Supreme Court grants man's appeal over week-long contempt sentence

Supreme Court grants man's appeal over week-long contempt sentence

A five-judge Supreme Court has unanimously granted a man's appeal over being jailed for a week for contempt by a District Court judge.

The judgments of Mr Justice Donal O'Donnell and Mr Justice William McKechnie in the successful appeal by Kevin Tracey, and an unsuccessful separate appeal by another man, clarify issues concerning the courts' approach to contempt and disruptive behaviour in court.

The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission had submitted the finding of contempt against Mr Tracey, who represented himself, breached his rights.

Mr Tracey was jailed arising from comments he made when his case, involving a charge of driving without due care and attention, was mentioned before the District Court on May 31, 2006 for the purpose of fixing a hearing date.

Mr Tracey made comments including "how crooked? And you think you will get away with this? How crooked you are" which, he claimed, were directed to a Garda after the District Judge refused to allow Mr Tracey to read a statement to the court.

As a result of the comments, the District judge directed Mr Tracey be brought back before him and jailed him for contempt.

In his Supreme Court judgment today, Mr Justice O'Donnell noted Mr Tracey believes he has been a subject of "victimisation" by the legal system, dating back to a civil dispute he had with a neighbour who is a judge.

In this particular case, Mr Tracey had no right to demand to make a statement to the District Court, no right to persist in attempting to do so and no right to make allegations against the gardai, "if they were indeed the object of his comments", on the occasion in question.

However, when the District Judge ordered Mr Tracey be brought back before him, the situation changed since it was now possible punishment could be imposed, he said.

That meant "more elaborate" procedures were called for. Mr Tracey was entitled to have a separate hearing, the possibility of getting legal assistance and, if appropriate, legal aid, and should be told of his entitlements in that regard.

Given the importance of fair procedures and the constitutional value of personal liberty, the committal order would be quashed, he ruled. His judgment was endorsed by three other judges.

In a separate judgment, Mr Justice McKechnie expressed "grave reservations" about the bona fides of Mr Tracey at the District Court. However, because he could not be sure the "appropriate" level of fair procedures were afforded, he "most reluctantly" would also allow the appeal.

When Mr Tracey then raised the issue of damages, he was told those would have to be sought in separate proceedings.

The court dismissed a separate appeal raising similar issues brought by David Walsh arising from a hearing at Waterford Circuit Court on May 31st 2016 which, among a list of cases, dealt with possession proceedings concerning his sister Feana.

Due to Mr Walsh's behaviour and constant interruptions, an order was made to jail him for two weeks for contempt. He was freed two days later by the High Court but the Court of Appeal in March 2017 reversed that High Court ruling after which the Supreme Court agreed to hear a further appeal.

Mr Justice O’Donnell said every court that had addressed this matter had concluded the "utterly unacceptable" conduct amounted to contempt. This matter would never have reached the stage of contempt had Mr Walsh been willing to accept, even at a late stage, he was wrong and must accept the rulings of the trial judge, he said.

For reasons including, when the question of imprisonment was raised, Mr Walsh was told of his entitlement to legal aid and given "ample opportunity" to address the issue, fair procedures were complied with and no injustice was done to Mr Walsh, he ruled.

After expressing hope the matter could be resolved without Mr Walsh spending any further time in prison, the court will hear submissions at a later date as to the form of order to be made.

More on this topic

Burglar who shook hands with victim before being helped from his house gets two years in prisonBurglar who shook hands with victim before being helped from his house gets two years in prison

High Court clears way for man accused of sexually abusing 8-yr-old relative over 50 years ago to go to trialHigh Court clears way for man accused of sexually abusing 8-yr-old relative over 50 years ago to go to trial

Appeal court upholds three year clean up order for illegal “Kafkaesque” dump in WicklowAppeal court upholds three year clean up order for illegal “Kafkaesque” dump in Wicklow

Woman tells court “I don’t believe I was sober enough to give consent' as friend reveals she heard moaning during alleged rapes Woman tells court “I don’t believe I was sober enough to give consent" as friend reveals she heard moaning during alleged rapes


More in this Section

Deal creating EU border in Irish Sea closerDeal creating EU border in Irish Sea closer

The key players in the UK’s hunt for a Brexit dealThe key players in the UK’s hunt for a Brexit deal

Talk of Northern Ireland-only backstop off the mark – Arlene FosterTalk of Northern Ireland-only backstop off the mark – Arlene Foster

Limerick IT and Athlone IT forming consortium to develop Technological UniversityLimerick IT and Athlone IT forming consortium to develop Technological University


Lifestyle

We know porridge is one of the best ways to start the day but being virtuous day in, day out can be boring.The Shape I'm In: Food blogger Indy Power

Sheila O’Flanagan can’t pin down an exact number of books she has written.First lady of fiction: Sheila O'Flanagan is happy to be accessible

This might not be the most entertaining topic but it is that time of year when colds, flus and nasty bugs enter classrooms and homes.Mum's the Word: Top tips for keeping nasty bugs and illnesses at bay

Laura Whalen is a Munster-based dollmaker and mother-of-five, and the founder of the Bábóg project, a community crafting drive to make a commemorative doll for all the babies born in Irish mother and baby homes.Made in Munster: Meet the West Cork dollmaker who uses bio-degradable materials for her craft

More From The Irish Examiner