Vatican guidance on gender identity 'completely at odds' with approach in Irish schools, claims group

Vatican guidance on gender identity 'completely at odds' with approach in Irish schools, claims group

New guidance for Catholic schools issued by the Vatican rejecting the idea that people can self-declare their gender “ignores the real and legitimate experiences” of young trans people, according to Transgender Equality Network Ireland (TENI).

Launched this week in a bid to tackle what the Vatican deems an “educational crisis” in modern gender identity, the guide is “completely at odds” with the approach adopted towards trans and intersex students in many schools here, according to the group.

Entitled ‘Male and Female, He created them’ and issued by the Congregation for Catholic Education, the guide is intended to be used by those teaching in Catholic schools, as well as parents, students, teachers, members of the clergy and other relevant bodies.

“We are disappointed both with tone and timing of the release of this document, coming at the beginning of a month of celebration and positive visibility for the whole LGBTI+ community,” TENI chair Sara R. Phillips said.

“Unfortunately, the rhetoric we see in this document, including references to gender theory as aiming to ‘annihilate the concept of nature’, is consistent with previous inflammatory statements from this papacy, which has compared the impact of so-called ‘gender theory’ with the destruction caused by nuclear arms.”

The 30-page document criticises the understanding that gender is not binary, stating that modern gender theory “denies the difference and reciprocity in nature of a man and a woman” and “envisages a society without sexual differences.”

It also calls for “peaceful dialogue” and for the education of young people so that “no one should suffer bullying, violence, insults or unjust discrimination” due to their differences.

"Essentially, this involves educating for active and responsible citizenship, which is marked by the ability to welcome all legitimate expressions of human personhood with respect."

This latest guidance from the Vatican “contradicts” the Gender Recognition Act, which gives those over the age of 18 the legal right to have their preferred gender recognised, according to TENI chief executive Stephen O’Hare.

“The formulation of this document seems to have been put together in consultation with a range of theologians and experts in canon law, who you would expect to be working within the sphere of the Vatican,” Mr O’Hare said. “But it doesn’t seem that any medical doctors, psychologists were consulted, any member of the LGBT community or indeed any schools.

“We would have good relations with many schools, who work to support students in the best possible way.”

“Our concern is that this document, if it is influential, would be influential in a negative way," he said, adding that "TENI believes dialogue is the best way forward, not to dismiss the identity of trans and intersex students."

More on this topic

Colm O'Regan: Maths - What do you think of when you see the word?Colm O'Regan: Maths - What do you think of when you see the word?

Former UCD president calls Brexit a 'national crisis' regards higher educationFormer UCD president calls Brexit a 'national crisis' regards higher education

Reaching out: Tabor Lodge's Sr Margaret Kiely is still giving back in her 80sReaching out: Tabor Lodge's Sr Margaret Kiely is still giving back in her 80s

Call for probe into allegations that special education resources mis-used Call for probe into allegations that special education resources mis-used


More in this Section

Study finds sons stay at home longer than daughters, costing parents thousands extraStudy finds sons stay at home longer than daughters, costing parents thousands extra

Mental Health Commission identifies 12 areas of high-risk non-compliance in three centresMental Health Commission identifies 12 areas of high-risk non-compliance in three centres

Number of religious marriages in Ireland drops for fourth year in a rowNumber of religious marriages in Ireland drops for fourth year in a row

Angry scenes outside Department of Agriculture ahead of first Beef Market Taskforce talksAngry scenes outside Department of Agriculture ahead of first Beef Market Taskforce talks


Lifestyle

Helen O’Callaghan says we are the least strict in all of Europe.Praise over punishment: Irish parents least strict in Europe - study

Kya deLongchamps detects a hint of rebellion behind the ritual of afternoon tea.Vintage View: English tradition of afternoon tea won't exit with Brexit

Friends and Young Offenders actors Shane Casey and Dominic MacHale speak to Pat Fitzpatrick about struggling to make it but why they are not seeking out fame.‘I was down to a euro’ - The Young Offenders actors tell of struggle to make it in acting

Gerry Fitzgerald runs Bandon Books Plus in Riverview Shopping Centre, Bandon, Co Cork.We Sell Books: Turning over a new leaf from bank to bookshop in Bandon

More From The Irish Examiner