Taoiseach questioned over ownership of planned broadband network

The Taoiseach has been questioned over who will own a proposed three billion euro national broadband network.

Leo Varadkar faced questions over the National Broadband Plan from both Fianna Fáil leader Micheal Martin and Sinn Féin chief Mary Lou McDonald during Leaders’ Questions in the Dáil on Wednesday.

Only one bidder remains in the process for the contract to deliver high-speed broadband to more than 540,000 homes across the country.

Mary Lou McDonald questions Leo Varadkar on the cost of the proposed National Broadband Plan (Oireachtas/PA)

Mr Martin queried who will own the new network when it is complete.

Mr Varadkar said that under the proposed contract terms the contractor is to build the network, operate the network, maintain the network and manage the network for 25 years.

“At that point Government has the option to buy, as it is not a commercial piece of infrastructure, one would expect that to be a relatively inexpensive proposition, and at any point if the contractor fails to deliver, the Government can step in and take over,” the Taoiseach told the Dáil.

The next step will be for the Government to make a decision on whether to accept a bid and designate a prepared bidder.

“That has not yet been done. I anticipate that can be done in the next couple of weeks.”

Mr Martin responded: “For the taxpayer to be spending three billion euro and not owning or having any prospect of owning at the end is something that needs to be fully explained,” he said.

“I find it very difficult to comprehend.”

Leo Varadkar defends plans for his Government’s National Broadband plan (Oireachtas/PA)

Ms McDonald put it to the Taoiseach that the process surrounding the National Broadband Plan was becoming reminiscent of the “debacle” that surrounds the spiralling costs of the new National Children’s Hospital.

“The aim of the National Broadband Plan has not changed, but what has changed incredibly is its cost. It’s now going to cost six times what was expected.

“The overspend here could run into billions of euros, and to top it all you advise us that the infrastructure would be in the ownership of the consortium but that the state could, 25 years on, spend more public money to buy that infrastructure back.

“It’s utterly ludicrous.”

It is a major project, possibly the biggest investment ever in rural Ireland ... it is not going to be done cheaply and it's not going to be done quickly

Mr Varadkar responded: “Minister (Pat) Rabbitte in 2014 gave an estimate of this project costing up to €512m specifically, that was for extending high-speed broadband to 1,100 villages in Ireland, not from there onwards to every home and business in Ireland.

“But we shouldn’t forget what this is about – this programme is about extending high speed broadband to over half a million homes, farms and businesses across the country.

“It is a major project, possibly the biggest investment ever in rural Ireland, possibly as important as rural electrification; it is not going to be done cheaply and it’s not going to be done quickly.

“Bear in mind the amount of investment that has gone into roads in the past 20 years, €40bn, the amount of investment that has gone into water in the past 20 years, €10bn.

“Building infrastructure like this, connecting homes, farms and businesses all over the country, is going to be expensive.”

- Press Association

More on this topic

Taoiseach denies broadband cost has risen to €3bn

National Broadband Plan could cost €3bn, says Varadkar

Bruton to recommend Govt back final bidder in National Broadband Plan

National broadband plan may be scrapped as all options remain on the table, PAC hears

More in this Section

Man pleads guilty to burglary and assault charges

‘Lock me up, I won’t do community service’

The Lotto results are in...

McDonald and Foster 'ready' for restored Assembly following challenge at Lyra McKee funeral


Lifestyle

Design/life: Aileen Lee profiles Andrew Pain of Black Hen Designs

Learning Points: School bullies grow up to be work bullies

Another day, another new label - will we ever reach ‘peak gin’?

Paul Linehan on his favourite books, music and the best gig he ever went to

More From The Irish Examiner