Transport Minister moves to close legal loophole in drink-driving cases

Transport Minister moves to close legal loophole in drink-driving cases

Transport Minister Paschal Donohoe has today moved to close a legal loophole which it had been feared could cast doubt over drink driving cases in court.

New laws have been signed in to close a loophole which threatened to see hundreds of drink-driving prosecutions thrown out.

Transport Minister Paschal Donohoe said the emergency legislation was drawn up over legitimate fears that data from breath test machines was not lawful as it did not give a read-out in both Irish and English.

Transport Minister moves to close legal loophole in drink-driving cases

Mr Donohoe said the rules have been changed “in the interests of road safety” to allow the computer statements to be given in either language.

The technicality was exposed when 29-year-old Mihai Avadenei challenged why data on his breath sample from the Evidenzer machine in a Garda station was not in Irish.

The High Court ruled that under law it was not a valid piece of evidence unless it was bilingual, forcing the Transport Minister to take the emergency action.

“The advice of the Attorney General’s Office was sought in respect of the need for amending legislation on foot of the judgment in relation to the language of the forms produced by evidential breath testing machines in Garda stations,” Mr Donohoe said.

“In the interests of road safety, I have moved immediately to provide the new legislation deemed necessary regarding the form of the statements to be provided under section 13 of the Road Traffic Act 2010.”

Evidenzer is the machine used to take an alcohol reading on a driver’s breath after he or she is detained by gardaí.

Blood or urine samples can be also be taken and tested to give a more scientific reading but that requires a doctor to go to a Garda station within a specified time.

Mr Avadenei’s lawyers raised concerns about the Evidenzer printout being only in English when his case came before the District Court in Swords.

The judge supported the argument but asked the High Court to rule on the point of law regarding the Prescribed Form and Manner of Statements Regulations 2011.

Mr Donohoe said the revised legislation was how the law was intended to be read.

More on this topic

Just 9.2% of banned motorists surrender licenceJust 9.2% of banned motorists surrender licence

Over 600 arrested for drink-driving in FebruaryOver 600 arrested for drink-driving in February

Latest: Road safety campaigner calls on Finian McGrath to resign over drink-driving check criticismsLatest: Road safety campaigner calls on Finian McGrath to resign over drink-driving check criticisms

McGrath withdraws comments about gardaí politicising the new drink driving lawsMcGrath withdraws comments about gardaí politicising the new drink driving laws

More in this Section

The Lotto results are in...The Lotto results are in...

Flight diverts to Shannon with suspected fire on boardFlight diverts to Shannon with suspected fire on board

Irish tug sails over a third of the way to Canada to tow crippled cargo ship to safetyIrish tug sails over a third of the way to Canada to tow crippled cargo ship to safety

Two arrested in connection with murder of Malcolm McKeownTwo arrested in connection with murder of Malcolm McKeown


Lifestyle

It will be tricky trying to see everybody at the huge Stradbally event next weekend, so Ed Power selects the ones you definitely shouldn’t miss.10 must-see acts at Electric Picnic

Dawn Behan owns Woodbine Books in Kilcullen, Co. Kildare.We Sell Books: ‘It’s lovely to see you are doing something right’

It hasn’t been the ideal summer for observing the skies, but as we move into September we live in that almost annual hope of an Indian summer, writes Niall Smith.Skymatters: Enjoy the last of the summer stars and check out 'Vega'

Actually the lights were on when I got dressed this morning, says Luke Rix-Standing.11 things you’ll only know if you have no sense of style

More From The Irish Examiner