War of words over Public Service Card rebuke by UN official

War of words over Public Service Card rebuke by UN official
A UN official with responsibility for human rights said the Public Services Card was discriminatory against the less well-off in Irish society. File picture.

A war of words has broken out between the Irish State and a senior UN official with responsibility for human rights after the Government delayed the publication of a letter critical of the public services card (PSC) project by a number of days.

On April 14, Professor Philip Alston, the UN’s special rapporteur at the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), wrote a 40-page letter to the Irish State accusing the PSC of being, among other things, discriminatory against the less well-off in Irish society.

It is believed that letter was delayed after the Government exerted pressure at the OHCHR to delay its publication.

The letter was officially released yesterday, with a stinging response from Ireland’s chief diplomat, Minister for Foreign Affairs and Tánaiste Simon Coveney, having been delivered to Prof Alston in return.

It is, however, believed that the letter, which bears Mr Coveney’s signature, was not drafted by his own officials, but rather by the body with chief responsibility for the card, the Department of Social Protection.

In the correspondence, Mr Coveney noted his “disappointment” that efforts by the Government to “engage” with Prof Alston on “these critically important issues” were not answered.

He said it is “surprising” that Prof Alston had made no mention of the Covid-19 crisis in his own letter, and said that “no inference should be drawn” from the decision to waive the need for a PSC for the duration of the pandemic.

“I would like to reiterate the Irish Government’s clear position that the PSC is properly grounded in law and does not contravene any of Ireland’s human rights obligations,” he wrote.

The Tánaiste likewise derided the fact that Prof Alston had not taken up a standing invitation to visit Ireland officially during his tenure, saying he was “at a loss to understand therefore, given your obvious interest in our social protection system, why you did not take up this invitation during the term of your mandate”.

Prof Alston has returned fire, stating that the Government’s response had “failed to address any of the key concerns” of his letter.

He said that any efforts by the Government to engage with him were limited to two occasions — the first followed an unofficial visit to Ireland last August in which he had been similarly critical of the card which led to a letter from Social Protection at the time saying “everyone loves it (the PSC) and there’s no problem”.

The second engagement, Mr Alston said, had followed the delivery of his new letter last week, which he said amounted to an attempt to delay its publication.

“It’s important to note that I’m all in favour of improving accessibility and efficiency and preventing fraud” he said.

“The PSC is actually a key plank in a broader strategy of digital transformation. That will lead to it becoming a de facto national biometric identity card. There hasn’t been the necessary debate to agree on the shape of such a card, the purposes for which it will be required, or the protections against abuse and for privacy that are an indispensable part of any such system,” he said.

More on this topic

Cianan Brennan: New war of words breaks out in saga of public services cardCianan Brennan: New war of words breaks out in saga of public services card

UN official challenges Simon Coveney to identify factual errors in Public Services Card reportUN official challenges Simon Coveney to identify factual errors in Public Services Card report

UN human rights body attacks Public Services Card saying it amounts to 'discrimination'UN human rights body attacks Public Services Card saying it amounts to 'discrimination'

PSC data protection policy updated after Doherty loses seatPSC data protection policy updated after Doherty loses seat

More in this Section

Burglars armed with baseball bat and hammer break into Belfast houseBurglars armed with baseball bat and hammer break into Belfast house

Two appear in court after €280k drug seizures in Laois and KildareTwo appear in court after €280k drug seizures in Laois and Kildare

Coronavirus: Health officials announce nine more deaths in IrelandCoronavirus: Health officials announce nine more deaths in Ireland

SpaceX and Nasa's second attempt to launch astronauts will cross Irish skies tonightSpaceX and Nasa's second attempt to launch astronauts will cross Irish skies tonight


Lifestyle

A Spectacular 28.86-carat ring, the largest D-colour diamond ever offered online, will come up at Christie's Jewels in New York from June 16-30.High value diamond adds serious sparkle to online sale

A whiff of new normality is in the air, writes Des O'SullivanAntiques: How to put a post-lockdown world in the frame

Buy everything on Michelle Darmody’s list and create five meals.One List, Five Meals: Irish stew with a twist; Yellow Pepper Omelette

‘There are two of us, in it together’From Chestnut to Sage - how family food businesses, real labours of love, are coping with Covid

More From The Irish Examiner