WATCH: Eighth Amendment Committee chair accuses pro-life members of trying to undermine her position

WATCH: Eighth Amendment Committee chair accuses pro-life members of trying to undermine her position
Catherine Noone. Pic: Oireachtas.ie

The chair of the Oireachtas Eighth Amendment Committee has today accused two prominent pro-life members of trying to "undermine" her position on the cross-party group, writes Fiachra Ó Cionnaith.

Fine Gael senator Catherine Noone made the claim after a tense exchange with Independent TD Mattie McGrath and Independent senator Ronan Mullen at the end of seven hours of meetings today.

At the start of the meetings, Mr McGrath had initially hit out at Ms Noone for refusing to read out two letters from pro-life witnesses to the committee saying they would not attend because the cross-party group's deliberations have become a "kangaroo court" and are biased against pro-life views.

Ms Noone initially rejected the allegation, alongside a number of other committee members including Independent senator Lynn Ruane.

However, returning to the matter at the end of seven hours of discussion with experts who did attend the committee, Ms Noone read from the Oireachtas committee chairperson rule book to say she is entitled to decide whether to read out the letters or not.

Ms Noone said under the "salient rules of the House" document, a committee chairperson does not have to read out a letter from a witness if the witness does not attend, and can instead simply publish it on the committee's website.

She added that a previous decision to read out letters from pro-choice medic Dr Peter Boylan and pro-life advocate Cora Sherlock was to clarify issues previously raised in public session.

Despite initially saying the rule book specifically states the decision of the chairperson on such a matter is final and cannot be challenged, Mr Mullen and Mr McGrath were allowed to "clarify" the point.

The debate quickly descended into a growing argument, with Ms Noone eventually warning both pro-life members they are trying to "undermine" her position.

Ronan Mullen and Mattie McGrath. Pic: Oireachtas.ie
Ronan Mullen and Mattie McGrath. Pic: Oireachtas.ie

As Ms Noone said she would be open to a vote if Mr Mullen and Mr McGrath demanded it, Social Democrats TD Catherine Murphy interjected to say the "practice" of the Oireachtas is clear - that the committee chair's view on the matter is final and cannot be challenged.

Sinn Féin TD Jonathan O'Brien said "I'm losing my temper here" at what colleagues said were the "stunts" from Mr Mullen and Mr McGrath and due to a Pro-Life Campaign media briefing at the gates of Leinster House as the committee was sitting, before Mr McGrath shouted back:

"Are you threatening us, are we going to be knee-capped."

Mr Mullen and Mr McGrath have insisted they raised their concern for legitimate reasons and knew nothing of the Pro-Life Campaign media briefing.

However, a number of committee members have privately said both individuals are trying to undermine the committee before its findings are given to the Dáil next month.

More on this topic

How a brave few are breaking Ireland’s abortion tabooHow a brave few are breaking Ireland’s abortion taboo

UN says UK violates women's human rights by criminalising abortions in Northern IrelandUN says UK violates women's human rights by criminalising abortions in Northern Ireland

Women march in Poland to demand Abortion rightsWomen march in Poland to demand Abortion rights

Readers' Blog: Pro-abortion agenda affected 8th committeeReaders' Blog: Pro-abortion agenda affected 8th committee

More in this Section

Over half of hospital admissions due to eating disorders last year related to childrenOver half of hospital admissions due to eating disorders last year related to children

Inquiry into IBRC could end up costing over €30mInquiry into IBRC could end up costing over €30m

Gardaí seek relatives or friends of man found dead after going missing in 2011Gardaí seek relatives or friends of man found dead after going missing in 2011

Climate Action Plan needs to be fully implemented to meet EU targetsClimate Action Plan needs to be fully implemented to meet EU targets


Lifestyle

Dónal Clancy is a musician from An Rinn in Co Waterford. He will perform the music of his late father, Liam Clancy, in a special online solo performance on Thursday at 7pm as part of this year's Clonmel Junction Festival.Question of Taste: Dónal Clancy

BETWEEN 1973 and early 1975, John Lennon split with Yoko Ono, took up with his assistant May Pang and embarked on a period of intense creativity and outrageous behaviour. Lennon later described this time as his “lost weekend”.Rufus Wainwright has returned a new man

Stan O’Sullivan tells Ellie O’Byrne about the genre-busting album from 2007 that probably doesn’t get the recognition it deservesB-Side the Leeside - Cork’s Greatest Records: Louder & Clearer from Stanley Super 800

About a week ago out of the blue my 9-year-old asked for a cup of tea after dinner. She has only ever had a sip or two of tea beforehand so it seemed an unusual request.Alison Curtis: Tea, chats and chores with my daughter

More From The Irish Examiner