that this man took a handbag from the car.

“He gave me a few pound out of it,” he said, adding that there was also a cheque for €10,000 in the bag.

He said they then hid the bag in a graveyard and brought Dundon to see the car.

He said that Dundon and Doyle called to his house again on the night of the murder.

“He (Dundon) was saying: ‘Pitchfork is dead’. I knew he was on about John McNamara,” he said. “Kind of excited he was.”

The trial continues before the non-jury, three-judge court with Justice Nicholas Kearns presiding.

More in this Section

Health Minister: Real risk of Covid-19 second wave from international travelHealth Minister: Real risk of Covid-19 second wave from international travel

Blanket 30km/hr speed limit proposed for DublinBlanket 30km/hr speed limit proposed for Dublin

'We have huge potential': Housing expert on rapid conversion of commercial units in Ireland'We have huge potential': Housing expert on rapid conversion of commercial units in Ireland

'Grossly irresponsible': Waterford Mayor hits out at weekend house party'Grossly irresponsible': Waterford Mayor hits out at weekend house party


It is the fourth of May, 2007. I am coming home from work, tired and scrolling through images of Trapani, Sicily - our holiday destination in a few weeks. Nothing remarkable about the journey, until I read the story of a missing girl in Praia De Luz, Portugal.Learning Points: Give Madeleine McCann's family the space to put their lives back together

Des O'Driscoll has your telly picks for tonight.Thursday's TV Highlights: Irish talents shine in Dunkirk and more Premier League football

More From The Irish Examiner