Simon Coveney: Government has nothing to hide in relation to broadband plan costs

Simon Coveney: Government has nothing to hide in relation to broadband plan costs
Simon Coveney speaking at the Community Centre, Castletownroche, Co Cork today. Picture: Dan Linehan

The government has nothing to hide in relation to the €3bn National Broadband Plan and will explain its decision and the project costs in due course, the Tánaiste says.

Simon Coveney has also challenged critics of the plan - branded by the opposition as “the worst deal ever seen” after it emerged that the selected private operator will own a €3bn asset despite investing just €200m in the scheme - to show how they could deliver high-speed broadband to rural Ireland cheaper and more effectively.

He was speaking after attending a government rural funding roadshow in North Cork today with Minister for Rural and Community Development, Michael Ring, and the Minister for Business, Enterprise and Innovation, Heather Humphreys.

Mr Ring, who was in Castletownroche for his department’s fifth Rural Opportunity event flagging the range of funding and supports available to rural communities, said broadband is raised at every single meeting he attends in rural Ireland.

“Seventy years ago, they were talking about rural electrification. The same people were saying we shouldn’t put it into every house. Broadband is the new electricity,” he said.

Mr Coveney said the government has debated the issue for a decade amid claims that a “silver bullet” technology solution would emerge, and following a “very active and challenging debate” within Government, the time had come for a decision with full knowledge of the costs.

“We have made a political decision which I believe to be the right one. We are going to leave no home, no business, no farm, no person behind," he said.

Yes it’s expensive, but I would challenge the critics to show how this can be done more cheaply or more effectively.

“In 20 years, in 10 years, people will be asking how could we ever have thought that not rolling out fibre to every home could have been acceptable across Irish society.”

He also dismissed suggestions that Fine Gael’s handling of this deal, on the back of the National Childrens’ Hospital costs controversy, has damaged its image as a party of strong fiscal control.

Decisions on the hospital project were based on incorrect cost estimates whereas decisions on the broadband deal were made based on full cost information, he said.

“Repeatedly we have shown that when others have, through policy mistakes, destroyed and undermined an economy, we have been put into Government to fix a broken economy, and we have done that over the past eight or nine years,” he said.

“Fine Gael is a party of prudence and responsible economic management. But we are also a party of big ideas. We are a party that is planning 20 years ahead.”

Today’s event heard how the government has allocated some €138.4m to rural programmes and schemes this year alone.

It heard from several speakers how such funding has helped them deliver projects that benefited their communities, including the Charlie Chaplin Comedy Festival in Waterville and the Banteer Community Sportsfield project.

Colm Murphy, the CEO of Firebird Heating Solutions, said his company, which employs 150 people, has thrived in a rural area thanks to research, development and innovation supports from Údarás na Gaeltachta.

More on this topic

Group tells Oireachtas committee it could deliver National Broadband Plan for €402mGroup tells Oireachtas committee it could deliver National Broadband Plan for €402m

Broadband monopoly in rural areas ‘very likely’, committee hearsBroadband monopoly in rural areas ‘very likely’, committee hears

Accepting Eir broadband offer ‘would be illegal’Accepting Eir broadband offer ‘would be illegal’

Eir's broadband proposal has to be considered, says FFEir's broadband proposal has to be considered, says FF

More in this Section

'I visit her grave every day': Santina Cawley's mum heartbroken at thought of life her daughter won't get to live 'I visit her grave every day': Santina Cawley's mum heartbroken at thought of life her daughter won't get to live

Eamon Ryan would be open to Green Party going into GovernmentEamon Ryan would be open to Green Party going into Government

Grieve accuses Johnson of Brexit ‘radicalisation’ over Irish backstopGrieve accuses Johnson of Brexit ‘radicalisation’ over Irish backstop

Dad of gifted student with special needs appeals for 'invaluable' resource class to stay openDad of gifted student with special needs appeals for 'invaluable' resource class to stay open


Lifestyle

Skincare guru Dr Raj Arora explains how this cleansing technique can make a big difference.Why you should follow the 60 second rule when washing your face, according to an expert

Karen Murray visited the island which is the smallest country in EU.Malta proves the best things come in small packages

It will be 40 years next month since the death of JG Farrell.Paying tribute to Booker Prize winner who drowned in West Cork 40 years ago

It’s called Kunfunadhoo and we really don’t understand why we’re not there right now.Take a look at the idyllic Maldives island where Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas are honeymooning

More From The Irish Examiner